Has been quite a while since we have been there, and experienced temperature issues on 2 of 3 entrees. My companion ordered matzo ball soup. The dumplings were steaming, but the soup was not hot. There was a long wait until the server came back so she could send it back to microwave it. She also special ordered a half chopped liver and pastrami sandwich that she enjoyed, but thought it was light on the pastrami. The rye bread accompanying the sandwhich and my entree was excellent. I always order the super hoppel poppel. It also was not hot enough with the cheesy topping almost congealed. A half order is a generous serving. I would advise telling the server that you need all dishes piping hot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Peter Juzenas
Best Rueben and Matzo ball soup in the USA. I travel a lot and there’s nothing that is this good. The people are so wonderful too!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrea Jessen
Tasty, fresh food in a classic deli. Ruben sandwich was fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cabbage Borscht, The Benji
SaltyKansan
A small shop in the inside corner of a strip mall served up a great sandwich! We ordered one of these giant Hear O Israel sandwiches that came with fries and split it between the two of us. They split it in the kitchen for us and we left satisfied.
Robert Kincade
Best Jewish Deli sandwiches west of Katz's!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jamie Kasten
It was good, but not great for the price. I ordered the Turkey pastrami. They forgot the Swiss cheese I asked for, but no big deal, really. The tiny potato salad that came with it was very bland. I probably won't return.
Anthony LaCriox
Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tony Braglia
It's a dream. Diner feel, friendly, good food for a great price. If you're passing by, or not, you gotta get here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William Zuehlke
It's a deli with charm. I enjoy all of the food I have tried. Would recommend to anyone looking for a good pastrami sandwich.
Ok, so the only sandwich I’ve had here is the Hear, O Israel, but it’s a dang good sandwich with some dang good fries. For the amount of meat that will put you into a food coma, it better be good. Authentic Israeli deli meat and a sandwich with such personality? Sign me up!
Joe Schmidt
The food here is always superior. The ingredients are fresh and cooked just right.
Jill Hart-Cary
Great food
connie tarbah
Benji’s Deli is a must-visit—especially the location in Fox Point, Wisconsin. The layout is warm and inviting, the food tastes incredible, and you really feel like you get more value for your money at this location. And did I mention the food is fantastic? Their corned beef is absolutely out of this world, and the potato salad is just as impressive. Honestly, just about everything on the menu is delicious. They offer a great variety, and while there are a few tables for dining in, most people opt for takeout. It’s very convenient, with plenty of parking since it’s located in an outdoor shopping plaza.
Paul A. Zehm
I have yet to be disappointed with the Hear-O-Israel sandwich, the fries and coleslaw probably the best I have ever had. Service has always been attentive and friendly. Definitely recommend Benji’s.
Has been quite a while since we have been there, and experienced temperature issues on 2 of 3 entrees.
My companion ordered matzo ball soup. The dumplings were steaming, but the soup was not hot. There was a long wait until the server came back so she could send it back to microwave it.
She also special ordered a half chopped liver and pastrami sandwich that she enjoyed, but thought it was light on the pastrami. The rye bread accompanying the sandwhich and my entree was excellent. I always order the super hoppel poppel. It also was not hot enough with the cheesy topping almost congealed. A half order is a generous serving. I would advise telling the server that you need all dishes piping hot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Best Rueben and Matzo ball soup in the USA. I travel a lot and there’s nothing that is this good. The people are so wonderful too!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tasty, fresh food in a classic deli. Ruben sandwich was fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cabbage Borscht, The Benji
A small shop in the inside corner of a strip mall served up a great sandwich! We ordered one of these giant Hear O Israel sandwiches that came with fries and split it between the two of us. They split it in the kitchen for us and we left satisfied.
Best Jewish Deli sandwiches west of Katz's!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
It was good, but not great for the price. I ordered the Turkey pastrami. They forgot the Swiss cheese I asked for, but no big deal, really. The tiny potato salad that came with it was very bland. I probably won't return.
Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's a dream. Diner feel, friendly, good food for a great price. If you're passing by, or not, you gotta get here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's a deli with charm. I enjoy all of the food I have tried. Would recommend to anyone looking for a good pastrami sandwich.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Taste great!
Restaurantji Recommends
Ok, so the only sandwich I’ve had here is the Hear, O Israel, but it’s a dang good sandwich with some dang good fries. For the amount of meat that will put you into a food coma, it better be good. Authentic Israeli deli meat and a sandwich with such personality? Sign me up!
The food here is always superior. The ingredients are fresh and cooked just right.
Great food
Benji’s Deli is a must-visit—especially the location in Fox Point, Wisconsin. The layout is warm and inviting, the food tastes incredible, and you really feel like you get more value for your money at this location. And did I mention the food is fantastic? Their corned beef is absolutely out of this world, and the potato salad is just as impressive. Honestly, just about everything on the menu is delicious. They offer a great variety, and while there are a few tables for dining in, most people opt for takeout. It’s very convenient, with plenty of parking since it’s located in an outdoor shopping plaza.
I have yet to be disappointed with the Hear-O-Israel sandwich, the fries and coleslaw probably the best I have ever had. Service has always been attentive and friendly. Definitely recommend Benji’s.
Loading...