St. Paul Fish Company Mequon

We dine at St Paul's Fish Company every few months and the food is always excellent. We are now “addicted” to the Salmon Crack” appetizer, but also love the Fried Calamari. I typically order the Steamed Mussels appetizer as my meal and my daughter usually orders the Pan Seared Scallops, both of which are excellent. My other daughter has had the Lobster Mac and Cheese or the Bouillbaisse, which are both fantastic. This time my husband and I decided to try the Maine Lobster and Alaskan Crab rolls and they were delicious. My daughters had the Arugula Beet and Chopped salads with grilled shrimp and those were both outstanding as well. Our server was exceptionally good, as well. This is one of our favorite restaurants and we are never disappointed.

Everytime we come here the food is great, the old fashioned is fantastic and I love the atmosphere. Staff is super friendly. My daughter and I both had the crab legs. Absolutely delicious

We had a great Father's Day dinner last night and Joe Pavon did a great job serving our table. My sons happen to know he and his brother Tony who we had serve us at Relish. Everything was excellent, but my wife's grouper didn't come out until well after everyone else was served. Joe had a woman come out to let us know they were comping her meal, which I thought was a nice gesture. The king crab legs were outstanding as always. We'll definitely be back!

Excellent food and service.

Made a reservation only to be informed that we needed to wait, while those who just showed up were promptly seated.

Tacos were super amazing

Go to the St. Paul Fish Company and go often, you won't be disappointed, they check all the boxes. As food and labor costs have soared along with an out of control cost of living Americans have been forced to dramatically cut back or stop entirely dining out. The fine dining white tablecloth restaurant in the United States is all but extinct. That being said St. Paul Fish Company provides the freshest and highest quality seafood in the Midwest at arguably the lowest possible prices. This place is by far your biggest bang for your buck in Wisconsin and maybe anywhere.

Awesome menu, great service, top notch decor. Found a new favorite

Stopped in here on my lunch today, first time I’ve ever been here. I tried the Atlantic salmon and it was insanely fresh and freaking delicious. Employees were helpful and friendly, I’ll definitely be back to try more.

Wonderful to have great fresh seafood... my granddaughter was so happy with her oysters and crab.

Had a reservation for right when they opened, it was perfect. The dining area was so cool, lots of neat items to look and the wall and hanging art were a treat. They had plenty of seating and even room for large groups and outdoor seating. Such a gem of the place. The bathrooms were clean, the restaurant was clean and same goes for the kitchen. Right when you walk in there is the host stand and the seafood market, to my surprise, there was not a bad smell. Everything looked so fresh and good, it was well maintained and kept. Thank you Val R and your trainee for such a wonderful lunch and first dine in experience here. We have got seafood to take home ourselves before, but never dined in. So glad we did. Val and her trainee were absolutely fabulous! They both made this lunch so special. Val had great recommends, explained everything well, even share the most popular items with us all while training a new waitress. We ordered 2 different style appetizers, the Cajun BBQ shrimp and hot peel & eat shrimp. WOW! The flavor was spot on, so good. The Cajun BBQ shrimp sauce is delightful and so tasty, heat but not over doing it. Shrimp were large and tender, cooked to perfection. The hot & eat shrimp, were flavored well, shells/legs peeled right off, they were tender and juicy. We each tried a boil. Lobster boil and the Snow Crab legs boil. Again, these were cooked to perfection and the seasoning was just perfect. All the seafood was cooked just beautifully, the crab meat came right out and the lobster meat was falling out. Not rubbery, not chewy, just amazing. The potatoes and corn were so good as well. We truly enjoyed these boils. Even added some king crab legs since they were available at market price. Just such a great time!! Even enjoyed a birthday dessert to top it all over. Overall, truly a fantastic experience. Nothing was a disappointment and the food was outstanding. Can't wait to come back again. Thanks again to Val R and her trainee, we appreciate you!

Everything was fine until one of the hosts shouted and I mean SHOUTED at us that we had to leave because they needed the table. Very embarrassing.

Just an off night for food tonight. Normally the food is excellent. The service as always was excellent and we will definitely go back as the food is usually excellent.

We had a group of seven and everything went very well. Loved being able to reserve on-line several days ahead. As always, the seafood was very fresh and delicious. Our grandsons came to visit from Green Bay. They wanted to try something different. We had shark bites, shrimp cocktail, calamari, shrimp tacos, lobster rolls, broiled walleye, lobster boil and fried perch. What a wonderful meal! Everyone was very pleased. St. Paul's is always busy. It is easy to see why. Service was fast and efficient.

Always a treat to have a meal at St. Paul or to take out. Our server was very nice and our meal arrived promptly. It was a busy day and the restaurant was crowded but we were seated right away. No complaints whatsoever.