Mama Mia's Germantown

Great pizza and garlic bread. Service was good, but appears to be under staffed.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Meat Sauce, Garlic Bread, Thin Crust Pizza

Not impressed. The best one is off Greenfield Ave in West Allis and it should be the only one!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Kind of a dinky little place that will soon be paired with a BBQ place we only sat in the bar so didn't really see much of the restaurant they had 1 bartender but weren't busy at all so it was fine. The menu is extremely limited with just a very few pasta dishes and pizza so you better want spaghetti or pizza but on the bright side it's genuine Mama Mias the same garlic bread we love and the same spaghetti and pizza sauce as the original

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Meat Sauce, Antipasto Salad, Garlic, Thin Crust Pizza

Great vibe. Appreciate the service and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I loved the garlic bread. I had the cheesey meatball sandwhich. It was served hot and large. the chips i was given with the sandwhich i didnt care much for but the sandwhich was so good it was large enough to be two meals. The staff are good natured and atentive. Over all good experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread

I love when I get to Milwaukee and get a chance to visit my family and eat my favorite food: Mama Mia's garlic bread. Unfortunately this place doesn't have it. The bread that they serve doesn't even come close to the one in Greenfield. It's just mush and tastes awful. Their pizza is fine but I will always take the long ride to the other restaurant even though we're only a couple blocks from this one.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Thin Crust Pizza

Ordered delivery through the food app, lasagne, no where near what it was before, both taste and portion.

Food: 2

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread

The original Mama Mia's recipes.... DELICIOUS. Limited menu when we were there...pizzas garlic bread, salad, lasagna, maybe spaghetti. The garlic bread (to die for) and pizza has even a tad more flavor than North Lake Inn or Bluemound Rd, but nonetheless, the original flavor... And it was awesome. The pizza crust, sauce, sausage all three same and wonderful. There was one size salad for$12. I thought it was pretty small for that price and was barely enough for two people.. but we like salad. I just think it should have been at least 50% larger. And it definitely needed more dressing but once we got extra it was delicious. The location is open, but going through some changes. Apparently it used to be half Mexican restaurant half Mama Mia's (nicely divided and different decor on each side... But if I understood correctly, the Mexican half is going to be taken out and replaced with a smokehouse/bbq type restaurant. When you enter it looks like you are inside a Mexican restaurant but the hostess will seat you on the Mama Mia's side... so no, you're not in the wrong place if you feel confused.So, we had 1 large pizza w sausage, 1 Salad w garlic bread, 1 more garlic bread, 2 sodas . It came to $42 plus we added our tip.I will definitely go back to this location. I am very VERY happy to know the Mama Mia's recipes are still live and well!

Parking: Plenty of free parking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carry out on Friday night, the young man who was working was so friendly. He recapped my food order. Pizza was just as delicious as eating in the restaurant. Everyone who knows me knows how much I love the pizza and Mama Mia’s

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It’s says open tried going on 3 different occasions ALWAYS closed! Tonight 3 people pulled up to see if they open , they were closed!! No voicemail nothing!

The pizza was trash so that is where it went. The worst pizza in germantown yet somehow also one of the most expensive? It makes sense why this place was closed down.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

It’s odd but the food was good. It’s 2 restaurants in one. It’s mostly Mexican type food but there are a few Italian dishes. Mama Mia’s is a few tables in a separate section with pizza and lasagne.

Order lasagna (extra meat sauce) with garlic bread and a extra garlic bread. The sauce on the lasagna was disgusting ? way to sweet. They changed us $1.50 for extra sauce and $2.00 for takeout container fee. In all the order came to almost $25.00 with all the extra fees. Definitely not the same. I’ll never go there again.

We were there Saturday evening. The food had no flavor. I thought the chips and salsa would be good because we were told they fresh, the salsa was more like Italian sauce then Mexican salsa. You should go to the Pick n Save and get some Mexican seasoning.

Commenting on the Mama Mia’s portion of the menu only. We did not order any of the new mexican food menu. The garlic bread was delicious (perfect amount of butter and garlic seasoning) the classic lasagna was a big disappointment though. The height of the lasagna has gone down, it seems the meat layer was missing? Simply noodles, mozzarella cheese and red sauce. I made my meal on the bread and sauce which was filling enough but don’t say you have the classic lasagna if the customer has to ask “Where’s the beef?”. Go to Bluemound Rd if you want the classic lasagna! Server was very nice but overworked.