Maple Tree Supper Club

6010 US-51, McFarland
(608) 838-5888

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Robert Zaborek

Best prime rib I’ve had in years waitress was awesome. I look forward to going back.

Jake Powers

Don't order take out, there is no quality control coming out of that kitchen. In particular the broasted chicken. I doesn't even resemble chicken, it's so bad. Prior to the Maple Tree reopening, it was awesome. We've tried a half dozen times since then with no luck. So we won't order take out again, and being long time locals, we have no interest in dining in with the long wait. Glad business is booming, just bring back good take out.

Briana Furrer

To start off, the bread was INCREDIBLE! They served a loaf of warm, soft bread before the meal and it was so good. The cheese curds were probably a 4 out of 5. The ranch with them was maybe a 3 out of 5. Not the best cheese curds I’ve had but still better than others! The fish fry was also incredible! The beer batter breading was very flavorful and the fish was fresh. I had a chicken sandwich which was very tasty. The fries are unseasoned but were fine. The place had pretty cheap silverware but was generally clean. Our meal was $70 for appetizer, two entrees, and three drinks. One of the entrees came with soup and salad bar access, so I would say it was well worth our money. Overall a great experience and we will be back!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cod Fish Fry

Ron R

My wife, our son and I stopped at this restaurant last night at the recommendation of another restaurant up the street because they don't serve prime rib. It took only 10 minutes to be seated and the first thing I noticed was how loud it was. Guests were talking to other guests at a far away table. Our waitress was talking to another table while serving a different table. And all we're at a very high volume. I had to turn my hearing aids off! By the time our order arrived, all but one table had left our section and their tables were reset. I eagerly cut my prime rib anxious to taste what deliciousness a good prime rib can offer. Yuck! The flavor was off-putting and the texture was chewy. Our waitress had stopped by to see the meals were and when I told her about mine, she did offer to bring me a new one. I refused because I didn't want to wait again. The cashier asked about the food and I shared my experience. He said, "Yeah we're running low.". I thought, "I should've ordered the broasted chicken." Don't think there will be a next time.

Peyton Turner

The food, service, and atmosphere were exactly what you would expect of a midwestern supper club. I do worry about the cholesterol and blood pressure of people who eat here on a regular basis though.

Troy BRADSHAW

What a fantastic place to eat and enjoy company.

craig poland

My favorite restaurant! Best prime rib I've ever had!!!

Donna Matts

Always great food, and plenty of it; served by great staff!

Jill Buckles

Excellent meal at Maple Tree! The salad bar is top notch with 2 homemade soups. We love the warm loaves of bread. The broasted chicken is my favorite. It is delicious. I’ll be back. Finished the meal with an ice-cream drink! Yum!

Isabella Brauhn Kendall

Had a great time at Maple Tree Supper Club 🥃🍒🥩 We really enjoyed the Brandy Old Fashioned, the salad bar (homemade croutons & cheese spread were a hit!), and the grasshopper ice cream drink to finish 😍

Kathryn Kozel

Best Prime Rib - very tasty, tender, and slow cooked perfectly 👌

Matthew Gramse

Good Wisconsin supper club. Good food and atmosphere

Becca Anderson

Absolutely love coming here, which we do at least 2-3 times a month as we live in Kenosha but come to visit family. Staff is friendly, drinks are good and food is delicious.

dalesT2465KY

Would be higher but lots of empty tables but not enough staff. So you wait a few hours for a table because the short staff can only handle so many ppl

Q7702ZStr

Are you kidding me? I ordered the PRIME RIB and when it came out I thought it was a prank. It looked like the Flintstones opening. The salad bar was great! The soup was delicious. The PRIME RIB was worth the trip from wherever you are coming from.

Loading...