Pizzas always delivered hot and within an hour. It's good to dine-in at a west allis staple. They've been around a long time, eat the pizza and you'll know why!
Kim Brunner
Food is always good
Tina Geiger
A family favorite for decades. My go to is their pizza bread and side salad with their homemade French dressing. It's to die for. The owners are amazing and so nice. Prices are very decent.
Frederick Wacker
Great pizza !
Spencer Berg
Best pizza I've ever had!
Paul Lorenz
LOVE IT!!! Thin, crispy SMO! It's the only way to go! Great folks, great neighbors. Ol' timey charm. Cataro's is the best.
Dan D
Amazing pizza. Best in the area
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
RichieZ1000
First time eating here. I thought the food was great, the crust on the pizza was perfectly crunchy. We had Mozzarella sticks and they actually give you 6 so it's easy to split between 2 people unlike other places that only serve you 5. The garlic bread was very buttery and delicious. We will definitely be going there again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Small Pizza, Garlic Bread
Justin Allen
Great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vnw F
We have stopped here a few times for pizza. I am always happy with the pizza we get.
Perfect place to get a taste of Nonna's recipies! Barb waa great. We stopped by last night - looking for a neighborhood place to eat after visiting grandma at St Luke's. I have to give Google credit for sending us to West Allis & Cataro's. Don't expect a fancy place with a lot of woodwork - but do you expect great food at an amazing price and hustling service It's in a clean but simple atmosphere. We had lasagna, spaghetti with meatballs and mushrooms, and took a pizza to go. The garlic bread was a perfect compliment. Didn't have dessert ( Preserved our dessert appetite for Leon's...) and we'll have to return one day to sample more items and stay for dessert.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
wendy s
We just moved from the neighborhood and will miss being able to walk over for delivery. Everyone works so hard there and is always friendly. The food is absolutely amazing!!
Kristina Herrera
This little place has apparently been there forever. The pizza was really good, but the menu wasn't updated. They only had a few kinds of soda, not even root beer as the menu stated. It's kind of bland and dated in the dining room. One waitress ran the entire dining room on a Saturday night!
Kid-friendliness: Great place for families
Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Small Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Only1Love
Small place but nice italian food is being cooked. Also, not to mention, name one place that can make a scratch made meat sauce... I'll wait... Cataros italian Villa is definitely one place in West Allis you have to eat at if you are feeling italian food. Reasonable sized portions, and definitely one place where you can strike up conversations but also be bringing home some leftovers for later. Great taste and lots more to come.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Moira McAdams
Ballesteries isn't much further away for pickup, but we love Cataro's pizza!
Pizzas always delivered hot and within an hour. It's good to dine-in at a west allis staple. They've been around a long time, eat the pizza and you'll know why!
Food is always good
A family favorite for decades. My go to is their pizza bread and side salad with their homemade French dressing. It's to die for. The owners are amazing and so nice. Prices are very decent.
Great pizza !
Best pizza I've ever had!
LOVE IT!!! Thin, crispy SMO! It's the only way to go! Great folks, great neighbors. Ol' timey charm. Cataro's is the best.
Amazing pizza. Best in the area
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time eating here. I thought the food was great, the crust on the pizza was perfectly crunchy. We had Mozzarella sticks and they actually give you 6 so it's easy to split between 2 people unlike other places that only serve you 5. The garlic bread was very buttery and delicious.
We will definitely be going there again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Small Pizza, Garlic Bread
Great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have stopped here a few times for pizza. I am always happy with the pizza we get.
Restaurantji Recommends
Perfect place to get a taste of Nonna's recipies!
Barb waa great.
We stopped by last night - looking for a neighborhood place to eat after visiting grandma at St Luke's.
I have to give Google credit for sending us to West Allis & Cataro's.
Don't expect a fancy place with a lot of woodwork - but do you expect great food at an amazing price and hustling service It's in a clean but simple atmosphere.
We had lasagna, spaghetti with meatballs and mushrooms, and took a pizza to go. The garlic bread was a perfect compliment.
Didn't have dessert ( Preserved our dessert appetite for Leon's...) and we'll have to return one day to sample more items and stay for dessert.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just moved from the neighborhood and will miss being able to walk over for delivery. Everyone works so hard there and is always friendly. The food is absolutely amazing!!
This little place has apparently been there forever. The pizza was really good, but the menu wasn't updated. They only had a few kinds of soda, not even root beer as the menu stated. It's kind of bland and dated in the dining room. One waitress ran the entire dining room on a Saturday night!
Kid-friendliness: Great place for families
Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Small Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Small place but nice italian food is being cooked. Also, not to mention, name one place that can make a scratch made meat sauce... I'll wait... Cataros italian Villa is definitely one place in West Allis you have to eat at if you are feeling italian food. Reasonable sized portions, and definitely one place where you can strike up conversations but also be bringing home some leftovers for later. Great taste and lots more to come.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ballesteries isn't much further away for pickup, but we love Cataro's pizza!
Food: 5
Loading...