On a Whim Sweet Treats Bakery

Erin was a pleasure to work with for my wedding day desserts. She was very flexible when it came to a tasting, altering our order, and determining a delivery and set-up plan. I was thrilled to find someone so talented and professional around my small town, so I wanted to make sure people know that Erin with On a Whim Sweets Treats is the real deal.

Everything was fresh and delicious. Also highly recommend cinnamon roll Saturdays!

Everything made here is absolutely delicious—from the cake-sized cinnamon rolls to the savory quiches. The shop has a quaint, cozy vibe, and the owners, a friendly husband-and-wife team, make you feel right at home. Their hours are limited, but that just adds to the charm—it feels like a hidden gem. Whether you’re local or just passing through, it’s definitely worth the stop. Headed to a game in Green Bay? Make a detour—you won’t regret it!

My husband stopped by - literally On A Whim - for treats this morning. What a lovely place with a wonderful employee. He picked a variety of goodies - and each was more delicious than the last! My kiddos loved their donuts and my husband and I both agree the Break Up Brownies are incredible!

Requested a custom cake for my daughters birthday and it turned out fabulous! Identical to the picture I sent. Everyone loved the design and how beautiful it was. The cake itself was very moist, fresh and delicious. On top of that, the owner is super sweet and friendly!!

Had my daughter’s birthday cake made from here. We requested strawberry cake and mermaid theme. As you can see it was stunning and the flavor was great, the cake was moist. I also tried her famous cinnamon rolls and blackberry danish. 10/10. Her store is very cute and welcoming as well. Definitely the best bakery I’ve found in the area.

Ordered a custom cake for my daughters 2nd birthday. Customer service was outstanding and the cake was delicious and reasonably priced.

The donuts are perfection! I've never had such delicious bakery in my life. It's the right amount of sweetness and flavor. Customer service was phenomenal as well. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for a small business bakery to shop!

Their bakery is to die for. Atmosphere delightful, as well as the owners. Quiche and coffee marvelous too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’d give 10 stars if I could!
Erin was great to work with and very responsive to my requests for a layered cake for a recent baby shower. Not only did it look perfect, it tasted amazing! When I picked up the cake it was hard to resist buying all the other treats in the display case.
Worth the trip for even a small delight. I will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beautiful bakery! Pumpkin spice iced chai is the best definitely a 10/10

This was my first time ordering a birthday cake and cupcakes from here. I sent them several photos of cakes and basically told them to take a little from each one and make something. They did a fantastic job, I would definitely recommend! I'll be ordering my other daughters birthday cake from here as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice little bakery! Was my first time going, but I had an absolutely delicious blackberry donut and a giant chocolate chip cookie sandwich. You can definitely tell everything is handmade with care. Next time I'm up that way I'd definitely go again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sweetest owner and amazing baked goods!

Erin went above and beyond for my children’s birthday cakes, they were beautiful!! She is so kind and easy to work with and the cake was delicious!