Wall Street Gallery & Bistro

As a Mazomanie resident, writing an unfavorable assessment of a local establishment is unpleasant as I want to support them as much as I can. However, I want my experience reflected in these reviews so future patrons are aware of what they should expect.

Atmosphere: The atmosphere of the restaurant itself is lovely. Eclectic collection of art and knickknacks with games available to play. We enjoyed the trivial pursuit cards on the table. There is a dog that roams freely about the indoor dining area. This is something I quite enjoy but my husband does not care for. The dog is very sweet and mostly keeps to itself but something to be aware of if you are allergic or prefer not to have animals in your dining spaces.

Drinks: Both my husband and I ordered whiskey old fashioneds. They were very good. My husband ordered a second that was accidentally made with brandy. The server offered to remake it when he realized his mistake but that wasn’t necessary, my husband enjoyed the brandy old fashioned just as much.

Food: This is where our experience began to fall apart. They have pizza and pasta on the menu, as well as a special that we did not try. For $18 you choose a pasta, three vegetables and a sauce. For an additional $8, you can add a protein. The meals do come with a small salad we all quite enjoyed, it was a mixture of Romaine lettuce and spinach with shaved Parmesan and croutons. They also give you a small loaf of bread to share that was tasty. I ordered linguini with mushrooms, broccoli and Kalamata olives with pesto cream sauce and I chose to add chicken. What I received: a VERY small portion of linguini with broccoli, mushrooms and Alfredo sauce with four small pieces (bite size) of chicken breast. This is not an exaggeration. I did not bring my phone to the restaurant with me but I wish I would have to take a photo. $26 for four bites of chicken and a side dish portion of pasta. No olives, and a completely wrong sauce. It tasted fine and I did not request they correct the mistakes because I also enjoy Alfredo sauce.

What my son ordered: capellini pasta with broccoli and Alfredo sauce. He chose to add shrimp. What he received: A very small portion of capellini pasta and broccoli with pesto cream sauce and three regular sized shrimp. Completely wrong sauce and again, way too pricy for the portion.

My husband ordered a pizza that was small but tasted good and seemed to be exactly what he ordered.

My son and I both left hungry because the portions were so small. Our bill for the evening was over $100. Unfortunately, we won’t be planning a trip back as the value for us is not there.

My husband and I stopped here for the first time today and feel as though we stumbled across a hidden gem. The pasta, bread, and dessert were delicious, and the owners are such welcoming and lovely people. The atmosphere is cozy and quaint, and all of the other patrons we chatted with were equally as wonderful. We don’t find ourselves in Mazomanie often, but maybe we will now!

Small, quiet place with fantastic food! Owners are the sweetest people!

Everything is homemade from scratch and delicious. You build your dish.

Wall street Bistro has a unique and downhome atmosphere. The service is excellent and the food is gourmet quality. We had the sourdough pizza which was delicious!!! Thankyou Nancy and Jeff for making it a wonderful dinner date night.

A very pleasant evening at this cozy Italian restaurant. Husband and wife team create simple pasta and pizza dishes - all home made pasta. A limited (less impressive) wine offering, but it did not distract from the delicious food. Worth a visit

OMG i rarely leave reviews, unless the place is outright horrible, but this small town mom and pop restaurant is put if this world!! Absolutely you must dine here!! All scratch made desert (actual home made) pasta blew my tastebuds into next week! I cannot say enough for this place, so glad i took this detour and found the gem!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food was absolutely delicious! The atmosphere was cozy and homey. The service was exceptional. I would definitely recommend this place to friends and family!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pesto & Olive Oil, Sauce

Suck a quaint & lovely place in a gem of a village. I'm in awe of what they have done here ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Between the eclectic atmosphere of the tables and chairs to the couple that runs the restaurant, this cozy little hole in the wall is always a treat, simple but homemade pasta, sauce and bread that's delicious and always hits the spot, worth a stop every time I swing through Mazomanie!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wow! This is a fantastic restaurant, the owners are great. The food was so good, everything made from scratch! We stopped on our way home and now will make it a point of coming here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Roasted Garlic And

Had a fantastic time tonight. The owner and his wife were great. We had our 2 year old daughter with us and the treated her awesome even though the resteraunt isnt kid centric. The food was fantastic. The atmosphere was great. The service was excellent. We cannot wait to come back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time visiting. Such a pleasant surprise! We loved the service, food, and atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We were so impressed with this place, including the food. Four of us, on a very quiet night for them, and we were treated like family. The husband/wife owners cooked for us and served us. Since we were the only ones left, they sat down and joined us for banter and a drink. They are lovely people, very welcoming, open, and have a great life story. We sought them out in hopes of a good dinner outside of the Spring Green ghost town and were pleasantly surprised. If you're in Mazomani, WI. You need to go here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing local mom and pop run spot! The food is some truly home cooked Italian and it never disappoints. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5