Nice, quiet eatery. Limited menu selection, but food is outstanding. Fresh, healthy, and very tasty. Eatery is in an organic health store but still quaint. Highly recommend, and I'm tough to please. Will be coming back for more.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dylan Pulvermacher
Excellent service, good selection, good food, very knowledgeable about products sold. The grill cheese sandwich with bacon is my favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rebecca Kurzendoerfer
Dietary restrictions: Many dishes can be prepared gluten free
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robin Bouton
Love this place. The owner is so knowledgeable and helpful. Atmosphere is charming. Must try shop!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Sara Heeringa
I only ate here once and made my decision to never eat there again. The store itself is very nice, however; I was extremely disappointed in the food I was served. The cook seems to not care at all. I was first impressed with the short menu because that usually means there is a limited number of high quality meals that are produced. This was definitely not the case. Also, there were no ingredients stated. What if someone has an allergy? As I waited it seemed like there was absolutely no communication among the 2 people working there. It was completely empty but there were a few carryout orders that were completed before mine. I ordered a smoked trout salad which sounded delicious. Upon receiving my meal the trout was ice cold which I wasn't expecting and the portion size couldn't have been over 3-4 ounces. There were microgreens that were so long with the stems it made it difficult to eat. The cucumbers were inedible. It looked like they had been presliced days ago. Nothing about this salad was fresh and that was the main reason I had tried this restaurant in the first place. It had to taken all of 2 minutes to put this together. The cook clearly has given up quality & elected to cut corners by serving the bare minimum. No points for flare. After I did eat some of my lunch I went somewhere else to get something to eat to make it through work. Very sad.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Kelli Iverson
The owners are so kind and helpful! They addressed all my questions with so much understanding of all the information including what is a plus for each brand of the same product to help make your choice easier. I absolutely love getting my natural and holistic items here!! I have not had anything to eat there yet but I can't imagine it's not awesome.
Kimberly Regner
What a hidden gem! This store has tons of healthy and holistic products that will keep you feeling your best! I haven’t tried the food but I’ve heard amazing things ?
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Nick Bodiu
CRAZY good food ,natural healthy products and atmosfere it's comforting here...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pat Kertzman
Delicious food, great people, cozy place to eat! Love the Natural Way! We’ve all eaten soups and salads in our lives, but not like Earl’s! Patty and Earl are fun to joke around with. My 92-year-old mother and I tease that we want to take Earl—the cook and Patty’s husband—home with us. Strangely, Patty doesn’t seem at all threatened, but Earl might be a little nervous! We visit there a few times a year because we see a great naturopathic doctor in Mayville, which is over an hours drive for us. Well worth the drive for both reasons!
Eva Billeb
As someone who understands the importance of eating organic, I really appreciate having a lovely place to eat like this. Yummy food and affordable!
Last weekend, Earl at The Natural Way created a Cheese and Charcuterie Board for a wedding reception cocktail hour. The presentation and variety of foods were delightful! Truly enjoyed by all. We also got 2 different soups and bread for the wedding party for lunch. So delicious! And Earl created a wonderful quinoa salad that really added a special touch to the catered reception meal. I can’t say enough good things about working with Earl and about the wonderful food he prepares. Mayville is so lucky to have your store and eatery there. Thank you so much!
carl sunsetfarms
Had a fantastic fresh & tasty meal catered at the catholic ecology center. My favorite was the rye revival bread with the sweet honey? butter. Would like more info on it please.
Tina Giese
Knowledgeable staff, great variety! Great place to find supplements vitamins and natural oils, plus a lot more.
Miranda Zuege
Finding healthy options in a small town is hard. I came in and asked if they could make something vegan. The hummus sandwich with fresh veggies and herbs was delicious! Thank you for accommodating my dietary preferences! This could be a happy accident to a new menu item.
Elizabeth OMalley
Great selection of products. Knowledgeable, helpful and caring owners!
Nice, quiet eatery. Limited menu selection, but food is outstanding. Fresh, healthy, and very tasty. Eatery is in an organic health store but still quaint. Highly recommend, and I'm tough to please. Will be coming back for more.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent service, good selection, good food, very knowledgeable about products sold. The grill cheese sandwich with bacon is my favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dietary restrictions: Many dishes can be prepared gluten free
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place. The owner is so knowledgeable and helpful. Atmosphere is charming. Must try shop!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
I only ate here once and made my decision to never eat there again. The store itself is very nice, however; I was extremely disappointed in the food I was served. The cook seems to not care at all. I was first impressed with the short menu because that usually means there is a limited number of high quality meals that are produced. This was definitely not the case. Also, there were no ingredients stated. What if someone has an allergy? As I waited it seemed like there was absolutely no communication among the 2 people working there. It was completely empty but there were a few carryout orders that were completed before mine. I ordered a smoked trout salad which sounded delicious. Upon receiving my meal the trout was ice cold which I wasn't expecting and the portion size couldn't have been over 3-4 ounces. There were microgreens that were so long with the stems it made it difficult to eat. The cucumbers were inedible. It looked like they had been presliced days ago. Nothing about this salad was fresh and that was the main reason I had tried this restaurant in the first place. It had to taken all of 2 minutes to put this together. The cook clearly has given up quality & elected to cut corners by serving the bare minimum. No points for flare. After I did eat some of my lunch I went somewhere else to get something to eat to make it through work. Very sad.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
The owners are so kind and helpful! They addressed all my questions with so much understanding of all the information including what is a plus for each brand of the same product to help make your choice easier. I absolutely love getting my natural and holistic items here!! I have not had anything to eat there yet but I can't imagine it's not awesome.
What a hidden gem! This store has tons of healthy and holistic products that will keep you feeling your best! I haven’t tried the food but I’ve heard amazing things ?
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
CRAZY good food ,natural healthy products and atmosfere it's comforting here...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious food, great people, cozy place to eat! Love the Natural Way! We’ve all eaten soups and salads in our lives, but not like Earl’s! Patty and Earl are fun to joke around with. My 92-year-old mother and I tease that we want to take Earl—the cook and Patty’s husband—home with us. Strangely, Patty doesn’t seem at all threatened, but Earl might be a little nervous! We visit there a few times a year because we see a great naturopathic doctor in Mayville, which is over an hours drive for us. Well worth the drive for both reasons!
As someone who understands the importance of eating organic, I really appreciate having a lovely place to eat like this. Yummy food and affordable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Last weekend, Earl at The Natural Way created a Cheese and Charcuterie Board for a wedding reception cocktail hour. The presentation and variety of foods were delightful! Truly enjoyed by all. We also got 2 different soups and bread for the wedding party for lunch. So delicious! And Earl created a wonderful quinoa salad that really added a special touch to the catered reception meal. I can’t say enough good things about working with Earl and about the wonderful food he prepares. Mayville is so lucky to have your store and eatery there. Thank you so much!
Had a fantastic fresh & tasty meal catered at the catholic ecology center. My favorite was the rye revival bread with the sweet honey? butter. Would like more info on it please.
Knowledgeable staff, great variety! Great place to find supplements vitamins and natural oils, plus a lot more.
Finding healthy options in a small town is hard. I came in and asked if they could make something vegan. The hummus sandwich with fresh veggies and herbs was delicious! Thank you for accommodating my dietary preferences! This could be a happy accident to a new menu item.
Great selection of products. Knowledgeable, helpful and caring owners!