The Old Post Pub Steakhouse
S 1599, WI-42, Maplewood
(920) 856-6966
Recent Reviews
Sort by
S 1599, WI-42, Maplewood
(920) 856-6966
Good food!
Off the beaten path location, but great food and atmosphere. Definitely will be back. Scallops were delicious.
OMG the food and atmosphere are amazing, it just made it to the top of my list of places to eat, and I eat out a lot
The atmosphere was great, the hostess and our server were great as well. We had heard of the positive reviews from others and decided to try it for our Anniversary dinner. But..... maybe we hit an off night for the kitchen as the meals were sub par to say the least. Our server recommended the bacon wrapped scallops for an appetizer which were great, however we also tried the steamed clams which had a very fishy taste. The salads had a bitter and sour taste Our meals, Prime Ri
Brand new historic little out-of-the-way place. Glad we found it! Nice steak and THE BEST corn fritters and carrot cake ever! Together with great service (thanks Mallory)....hope to return soon.
Very nice atmosphere and the food was excellent! Defiantly will be returning.
New hidden gem of Door County. Great cocktails, respectable food, charming atmosphere. A new favorite of ours. Confidently recommend to others and excited to come back again.
Food was excellent. Our second visit; but 3rd and 4th and beyond in our future. Our server was Halley (sp) she is new; but you wouldn't know it. Excellent server; who lives just down the road. Don't lose her!!! Thanks to all for a great date night.
Food, staff, and atmosphere were excellent. Steak, seafood, drinks...were amazing. We WILL be back again!
Enjoyed the Post Office atmosphere when walking into the restaurant with my friends. We ordered the fish (perch) and the bacon wrapped scallops. Seven layer salad was good but the New England clam chowder was lacking the clam flavor. The perch was good but not great. My friend said the scallops were good.
Restaurantji Recommends
The food wasn't bad, but we waited for an hour and a half between the first course and the entree. We are willing to try again, but another service failure and they're done.
The food was fantastic wait staff was great
Excellent food with excellent service! I highly recommend.
Great perch. Good beer pricing
Great place to eat! Great service and very accommodating. I had the tenderloin medallions and they were prepared perfectly. The salad I selected was the 7 layer which was too much for me I will pick the small side salad next time.
Loading...