Great pizza .. Milwaukee style at its finest! Cheese bread is amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Di Braccio
Wonderful service and even better pizza. As visitors from Chicago we didn’t know about this place but the pizza was perfectly thin and crispy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carri Torcivia
We ordered pizza delivery tonight and everything was fantastic! The order arrived right on time and the driver was super friendly. The pizza had the perfect balance of crispy crust, fresh toppings and a nice tomato sauce — you can really taste the quality ingredients. My husband also ordered a side of chicken tenders with french fries and he loved them....and he is super picky about his chicken!🐔
It’s hard to find delivery that’s both fast and consistently good, but this place nailed it. Definitely our new go-to for pizza delivery nights! Thank you, Caradaro Club, for a delicious meal❤️
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Giuntoli
I’ve been a customer here for17 years and in my opinion it’s one of THE BEST pizzas in MKE. Always consistent. One of the tastiest sauces and some of the best sausage ever! Friendly staff and for an extra treat, try their garlic bread. Delicious! Weekends can be super busy. Best times during the week. Reasonable prices make this my #1 choice for pizza! 👍❤️😊
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Molly Frank
My absolute favorite pizza in Milwaukee! Such good flavor and quality every time. They also have the friendliest and most welcoming staff!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wally Gulumian
Best pizza in Milwaukee!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Raymond Duncan
This business helps the Martin Drive Neighborhood with local community events. Ingredients are fresh with the dough. This is the place you go to if you want a classic, thin crust pizza that won't make it to leftovers or beyond one day because everyone will eat it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesy Garlic Bread, Mozzarella Marinara, Large Cheese Pizza, The Works Pizza, Mushroom and Onion Pizza, Pepperoni Sausage Pizza, Deluxe Pizza
Jeanene Ennis
This was one of the best pizzas Ive ever had. Super crispy crust. Bottom crust held up to all the toppings. Great flavor on sauce. And the owner was SO nice and told us the history of the place while we waited for our togo order. We WILL be back!!
Mimi L
Excellent thin crust pizza! We love the quality ingredients including flavorful tomato sauce and the sausage. Very fair prices given the quality. We always do takeout. Highly recommend this local pizzeria!
Michael Hilden
Great pizza! Thin, crispy, and savory. A perfect cook! Shout out to the garlic bread strips. Very light and well seasoned.
Owner was so accommodating and friendly. Just makes you feel like home
Neil Chakrabarti
When I came in to dine in, I ordered ahead using the online menu as we were in a rush to have a quick dine in meal and get home. The pizza wasn't started until we got there and took about 30 minutes to arrive. The owner had never given us a menu when we sat down. When we received the bill, there was no itemization. I had referenced the prices online from the website and the owner stated that the prices were from 2008 and so didn't reflect current prices. The breakdown of costs didn't make sense to me even after I discussed it with the owner. He asked if he should provide discounts to me after explaining it and I felt awkward to be in that position as a customer. There should be a clear menu available to customers with current prices both in store and online and the final bill should be itemized explaining all charges. I believe we were also charged for garlic strips even though we had referenced the coupon online for free garlic strips. The pizza didn't seem as good as a few years ago. The inside of the restaurant also had dirty lounge seating and the floors didn't seem to clean. The owner and the cook doubled as wait staff. We had pleasant conversation and their demeanor was friendly. This is a historic place and I believe the reputation it has should carry with it the basic experience of cost transparency and cleanliness for a restaurant that has been around so long and has become a tourist destination for many visiting Milwaukee.
doglvr895
Excellent pizza from Milwaukee's oldest pizzeria! We chatted with an older gentleman who took our order - mentioned we visited because of the Secret Milwaukee book - he is an absolute TREASURE! Pizza excellent!
Adeline Ballard
Meeting the owner, Wally, was reason enough to come. He's a glowing example of everything that makes the Midwest great - warm, good humored, and incredibly hard working. If there's a Milwaukee welcoming committee - Wally should be a member of it.
Beyond the beam of light that is Wally, the food was really fantastic. Delicious cracker crust pizza cooked to perfection with balanced and slightly sweet sauce. Everything had perfect ratios and there was immense care put into everything they served.
Grab a cold can of Schlitz and you've got a perfect evening with friends, family, and the amazing folks who own and operate the restaurant. Can't recommend it enough.
Matthew Martinez
Excellent pizza, great service and fun atmosphere.
Places like this are hidden gems!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Special Large, Garlic Bread, Cheesy Garlic Bread
Great pizza .. Milwaukee style at its finest! Cheese bread is amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful service and even better pizza. As visitors from Chicago we didn’t know about this place but the pizza was perfectly thin and crispy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered pizza delivery tonight and everything was fantastic! The order arrived right on time and the driver was super friendly. The pizza had the perfect balance of crispy crust, fresh toppings and a nice tomato sauce — you can really taste the quality ingredients. My husband also ordered a side of chicken tenders with french fries and he loved them....and he is super picky about his chicken!🐔
It’s hard to find delivery that’s both fast and consistently good, but this place nailed it. Definitely our new go-to for pizza delivery nights! Thank you, Caradaro Club, for a delicious meal❤️
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve been a customer here for17 years and in my opinion it’s one of THE BEST pizzas in MKE. Always consistent. One of the tastiest sauces and some of the best sausage ever! Friendly staff and for an extra treat, try their garlic bread. Delicious! Weekends can be super busy. Best times during the week. Reasonable prices make this my #1 choice for pizza! 👍❤️😊
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
My absolute favorite pizza in Milwaukee! Such good flavor and quality every time. They also have the friendliest and most welcoming staff!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in Milwaukee!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This business helps the Martin Drive Neighborhood with local community events. Ingredients are fresh with the dough. This is the place you go to if you want a classic, thin crust pizza that won't make it to leftovers or beyond one day because everyone will eat it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesy Garlic Bread, Mozzarella Marinara, Large Cheese Pizza, The Works Pizza, Mushroom and Onion Pizza, Pepperoni Sausage Pizza, Deluxe Pizza
This was one of the best pizzas Ive ever had. Super crispy crust. Bottom crust held up to all the toppings. Great flavor on sauce. And the owner was SO nice and told us the history of the place while we waited for our togo order. We WILL be back!!
Excellent thin crust pizza! We love the quality ingredients including flavorful tomato sauce and the sausage. Very fair prices given the quality. We always do takeout. Highly recommend this local pizzeria!
Great pizza! Thin, crispy, and savory. A perfect cook! Shout out to the garlic bread strips. Very light and well seasoned.
Restaurantji Recommends
Owner was so accommodating and friendly. Just makes you feel like home
When I came in to dine in, I ordered ahead using the online menu as we were in a rush to have a quick dine in meal and get home. The pizza wasn't started until we got there and took about 30 minutes to arrive. The owner had never given us a menu when we sat down. When we received the bill, there was no itemization. I had referenced the prices online from the website and the owner stated that the prices were from 2008 and so didn't reflect current prices. The breakdown of costs didn't make sense to me even after I discussed it with the owner. He asked if he should provide discounts to me after explaining it and I felt awkward to be in that position as a customer. There should be a clear menu available to customers with current prices both in store and online and the final bill should be itemized explaining all charges. I believe we were also charged for garlic strips even though we had referenced the coupon online for free garlic strips. The pizza didn't seem as good as a few years ago. The inside of the restaurant also had dirty lounge seating and the floors didn't seem to clean. The owner and the cook doubled as wait staff. We had pleasant conversation and their demeanor was friendly. This is a historic place and I believe the reputation it has should carry with it the basic experience of cost transparency and cleanliness for a restaurant that has been around so long and has become a tourist destination for many visiting Milwaukee.
Excellent pizza from Milwaukee's oldest pizzeria! We chatted with an older gentleman who took our order - mentioned we visited because of the Secret Milwaukee book - he is an absolute TREASURE! Pizza excellent!
Meeting the owner, Wally, was reason enough to come. He's a glowing example of everything that makes the Midwest great - warm, good humored, and incredibly hard working. If there's a Milwaukee welcoming committee - Wally should be a member of it.
Beyond the beam of light that is Wally, the food was really fantastic. Delicious cracker crust pizza cooked to perfection with balanced and slightly sweet sauce. Everything had perfect ratios and there was immense care put into everything they served.
Grab a cold can of Schlitz and you've got a perfect evening with friends, family, and the amazing folks who own and operate the restaurant. Can't recommend it enough.
Excellent pizza, great service and fun atmosphere.
Places like this are hidden gems!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Special Large, Garlic Bread, Cheesy Garlic Bread
Loading...