This restaurant seems to keep a low profile, as you do not hear about it through the critics and that is probably the way they like it. The exterior was well kept and inviting. Parking was close by. My brother had his standard old fashioned and I had a great glass of red Zinfandel. My brother started off with the french onion soup and enjoyed it. We both ordered the Tenderloin steak and were not disappointed. They were done perfectly, with nice grill markings from the high heat. Sides were a double baked potato presented in a small ramekin and house salads. The onion rings were on point. I told my brother this place is as good as Jakes, which sadly imploded a few years ago. I envision my brother will make this his favorite go to restaurant. He lives in Fox Point where there are few choices for fine dining and this place is an easy drive. We finished our dinners and had cheesecake and coffee. Again, they excelled in the preparation. I will return for Prime Rib (Saturdays only) on my next visit. Running a restaurant is no easy task. The seasoned employees here made it look effortless. We knew we were in good hands from the moment we sat down. Our waitress had a quick answer for all our questions.
Susan Solomon
A historical treasure! Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ethan Brooks
Good food, fresh warm rolls served for the table, delicious old fashioned! A cozy, friendly place with classic food and drink selection.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Judith Rehm
Lots of people enjoying the time at the Inn
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Diana McGath
A classic gathering place for delicious food and great company!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lyn Bensman
Always great! Great service, Dawn!!
Tracey Pederson
We called for a 5:00 pm reservation and were told they would need the table by 6:20. Not a problem at all. At 6 the hostess was hovering around our table, it was awkward so we asked for boxes and our check. The minute our waitress brought back the folder with credit card the hostess drops in, takes it and says have nice evening. Ah.. we haven’t had a moment to sign and you just took my credit card. We thought we would have an after finger drink at the bar. Grab a seat, ordered our drinks and halfway through our drinks same hostess comes up to us and says you will need to leave, we need these chairs for people who want to eat, She was rude ! It was totally embarrassingly as this wasn’t done quietly and we were only half way through our drinks. We will never be back!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Judith Henry
The owner/hostess is awfully rude. Their Range Line burger is awesome if they cook it to the correct temperature you ordered but that is hit or miss. And if they overcook it, she will come with a flashlight to look at the burger at your table and rather than take responsibility that their cooks didn’t prepare it correctly, she tell the customer (me) that I didn’t order it correctly. Seriously! Beyond rudeness!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Michael
Good food. The reason for not giving it 5 stars is due to the owners attitude and customer service skills. She is rude and rushes people to get out if they stay a bit longer than she’d like. She’s definitely a born and raised mequonite.
Emily Mondloch
Fun atmosphere, wonderful food! We had Paige as our waitress and she was lovely! We will definitely be back
The food is very good, nice atmosphere, & service. We will be regulars now. The history itself should bring you in! Was like stepping back into time.
Jessica charris
Checked this place out this last Friday. It's was busy but a very good chill vibe. I had the Walleye it was delicious so was the desserts I tried a few. Great service. I will definitely be back soon to check out the rest of the menu.
Rich Hall
Just an all around great place! Food was great and the service was outstanding!
Kathleen Gorlewski
A great place to dine. Wonderful staff and the owner always seems to be on site making sure of your satisfaction. The food is great..what more can you ask for!?
Joe Schmidt
Absolutely amazing food. Everything was done to perfection. The drinks were also amazing and the service was prompt, polite, and not overbearing. Its been far too long so nice I was here last, I will try to be back soon.
This restaurant seems to keep a low profile, as you do not hear about it through the critics and that is probably the way they like it. The exterior was well kept and inviting. Parking was close by. My brother had his standard old fashioned and I had a great glass of red Zinfandel. My brother started off with the french onion soup and enjoyed it. We both ordered the Tenderloin steak and were not disappointed. They were done perfectly, with nice grill markings from the high heat. Sides were a double baked potato presented in a small ramekin and house salads. The onion rings were on point. I told my brother this place is as good as Jakes, which sadly imploded a few years ago. I envision my brother will make this his favorite go to restaurant. He lives in Fox Point where there are few choices for fine dining and this place is an easy drive. We finished our dinners and had cheesecake and coffee. Again, they excelled in the preparation. I will return for Prime Rib (Saturdays only) on my next visit. Running a restaurant is no easy task. The seasoned employees here made it look effortless. We knew we were in good hands from the moment we sat down. Our waitress had a quick answer for all our questions.
A historical treasure! Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good food, fresh warm rolls served for the table, delicious old fashioned! A cozy, friendly place with classic food and drink selection.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lots of people enjoying the time at the Inn
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
A classic gathering place for delicious food and great company!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always great! Great service, Dawn!!
We called for a 5:00 pm reservation and were told they would need the table by 6:20. Not a problem at all. At 6 the hostess was hovering around our table, it was awkward so we asked for boxes and our check. The minute our waitress brought back the folder with credit card the hostess drops in, takes it and says have nice evening. Ah.. we haven’t had a moment to sign and you just took my credit card. We thought we would have an after finger drink at the bar. Grab a seat, ordered our drinks and halfway through our drinks same hostess comes up to us and says you will need to leave, we need these chairs for people who want to eat, She was rude ! It was totally embarrassingly as this wasn’t done quietly and we were only half way through our drinks. We will never be back!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
The owner/hostess is awfully rude. Their Range Line burger is awesome if they cook it to the correct temperature you ordered but that is hit or miss. And if they overcook it, she will come with a flashlight to look at the burger at your table and rather than take responsibility that their cooks didn’t prepare it correctly, she tell the customer (me) that I didn’t order it correctly. Seriously! Beyond rudeness!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Good food. The reason for not giving it 5 stars is due to the owners attitude and customer service skills. She is rude and rushes people to get out if they stay a bit longer than she’d like. She’s definitely a born and raised mequonite.
Fun atmosphere, wonderful food! We had Paige as our waitress and she was lovely! We will definitely be back
Restaurantji Recommends
The food is very good, nice atmosphere, & service. We will be regulars now. The history itself should bring you in! Was like stepping back into time.
Checked this place out this last Friday. It's was busy but a very good chill vibe. I had the Walleye it was delicious so was the desserts I tried a few. Great service. I will definitely be back soon to check out the rest of the menu.
Just an all around great place! Food was great and the service was outstanding!
A great place to dine. Wonderful staff and the owner always seems to be on site making sure of your satisfaction. The food is great..what more can you ask for!?
Absolutely amazing food. Everything was done to perfection. The drinks were also amazing and the service was prompt, polite, and not overbearing. Its been far too long so nice I was here last, I will try to be back soon.
Loading...