Dig their tasty sandwiches and salads more than their pizzas. Great location.
Harper Beresford
Went to the Mequon Public Market and had the Pronto special, a personal pizza with a caesar salad for $8. Eight bucks! The salad was fresh as was the tasty pizza and the service was excellent! Completely friendly, helpful, considerate server who took our order, patiently helped my elderly mom with all her questions, and kindly brought our order to us outside. Wow!
Scott Loewenstein
Very delicious pizza and a good overall selection. Is perfect for carry out or cafeteria style dine in.
Andrew Bartelt
Pretty solid pizza overall. Could use more sauce in my opinion. Slices were cut too large. But like the light, crispy crust. Will be back to try again.
Max Sawa
Ordered the margherita pizza and was surprised how flavorful it was. Great spot to grab a personal pizza or a large for a group. Seating outside and inside the market with plenty of space. They offer sandwiches as well but I recommend going for the pizza!
jeremy
Had a bit of an issue with a gift card we won at the chinooks game but they made it right. Pizza was actually really good! Wife had a hard time finding it but other than the gift card and location the pizza was very good!
Emma Lucht
My husband, toddler, and I went to Pizza Man for dinner. There were some other people but it wasn't super busy. We ordered a salad, personal pizza, and a sandwich. They said I would receive a text when my order was ready.We sat down and waited 20 minutes. I went to ask about our order and was told by the head chef that if I hadn't gotten a text I had to wait and proceeded to turn around and walk away.I waited another 20 minutes and then checked on my order. The woman behind the register checked on my order and told me the salad and pizza were ready, but the sandwich was not. I took what was ready and went to eat.Came back 20 minutes later, a whole HOUR after I had ordered to ask about the sandwich. The worker said she would check and told me it was not ready. I went and bought ice-cream for my child and myself and when I came back it had been 75 minutes since I ordered.Seeing as my family had now completely eaten and had dessert, I went to cancel my sandwich order and was told "they just put it in" and that the kitchen hadn't received a ticket for the sandwich, despite 2 of my 3 items which were on the same ticket already being done. They gave me a refund but offered no apologies or any sympathy for taking over 75 minutes to realize they didn't make the sandwich, thus wasting my time.They clearly don't have anyone keeping track of timing or making sure that everything on tickets are being made in a timely manner.
Leah Shook
We got the Topher pizza and a Caesar salad. The salad was fine, it seemed like they may make their own dressing and croutons, which was a plus, but this pizza was so unique it totally made my day.I don't think I've had this combination on a pizza before, but I would totally order it again: sausage, cream cheese, jalapenos, and hot honey, strangely it wasn't too spicy either.
Chris Jansen
Placed a carry out order at 7:15 and told 20 to 25 minutes for pick up. I arrived at 7:35 and was told the order was going into the oven. I proceeded to sit at the bar have a soda and wait. My order was rung up by 7:45. At 8:00 I inquired about my pizza and was told it was going into the oven(been here before). At 8:05 I was given my garlic bread. I refused to take it until the pizza was ready so they would both be hot. My pizza came out at 8:15 with no garlic bread. I waited another 10 minutes for a hot garlic bread. Short staffed or not this is unacceptable.
Mike Henry
Pizza man for me was a reminder of what great pizza tastes like. The Pizza is square cut and easy to eat with your hands...Nice if that's the way you like it. The pizza is thin crust but not cracker like... great balance there. The ingredients were fresh and ripe... I especially loved the mozzarella chunks on the Artichoke A La Mode pizza. The pizza is also clean... I ate a lot but I didn't feel gross after a great meal.
My experience is similar to everyone else’s. I got there at lunch time and they were not busy. The staff was all sitting there chatting and eating their own food. I ordered ONE personal pan pizza and waited at the tables with my toddler. I waited 50 MINUTES. I go up there, ready to walk out, and said “where is my pizza?” They had no idea then looked in like the heated take out fridge behind counter and like “here it is.” So yay for not so fresh pizza… the experience alone is enough for me to never go again. Then the pizza itself is not good. Very thin crumbly crust.
John P
Ordered at 220pm for dine in and we were the only customers waiting. We sat at the tables until 255pm but they never brought out the pizza. Went to the counter and it was sitting in the warmer in a box like a to go order but the staff was just sitting there. They were friendly enough but just odd as we were the only people waiting on food and they didn’t appear to be doing anything else. As far as pizza, great flavor but the crust was too thin in the middle to the point the sauce and cheese broke through and was very hard to eat. Actually had to scrape the middle slices onto a plate because it all stuck together to the box. Good garlic bread though.
Matthew Anderson
It's a great concept, but the pizza crust is usually covered in some kind of gritty burnt flour and is undercooked in the middle. It's like eating raw dough covered in sand.
Laura Gallitz
Super slow service, out of many items. Pizza was good, but nothing very exciting. Food came up to window and sat there for five minutes as cashier chatted with a delivery guy. Would not recommend or come back.
MistahZ
Eh, pizza man is o.k, nothing too bad but nothing too excellent either. I didn't go to the store myself so I cannot comment on the building or service. What I can comment on is the food. The pizza was just...alright I guess. Thin crust isn't really my kind of pizza but that's apparently what I got and...eh, less said the better. The cheese bread was good but...kinda just felt like garlic bread without the garlic and replaced with a LITTLE cheese. I wouldn't say to go to pizza man or not but if it's a option for pizza I guess it is there.Pictures are of the food.
Dig their tasty sandwiches and salads more than their pizzas. Great location.
Went to the Mequon Public Market and had the Pronto special, a personal pizza with a caesar salad for $8. Eight bucks! The salad was fresh as was the tasty pizza and the service was excellent! Completely friendly, helpful, considerate server who took our order, patiently helped my elderly mom with all her questions, and kindly brought our order to us outside. Wow!
Very delicious pizza and a good overall selection. Is perfect for carry out or cafeteria style dine in.
Pretty solid pizza overall. Could use more sauce in my opinion. Slices were cut too large. But like the light, crispy crust. Will be back to try again.
Ordered the margherita pizza and was surprised how flavorful it was. Great spot to grab a personal pizza or a large for a group. Seating outside and inside the market with plenty of space. They offer sandwiches as well but I recommend going for the pizza!
Had a bit of an issue with a gift card we won at the chinooks game but they made it right. Pizza was actually really good! Wife had a hard time finding it but other than the gift card and location the pizza was very good!
My husband, toddler, and I went to Pizza Man for dinner. There were some other people but it wasn't super busy. We ordered a salad, personal pizza, and a sandwich. They said I would receive a text when my order was ready.We sat down and waited 20 minutes. I went to ask about our order and was told by the head chef that if I hadn't gotten a text I had to wait and proceeded to turn around and walk away.I waited another 20 minutes and then checked on my order. The woman behind the register checked on my order and told me the salad and pizza were ready, but the sandwich was not. I took what was ready and went to eat.Came back 20 minutes later, a whole HOUR after I had ordered to ask about the sandwich. The worker said she would check and told me it was not ready. I went and bought ice-cream for my child and myself and when I came back it had been 75 minutes since I ordered.Seeing as my family had now completely eaten and had dessert, I went to cancel my sandwich order and was told "they just put it in" and that the kitchen hadn't received a ticket for the sandwich, despite 2 of my 3 items which were on the same ticket already being done. They gave me a refund but offered no apologies or any sympathy for taking over 75 minutes to realize they didn't make the sandwich, thus wasting my time.They clearly don't have anyone keeping track of timing or making sure that everything on tickets are being made in a timely manner.
We got the Topher pizza and a Caesar salad. The salad was fine, it seemed like they may make their own dressing and croutons, which was a plus, but this pizza was so unique it totally made my day.I don't think I've had this combination on a pizza before, but I would totally order it again: sausage, cream cheese, jalapenos, and hot honey, strangely it wasn't too spicy either.
Placed a carry out order at 7:15 and told 20 to 25 minutes for pick up. I arrived at 7:35 and was told the order was going into the oven. I proceeded to sit at the bar have a soda and wait. My order was rung up by 7:45. At 8:00 I inquired about my pizza and was told it was going into the oven(been here before). At 8:05 I was given my garlic bread. I refused to take it until the pizza was ready so they would both be hot. My pizza came out at 8:15 with no garlic bread. I waited another 10 minutes for a hot garlic bread. Short staffed or not this is unacceptable.
Pizza man for me was a reminder of what great pizza tastes like. The Pizza is square cut and easy to eat with your hands...Nice if that's the way you like it. The pizza is thin crust but not cracker like... great balance there. The ingredients were fresh and ripe... I especially loved the mozzarella chunks on the Artichoke A La Mode pizza. The pizza is also clean... I ate a lot but I didn't feel gross after a great meal.
Restaurantji Recommends
My experience is similar to everyone else’s. I got there at lunch time and they were not busy. The staff was all sitting there chatting and eating their own food. I ordered ONE personal pan pizza and waited at the tables with my toddler. I waited 50 MINUTES. I go up there, ready to walk out, and said “where is my pizza?” They had no idea then looked in like the heated take out fridge behind counter and like “here it is.” So yay for not so fresh pizza… the experience alone is enough for me to never go again. Then the pizza itself is not good. Very thin crumbly crust.
Ordered at 220pm for dine in and we were the only customers waiting. We sat at the tables until 255pm but they never brought out the pizza. Went to the counter and it was sitting in the warmer in a box like a to go order but the staff was just sitting there. They were friendly enough but just odd as we were the only people waiting on food and they didn’t appear to be doing anything else. As far as pizza, great flavor but the crust was too thin in the middle to the point the sauce and cheese broke through and was very hard to eat. Actually had to scrape the middle slices onto a plate because it all stuck together to the box. Good garlic bread though.
It's a great concept, but the pizza crust is usually covered in some kind of gritty burnt flour and is undercooked in the middle. It's like eating raw dough covered in sand.
Super slow service, out of many items. Pizza was good, but nothing very exciting. Food came up to window and sat there for five minutes as cashier chatted with a delivery guy. Would not recommend or come back.
Eh, pizza man is o.k, nothing too bad but nothing too excellent either. I didn't go to the store myself so I cannot comment on the building or service. What I can comment on is the food. The pizza was just...alright I guess. Thin crust isn't really my kind of pizza but that's apparently what I got and...eh, less said the better. The cheese bread was good but...kinda just felt like garlic bread without the garlic and replaced with a LITTLE cheese. I wouldn't say to go to pizza man or not but if it's a option for pizza I guess it is there.Pictures are of the food.
Loading...