Best pizza I have had in Wisconsin by a long shot. Would highly recommend making the drive to try this pizza. The service was great, the atmosphere was great and the pizza was great. Top notch place, definitely returning to try the rest of the pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
Greg Lawler
Great Pizza and service. Fire baked pizza. Really good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Lori Richardt
What a hidden gem! Stopped in on my way back from GB...have been wanting to try it out for some time now and WOW! they did not disappoint! Large variety of ingredients available and quite the cool imagination in Ross and his "Special" creations! I am a red sauce snob and asked for extra sauce.... Again... fabulous!!! Like no other!After reading other reviews I do have to say... You have to remember that wood fired pizzas are very different from your Americanized pizza. Fresh ingredients and special ingredients are supposed to be a treat when you get a bite of it...not smothered like many are use to. Give it a try! I will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jordan Sargent
Pizza is pretty good. Just kidding! It is the best stop between Green Bay and Door County…They do a fantastic job! Stayed at their motel across the street! The views are amazing, can’t say enough! Welcome to Dyckesville!! It should stop at the Next Door Pizza joint in town! Amazing!
Ross VanGompel
It's always an amazing experience at the Next Door Pizza Co! Incredible pizza at great prices, and always a fun and warming atmosphere! I highly recommend it to everyone who loves hand-streched pizza with the freshest ingredients!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Bruschetta
Joseph
I ordered the Margherita Pizza and it was excellent. Savory fresh tasting sauce, perfect dough, and all around a tasty pizza. The staff were excellent and polite. 10/10 recommend to anybody looking for some pizza. Will most definitely eat here again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Miriam Stocking
Two of us went on a Saturday night around 5:00. Ordering is at a counter and then seating yourself. The seating area is extremely clean and inviting. Cute booths on the side, though not especially comfortable wood benches for the booth seating. Still they were clean snd had ample room.We ordered 2 pizzas, a bruschetta appetizer and a Caesar salad to share, as well as 2 cans of a specialty lemonade (non alcoholic) our bill came to $52 before tip.The bruschetta came out first and was 4 rounds of a crusty baguette style bread with seasoned tomato drizzled with balsamic. Though it was very tasty, it seemed over priced for what you got.Our pizzas took probably another 20 minutes to arrive and came out together. The salad was the odd thing in that it didn’t arrive until 1/2 way through our pizzas being finished.Though I’m sure they had takeout orders being prepared, we were the only two people in the restaurant, and since I was seated where I could see the order counter I can honestly say no more than 1 or 2 people came in the entire time we were seated. So for a basic salad to take that long to arrive was a bit puzzling.The salad was fresh, though very basic and came with a single heated breadstick. The breadstick tasted a day old , reheated and store bought . Absolutely nothing special. The salad was large enough to share (we got a small one) so that was nice.The pizzas were just ok. The ingredients seemed fresh and the sauce was tasty. The crust had a nice bite and a good chew, but was rather flavorless. The margharitta needed a bit more cheese. Some slices had no cheese dollop at all (see attached photo)The vegetarian was flavorful and had adequate toppings, but the crust got soggy before the pizza could be finished.We had hoped to find a hidden gem not too far from Green Bay, but were disappointed it’s just OK.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Jacob Frye
Excellent Wood Fire Pizza. Reasonable priced.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Geoff H.
- CLOSED - Left the west side of Green Bay for a 30 min drive to try a new pizza place. Upon arriving, the place was dark and closed. Turned around to drive 30 minutes back. A waste of time and very disappointing.
Harvey Pokorny
Vegetarian options: Spinach salad top notch! Plenty of veggie options for pizza.
Excellent pizza, an interesting menu of pizzas and salads -- with a fresh and healthy tone. Friendly service, casual ambience. We were delighted to discover Next Door Pizza on a recent trip to the Door County/Green Bay area. We went back twice in the week we were there.
Carla Martin
The artisan pizza was delicious. Service was great and I will definitely be enjoying their pizza again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Debra Gagner
We are from Deerfield wis and this place is amazing . Very friendly staff and owner . Hope to be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Scott Schmitt
Cute place, but.... When I ordered (2 pizzas) cashier stated 30 min for the food to be ready, 50 min later, still did not get our food. Went to ask where our food was, the guy making the food stated he was working on it and it would be another 10 min. 10 min go by no pizza, but they did bring comprementy bread sticks. At about 60min we got one pizza. And about 5 min later got our other pizza. The pizza was ok, pretty sparse on the topping. Very disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Kolton DeJardin
As a person who's gone here many times I can gladly say this pizza is amazing the flavors are there, the toppings and everything tastes fresh and it's overall a great environment,worth the wait!
Best pizza I have had in Wisconsin by a long shot. Would highly recommend making the drive to try this pizza. The service was great, the atmosphere was great and the pizza was great. Top notch place, definitely returning to try the rest of the pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
Great Pizza and service. Fire baked pizza. Really good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
What a hidden gem! Stopped in on my way back from GB...have been wanting to try it out for some time now and WOW! they did not disappoint! Large variety of ingredients available and quite the cool imagination in Ross and his "Special" creations! I am a red sauce snob and asked for extra sauce.... Again... fabulous!!! Like no other!After reading other reviews I do have to say... You have to remember that wood fired pizzas are very different from your Americanized pizza. Fresh ingredients and special ingredients are supposed to be a treat when you get a bite of it...not smothered like many are use to. Give it a try! I will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is pretty good. Just kidding! It is the best stop between Green Bay and Door County…They do a fantastic job! Stayed at their motel across the street! The views are amazing, can’t say enough! Welcome to Dyckesville!! It should stop at the Next Door Pizza joint in town! Amazing!
It's always an amazing experience at the Next Door Pizza Co! Incredible pizza at great prices, and always a fun and warming atmosphere! I highly recommend it to everyone who loves hand-streched pizza with the freshest ingredients!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Bruschetta
I ordered the Margherita Pizza and it was excellent. Savory fresh tasting sauce, perfect dough, and all around a tasty pizza. The staff were excellent and polite. 10/10 recommend to anybody looking for some pizza. Will most definitely eat here again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Two of us went on a Saturday night around 5:00. Ordering is at a counter and then seating yourself. The seating area is extremely clean and inviting. Cute booths on the side, though not especially comfortable wood benches for the booth seating. Still they were clean snd had ample room.We ordered 2 pizzas, a bruschetta appetizer and a Caesar salad to share, as well as 2 cans of a specialty lemonade (non alcoholic) our bill came to $52 before tip.The bruschetta came out first and was 4 rounds of a crusty baguette style bread with seasoned tomato drizzled with balsamic. Though it was very tasty, it seemed over priced for what you got.Our pizzas took probably another 20 minutes to arrive and came out together. The salad was the odd thing in that it didn’t arrive until 1/2 way through our pizzas being finished.Though I’m sure they had takeout orders being prepared, we were the only two people in the restaurant, and since I was seated where I could see the order counter I can honestly say no more than 1 or 2 people came in the entire time we were seated. So for a basic salad to take that long to arrive was a bit puzzling.The salad was fresh, though very basic and came with a single heated breadstick. The breadstick tasted a day old , reheated and store bought . Absolutely nothing special. The salad was large enough to share (we got a small one) so that was nice.The pizzas were just ok. The ingredients seemed fresh and the sauce was tasty. The crust had a nice bite and a good chew, but was rather flavorless. The margharitta needed a bit more cheese. Some slices had no cheese dollop at all (see attached photo)The vegetarian was flavorful and had adequate toppings, but the crust got soggy before the pizza could be finished.We had hoped to find a hidden gem not too far from Green Bay, but were disappointed it’s just OK.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Excellent Wood Fire Pizza. Reasonable priced.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
- CLOSED - Left the west side of Green Bay for a 30 min drive to try a new pizza place. Upon arriving, the place was dark and closed. Turned around to drive 30 minutes back. A waste of time and very disappointing.
Vegetarian options: Spinach salad top notch! Plenty of veggie options for pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent pizza, an interesting menu of pizzas and salads -- with a fresh and healthy tone. Friendly service, casual ambience. We were delighted to discover Next Door Pizza on a recent trip to the Door County/Green Bay area. We went back twice in the week we were there.
The artisan pizza was delicious. Service was great and I will definitely be enjoying their pizza again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We are from Deerfield wis and this place is amazing . Very friendly staff and owner . Hope to be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Cute place, but.... When I ordered (2 pizzas) cashier stated 30 min for the food to be ready, 50 min later, still did not get our food. Went to ask where our food was, the guy making the food stated he was working on it and it would be another 10 min. 10 min go by no pizza, but they did bring comprementy bread sticks. At about 60min we got one pizza. And about 5 min later got our other pizza. The pizza was ok, pretty sparse on the topping. Very disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza
As a person who's gone here many times I can gladly say this pizza is amazing the flavors are there, the toppings and everything tastes fresh and it's overall a great environment,worth the wait!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza