Great place for our work Christmas party! Loved the atmosphere and decor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dixie
There was a buffet with several meat and vegetable options as well as salad and homemade rolls and ? desserts. It was wonderful. The building is an old mill and very quaint with a gift shop with homemade home goods and jellies and jams. Atmosphere is fantastic, service excellent. Highly recommend The Old Feed Mill.
Mary Neuhaus
The Thanksgiving buffet seating @3:30 was a disappointment. We were seated up stairs in a lone corner. Butter, salad dressing, and turkey were in short supply. We could not tell what a couple of the items were on the buffet. Desserts had been sitting out to long & were dried out. Cannot recommend..doesn't live up to past billing.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Janet Tegtmeier
The Thanksgiving Buffet was so delicious! Everyone was friendly, attentive, and focused on ensuring that all guests enjoyed themselves. The atmosphere is cozy, warm, and welcoming. A perfect way to centenary the holiday without the stress!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Pudding
Rachel A.
Unassuming yet quite delightful is how I'd describe this place. The menu may not look overtly impressive, but the food was well cooked and most enjoyable. Within easy walking distance of the Iron Amethyst Inn, this was an ideal location to relax and eat well cooked fair that pleased the palette and soothed the soul. We were served on both nights by Aliyah who made us feel very welcome with her prompt service and happy demeanor. The prices felt reasonable and at no time did we feel anything except happy we'd picked the Inn to eat at. If you're in the area I feel you can't go far wrong eating here. And after you've eaten, the gift shop beckons!
Kari Kiefer
Absolutely wonderful place and price was food was amazing! Buffet Style with many options! Employees were very welcoming.From me being an out a Stater, my experience was awesome! Thank u❣️
Troy Baumann
5:30 reservation for dinner and didn't receive entrees until 7:15. Late for American Players Theater. Lots of apologies but no action. Will not return.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Ron Rowden
The Buffet was remarkable and affordable. We are definitely going back again.
Pretentious, nasty old lady with condescending attitude. Have been there in a long time, overpriced and unimaginative.
Bill R.
Dinner was so good a week ago we decided to come back for the Sunday brunch. Met one of our families after church and really had a wonderful experience. The brunch was a little limited but everything on it was delicious. We started with salads, fruit and a selection of breads. The salads were fresh and nicely presented. Bread selection mirrored what they have a dinner. For those who wanted breakfast choices, the following were available: eggs, bacon, sausage, fried potatoes and an absolutely wonderful French toast that was dripping with a delicious caramel sauce. I had two servings of the French toast. For those who wanted dinner choices there were several proteins available: shaved prime rib, chicken and ham. Sides included mashed potatoes, carrots and very cheesy macaroni. There may have been more choices but I missed them. Everything was delicious and clearly home cooked. The dessert table had pies, brownies, bread pudding and a few pastries. Kids loved the brownies, the moms loved the pies and I went for an additional serving of the French toast. Three juices (orange, apple and cranberry) were available for a starter and coffee was served at the table. Now ... this place is quaint and the food is very, very good. Prices were reasonable and the value was superb. We had very good service and even had a chance to visit with the owner, Nancy. Again, we highly recommend without any reservations. You will have a good experience.
Dtwom516 Motorsports
What a unique discovery! Cozy dining in an old feed mill. Great home style meals and prices that won't scare you away. Definitely a must stop if you're in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Pulled Pork Mac and Cheese, Pot Roast Veggies
Mark Daspit
Wow! Was not expecting food to be an extremely high quality! Definitely worth the drive from Madison!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Friday Fish Specials, Mushroom Strudel, Fish
Luz Burkard
Super Romantic rustic elegance! The gourmet chicken salad sandwiches on a variety of breads were delicious. The Tea table was so adorable and the sweets tables was decadent.
Great food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mushroom Strudel
Great atmosphere great place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie
Great place for our work Christmas party! Loved the atmosphere and decor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
There was a buffet with several meat and vegetable options as well as salad and homemade rolls and ? desserts. It was wonderful. The building is an old mill and very quaint with a gift shop with homemade home goods and jellies and jams. Atmosphere is fantastic, service excellent. Highly recommend The Old Feed Mill.
The Thanksgiving buffet seating @3:30 was a disappointment. We were seated up stairs in a lone corner. Butter, salad dressing, and turkey were in short supply. We could not tell what a couple of the items were on the buffet. Desserts had been sitting out to long & were dried out. Cannot recommend..doesn't live up to past billing.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
The Thanksgiving Buffet was so delicious! Everyone was friendly, attentive, and focused on ensuring that all guests enjoyed themselves. The atmosphere is cozy, warm, and welcoming. A perfect way to centenary the holiday without the stress!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Pudding
Unassuming yet quite delightful is how I'd describe this place. The menu may not look overtly impressive, but the food was well cooked and most enjoyable. Within easy walking distance of the Iron Amethyst Inn, this was an ideal location to relax and eat well cooked fair that pleased the palette and soothed the soul. We were served on both nights by Aliyah who made us feel very welcome with her prompt service and happy demeanor. The prices felt reasonable and at no time did we feel anything except happy we'd picked the Inn to eat at. If you're in the area I feel you can't go far wrong eating here. And after you've eaten, the gift shop beckons!
Absolutely wonderful place and price was food was amazing! Buffet Style with many options! Employees were very welcoming.From me being an out a Stater, my experience was awesome! Thank u❣️
5:30 reservation for dinner and didn't receive entrees until 7:15. Late for American Players Theater. Lots of apologies but no action. Will not return.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
The Buffet was remarkable and affordable. We are definitely going back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pretentious, nasty old lady with condescending attitude. Have been there in a long time, overpriced and unimaginative.
Dinner was so good a week ago we decided to come back for the Sunday brunch. Met one of our families after church and really had a wonderful experience. The brunch was a little limited but everything on it was delicious. We started with salads, fruit and a selection of breads. The salads were fresh and nicely presented. Bread selection mirrored what they have a dinner. For those who wanted breakfast choices, the following were available: eggs, bacon, sausage, fried potatoes and an absolutely wonderful French toast that was dripping with a delicious caramel sauce. I had two servings of the French toast. For those who wanted dinner choices there were several proteins available: shaved prime rib, chicken and ham. Sides included mashed potatoes, carrots and very cheesy macaroni. There may have been more choices but I missed them. Everything was delicious and clearly home cooked. The dessert table had pies, brownies, bread pudding and a few pastries. Kids loved the brownies, the moms loved the pies and I went for an additional serving of the French toast. Three juices (orange, apple and cranberry) were available for a starter and coffee was served at the table. Now ... this place is quaint and the food is very, very good. Prices were reasonable and the value was superb. We had very good service and even had a chance to visit with the owner, Nancy. Again, we highly recommend without any reservations. You will have a good experience.
What a unique discovery! Cozy dining in an old feed mill. Great home style meals and prices that won't scare you away. Definitely a must stop if you're in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Pulled Pork Mac and Cheese, Pot Roast Veggies
Wow! Was not expecting food to be an extremely high quality! Definitely worth the drive from Madison!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Friday Fish Specials, Mushroom Strudel, Fish
Super Romantic rustic elegance! The gourmet chicken salad sandwiches on a variety of breads were delicious. The Tea table was so adorable and the sweets tables was decadent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5