Staff friendly, drinks delicious and the food... Well the food was delicious, with reasonable portions and brought out hot. Fresh and crispy greens on the side. Red snapper tostadas were amazing and the crab cakes the perfect app
Elizabeth Jolly-Haslitt
We did the tasting menu for my birthday. Wish I could rate it higher than 5 stars. Totally unpretentious vibes, just classic Wisconsin. The food is out. of. this. world. Some classic pairings/dishes with a bit of a twist - emphasis on local and seasonal flavors. My favorites were the herby nutty hollandaise based dressing on a charred/grilled romaine and a mahi mahi with chicken fried rice and carrot ginger purée. Chef Curt is also just fantastic to talk to - laid back, funny, so knowledgeable and talented. Staff was amazing. On the higher price end but worth every penny.
julie gordon
Amazing food and cocktails! Can’t wait to go back 🥰
Melissa Hammer
I’d give this place an 11 if I could. Outstanding. Food was delicious and top quality. It came out quick and steaming hot. Atmosphere is very chill, love it. Highly recommend
Dale Posvic
We stopped in on a Saturday night after hearing about it at a fundraiser a few weeks before. We didn't realize we needed reservations but they squeezed us in 40 minutes later. My ribeye and my wife's scallops were both amazing. The bartender and waitresses were very accommodating. We will absolutely be back to try other entrees. The chicken dish looked really good when it came out for somebody else. Thank you for a great meal and drinks.
Kathleen Murphy
If you haven’t eaten here yet you need to! The steak was amazing. It had a nice crispy sear and was perfectly cooked inside and warm. The cheese mashed potatoes are so smooth and creamy. The lobster risotto was the best I’ve ever had. We also had the Calamari and Crab Cakes. Both were amazing. Definitely would come back.
Chris Graham
We love Archie’s the food is outstanding! Bartenders are wonderful. Only complaint was our waitress. Made inquiry about one of the dishes on the menu that stated it had lobster and seafood. We asked what the other seafood was and she she said “it has seafood things” we politely asked if she could could find out for us while she put in our appetizer order what the other seafood was, she returns and stated what the seafood was but couldn’t remember what some of what the chef said. Not the end of the world and yes we have a great sense of humor so we got a a little laugh out of that. Having been a waitress it is their job to know the menu and ingredient’s especially when you are paying those prices.
Other than that everything was fabulous
Mary Schultz
We were not familiar with the area and stopped by thinking it was a friendly neighborhood bar. Instead, we were told that we had to have reservations and we couldn't even sit at the bar. Needless to say, we left.
Eric Fleming
Great food in a cozy settings. Reservations are a must!
Elisabeth Moy
Wow!!! 🤩 10/10 for food! I went with a couple friends and we all tried each other’s meals… each one exceeded expectations!!! We also had appetizers and desserts and drinks and were just blown away! I will be coming back!
Country bar vibe with high quality food!!! Show up as you are but enjoy impeccable cuisine!
We’ve been there 3 times now and haven’t been let down once! Make a reservation as seating is limited! But the food is absolutely delicious and at a fair price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kayla Koch
What a fun Wisconsin night out. Love the vibe, great drinks and conversation from bartender Jason, creative menu. We tried the Calamari, lobster risotto, and feature monkfish. We will be back!
Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp in the second entry, easy access from parking lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Selle
If you are unsure, just order something. I am a total good snob and I can honestly say my only complaint is I couldn’t eat it all! This place is simple and a bar vibe with the most amazing food coming out of the kitchen.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dave Elsen
Love Archie’s. It’s a hidden gem off the beaten path. Chef Curt rocks. He has a wonderful menu. I’m partial to the Pan Seared Ribeye and Macadamia Nut Crusted Walleye. It’s a quaint little country bar that has been transformed into an experience that’s certainly worth a visit.
It does get a bit busy at times, so I’d recommend having a reservation.
If the parking lot is full, we park across the road in the church lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Melissa Helf
Dive bar with gourmet food - you will definitely want to make a reservation as they have limited seating, and the word has gotten it about how great the place is.
Staff friendly, drinks delicious and the food... Well the food was delicious, with reasonable portions and brought out hot. Fresh and crispy greens on the side. Red snapper tostadas were amazing and the crab cakes the perfect app
We did the tasting menu for my birthday. Wish I could rate it higher than 5 stars. Totally unpretentious vibes, just classic Wisconsin. The food is out. of. this. world. Some classic pairings/dishes with a bit of a twist - emphasis on local and seasonal flavors. My favorites were the herby nutty hollandaise based dressing on a charred/grilled romaine and a mahi mahi with chicken fried rice and carrot ginger purée. Chef Curt is also just fantastic to talk to - laid back, funny, so knowledgeable and talented. Staff was amazing. On the higher price end but worth every penny.
Amazing food and cocktails! Can’t wait to go back 🥰
I’d give this place an 11 if I could. Outstanding.
Food was delicious and top quality. It came out quick and steaming hot. Atmosphere is very chill, love it. Highly recommend
We stopped in on a Saturday night after hearing about it at a fundraiser a few weeks before. We didn't realize we needed reservations but they squeezed us in 40 minutes later. My ribeye and my wife's scallops were both amazing. The bartender and waitresses were very accommodating. We will absolutely be back to try other entrees. The chicken dish looked really good when it came out for somebody else. Thank you for a great meal and drinks.
If you haven’t eaten here yet you need to! The steak was amazing. It had a nice crispy sear and was perfectly cooked inside and warm. The cheese mashed potatoes are so smooth and creamy. The lobster risotto was the best I’ve ever had. We also had the Calamari and Crab Cakes. Both were amazing. Definitely would come back.
We love Archie’s the food is outstanding! Bartenders are wonderful. Only complaint was our waitress. Made inquiry about one of the dishes on the menu that stated it had lobster and seafood. We asked what the other seafood was and she she said “it has seafood things” we politely asked if she could could find out for us while she put in our appetizer order what the other seafood was, she returns and stated what the seafood was but couldn’t remember what some of what the chef said. Not the end of the world and yes we have a great sense of humor so we got a a little laugh out of that. Having been a waitress it is their job to know the menu and ingredient’s especially when you are paying those prices.
Other than that everything was fabulous
We were not familiar with the area and stopped by thinking it was a friendly neighborhood bar.
Instead, we were told that we had to have reservations and we couldn't even sit at the bar.
Needless to say, we left.
Great food in a cozy settings. Reservations are a must!
Wow!!! 🤩 10/10 for food! I went with a couple friends and we all tried each other’s meals… each one exceeded expectations!!! We also had appetizers and desserts and drinks and were just blown away! I will be coming back!
Country bar vibe with high quality food!!! Show up as you are but enjoy impeccable cuisine!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We’ve been there 3 times now and haven’t been let down once! Make a reservation as seating is limited! But the food is absolutely delicious and at a fair price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a fun Wisconsin night out. Love the vibe, great drinks and conversation from bartender Jason, creative menu. We tried the Calamari, lobster risotto, and feature monkfish. We will be back!
Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp in the second entry, easy access from parking lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you are unsure, just order something. I am a total good snob and I can honestly say my only complaint is I couldn’t eat it all!
This place is simple and a bar vibe with the most amazing food coming out of the kitchen.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love Archie’s. It’s a hidden gem off the beaten path. Chef Curt rocks. He has a wonderful menu. I’m partial to the Pan Seared Ribeye and Macadamia Nut Crusted Walleye. It’s a quaint little country bar that has been transformed into an experience that’s certainly worth a visit.
It does get a bit busy at times, so I’d recommend having a reservation.
If the parking lot is full, we park across the road in the church lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Dive bar with gourmet food - you will definitely want to make a reservation as they have limited seating, and the word has gotten it about how great the place is.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...