It's been a minute since I had Classic Slice. It used to be my go-to before I moved away from the NE side of Milwaukee. Four of us decided to jaunt around the East side where a Classic Slice used to be and was surprised to find it wasn't there. We looked it up and found the KK location. So after driving to Milwaukee's East side we then decided to head down to this KK location. At this point I would say we're going out of our way just to eat a slice here. But when we showed up they didn't have slices and were told it'd be a 45 minute wait. So we left. What tbe he'll happened? Is this why the East side location closed? Very disappointed to say the least. Thankful we have Sal's or Ian's when we want to come into town for a QUICK slice.
Sam Willett
Paid $11 each for two specialty slices, and it took about 30 minutes for the food to come out
TheRayMaynard
Very thin crust and not much topping. Not a good value for the price.
jojo dodo
The absolute best Pizza in Milwaukee especially if you just want a slice and especially to take out of town friends to or a cheap cute date. Just don't tell them the slice is going to be bigger than their head and watch the surprise on their faces when they get this freaky big slice of the tastiest NY style pizza outside of actual New York. My favorite is the Meatalica.
tatuaggio spesso
Best pizza I've had so far since moving to the area. Too expensive though
Veronica
Best pizza around.
Randy V.
Went in just before 8 pm on a Saturday 7/12. They told me they can’t make me anything because they were too busy making orders. Mind you. I was a walk in customer not a phone in. He then walked from behind the counter a was wiping down empty tables to look busy. Too busy to take an order huh. Hope the owner reads this.
keith barrett
Giant specialty slices. Was delicious!
Axe Graves
Great pizza, kind of a huge bummer they won’t deliver 1.7 miles down the road though because they “don’t deliver past 6th street”. Not a huge fan of places that put demographic stipulations on where they deliver to. We used to eat in a lot. Probably won’t anymore.
John Bolton
Absolute fire but a little expensive but what isnt expensive right now...
Amazing food. Their pizza is spot on. The vibes are really good too, they have classic arcade machines, and good seating. Overall this is 5 stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Krista Guckenberger
I'm not sure what the hype is. My husband said his pizza was fine, but the vegan pizza is an absolute disgusting mess. ? that's NOT "spy cheese." It looked like scrambled tofu, and it all tasted like nothing. I gave them another shot and ordered a byo with daiya, sausage, and pepperoni, and even that was just so bland. Probably doesn't help that they screwed up and gave me vegan sausage. The sauce seemed to be fairly good, but that's it. Otherwise, it was like eating a thin cardboard box. The service was less than stellar. The guy at the counter couldn't care less. I won't waste my time and ever be back. Toppers has a better vegan pizza and topperstix... And that's saying a lot.
Me and the wife come all the time and they know me now as the “heart attack pepperoni pizza” guy and I love it ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spinach and Artichoke Dip, Artichoke Dip, Slice of Pizza
Shannon Ludwig
My husband is super picky about his pizza and you guys nailed it! Crust was perfectly crunchy with the right amount of yummy sauce and melted cheese! Sausage was very flavorful also! And the cookies..crunchewy goodness!
It's been a minute since I had Classic Slice. It used to be my go-to before I moved away from the NE side of Milwaukee. Four of us decided to jaunt around the East side where a Classic Slice used to be and was surprised to find it wasn't there. We looked it up and found the KK location. So after driving to Milwaukee's East side we then decided to head down to this KK location. At this point I would say we're going out of our way just to eat a slice here. But when we showed up they didn't have slices and were told it'd be a 45 minute wait. So we left. What tbe he'll happened? Is this why the East side location closed? Very disappointed to say the least. Thankful we have Sal's or Ian's when we want to come into town for a QUICK slice.
Paid $11 each for two specialty slices, and it took about 30 minutes for the food to come out
Very thin crust and not much topping. Not a good value for the price.
The absolute best Pizza in Milwaukee especially if you just want a slice and especially to take out of town friends to or a cheap cute date. Just don't tell them the slice is going to be bigger than their head and watch the surprise on their faces when they get this freaky big slice of the tastiest NY style pizza outside of actual New York. My favorite is the Meatalica.
Best pizza I've had so far since moving to the area. Too expensive though
Best pizza around.
Went in just before 8 pm on a Saturday 7/12. They told me they can’t make me anything because they were too busy making orders. Mind you. I was a walk in customer not a phone in. He then walked from behind the counter a was wiping down empty tables to look busy. Too busy to take an order huh. Hope the owner reads this.
Giant specialty slices. Was delicious!
Great pizza, kind of a huge bummer they won’t deliver 1.7 miles down the road though because they “don’t deliver past 6th street”. Not a huge fan of places that put demographic stipulations on where they deliver to. We used to eat in a lot. Probably won’t anymore.
Absolute fire but a little expensive but what isnt expensive right now...
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing food. Their pizza is spot on. The vibes are really good too, they have classic arcade machines, and good seating. Overall this is 5 stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm not sure what the hype is. My husband said his pizza was fine, but the vegan pizza is an absolute disgusting mess. ? that's NOT "spy cheese." It looked like scrambled tofu, and it all tasted like nothing. I gave them another shot and ordered a byo with daiya, sausage, and pepperoni, and even that was just so bland. Probably doesn't help that they screwed up and gave me vegan sausage. The sauce seemed to be fairly good, but that's it. Otherwise, it was like eating a thin cardboard box. The service was less than stellar. The guy at the counter couldn't care less. I won't waste my time and ever be back. Toppers has a better vegan pizza and topperstix... And that's saying a lot.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Specialty Slice, Vegan Mke Pizza Slice
Hipster pizza place
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Love the “hole in the wall” store vibes here.
Me and the wife come all the time and they know me now as the “heart attack pepperoni pizza” guy and I love it ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spinach and Artichoke Dip, Artichoke Dip, Slice of Pizza
My husband is super picky about his pizza and you guys nailed it! Crust was perfectly crunchy with the right amount of yummy sauce and melted cheese! Sausage was very flavorful also! And the cookies..crunchewy goodness!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Avocado Salad
Loading...