Batter and Mac

1100 E Oklahoma Ave, Milwaukee
(414) 231-9398

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jae S

Great food and staff. Ham and rolls are only on Sundays

Leah Duckert-Kroll

I ordered a bunch of different bakery items, and each one was better than the one before! SO YUMMY!!! The staff is really kind, patient, and helpful too. I need to go back! Love them for EVERYTHING!

Daryl Kirchen

Things look pretty and the normal donut texture is fine but the Persian texture is off and the Cruller isn't a Cruller. It looks like a milwaukee style but it more like a basic cake donut. Everything looks great but the texture and taste is a bit blah and for the price your best bet is something like a small tart. Won't be going there for a long while.

I also heard some rumors about employee pay withholding etc but not holding that against them.

Service was good and pretty quick.

Lose all the plastic containers and bags too ick.

Nicholas Whitehead

Best. Croissant. Ever. Seriously.

Nina Gevelinger

We arrived in the morning and had a bit of a wait because only one person was working the front. But the selection was great!

John Jancar

Very disappointed. Received a promotional birthday coupon via email last week. They would not honor it because they have a “new system”. It’s not my fault they have a “ new system”. They could have subtracted the $5.00 promotional discount from my bill. They also have a 3% surcharge if using a credit card. Some establishments do this but they have signage stating this. I did not see any posting regarding the credit card surcharge. Product quality was good but way overpriced.

Stephanie Ladd

The bakery is usually good. I’ve had some very yummy things from there. Once I went a few weeks ago and ordered a Canfora Chop sandwich and it was so delicious. I was craving one this week and went in yesterday around 10:30. They didn’t have any premade and there was only one person working and she said she couldn’t make me one. Today my husband stopped in and bought two premade Canfora Chops. They weren’t even edible. The bread was very stale and the meat mixture was not at all like the other sandwich I had. There were some really gross chewy pieces in the meat mix that I had to spit out. I may stop in for bakery occasionally but I’m definitely not going in for sandwiches again.

Anna R

I'm so excited there's now a location closer to home! I've been following their journey for a while--totally obsessed with their creatively shaped macarons--and even took a macaron class at their Menomonee Falls spot.

I had to stop by for their Dubai Chocolate Takeover Day--I'm such a fan of those flavors and couldn't wait to see the creativity in action. Despite it being the morning of the Milwaukee Marathon (parking was a bit tricky!), I made it and even found a spot. Usually, parking in the area is a breeze, and it wasn't too busy when I went.

I treated myself to the Dubai Brownie, Dubai Cream Puff, Dubai Macaron, and the W.A.P. latte--can you tell I'm into the Dubai theme? Everything was incredible, and that brownie was so rich and decadent. Honestly, I wish I could've taken home the whole display case!

They also offer hot ham and rolls on Sundays, mouthwatering deli sandwiches, locally made goodies (like tots, lumpia, and fish), plus your classic bakery favorites. The cakes looked amazing too--perfect if you need something to grab and go.

Can't wait to become a regular at this new spot!

susan schmitt

I went in to do an Easter pre-order as I was having phone trouble. The clerk was super helpful and kind. I also grabbed a Bay view chopped sandwich that was amazing, I'll definitely be back for another.

Kimberly k

Not alot of selection, I miss the old bakery 😢

Krystle K.

Donuts have changed and quality is inconsistent. I used to frequent often for their buttercream donut. Loved that the donut was cut in half and loaded with cream, reminded me of an old school donut however most recently the last few visits have been very disappointing. One visit donuts were made the usual way and the cream had pieces of butter still in it, no longer cut in half. Week 2 cut in half way less cream mostly chunky butter. Very sad that things have changed, wanted to reach by email but you do not offer contact information on website so hopefully staff will see my review and make necessary changes.

Sharon Sadowski

This week we tried the multi-grain sourdough bread, it was delicious. Lovely crisp crust and a wonderfully nutty delicious flavor. See you next Wednesday to buy more!!!
Also the young woman that waited on us was very friendly and efficient.

Douglas Bay

Never consistent in their supply
Never make enough rolls
Out of stock by 10am
Only want to sell over priced cooking n sweets
Don't plans your dinner without calling
Not your canforia

Katy Klinnert

Love the feel of this place and everything I’ve had has been delicious! New macaron spot for the win 🏆

Chris Riemer

The best ham and cheese danish I have ever eaten. In fact one of the best things I have ever tasted!! The place is clean but kind of plain and dark. That is why I gave it a 4 for atmosphere. I will be back with friends many times!!

Loading...