Cold Spoons Gelato

5924 W Vliet St, Milwaukee
(414) 395-3111

Recent Reviews

Sort by
A Sato

They have “UPGRADE Tuesday” and you can get Medium cup for a price of small and Large for a price of Medium. It’s a great deal. Their gelato was tasty, sorbet was too sweet. I judge gelato places based on the color of their pistachios gelato, and this place looked natural and it wasn’t bright green (sign of artificial coloring). Sorbet was okay, hit and miss (guava and strawberry basil were both way too sugary and tasted like a gum flavor) but mango was nice. Overall, I rate it 4-4.5 star because the gelato was good for the price you pay! I probably won’t come if it wasn’t for the Tuesday deal tho.

Sam Reitinger

Excellent flavors

Doug Menson

Great product and service just like my hometown in Italy

P. Kahn

Great stop for a large selection of gelato. The small portion is pretty large and you get to choose two flavors! All of the choices we made as a group were delicious. The inside is pretty sparse, but that didn't impact us because we bought and walked. Check it out.

L C

Very nice gelato and sorbet. I got the grapefruit and strawberry basil which were both wonderful. The grapefruit was tart and refreshing. The basil strawberry was sweet with a bit of herb taste which was a wonderful refreshing twist. The serving size for a large is definitely enough for me. If they had pints that would be wonderful as I would definitely want one.

Goo Usa

Very nice product and great presentation, i liked the gelato. The service was good, but that’s where it ends. The serving sizes are baby sized, the small is almost the same size as large and i DONOT.like the star cups. The chest freezer on display had NO pints to buy and take home. which was very disappointing considering the small portion sizes for the price paid. The interior had very minimalistic decorations and the seats had a tear. Considering the area it was appropriate (ish) but could have a bit much more character. Definetly some room for improvement, considering the small portion sizes cold spoons wouldnt be my first choice of a place to stop

(FYI THE LARGE IS SMALLER THAN A SNACK SIZE MCFLURRY)

ADAM PERELLA

Gelato was okay.
Every time I'm there I see affogato the menu. When I order it, the staff turn around and then say, "The espresso machine is out of order."
I've been there over six times the past couple of years - this is more than irksome.

Chk1 2

This was not gelato. Couldn't get past first spoonful, as it had a weird aftertaste. I was disappointed the young lady barely put a couple tablespoon for $5 each...well my disappointment turned into disgust. A waste of $10.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Laila Doggie

Worst tasting chocolate Gelato I've ever tasted. My daughter got a different flavor and she said the same thing.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

polosavage1

Great gelato and sorbet. Extremely small servings for how expensive it is. I recommend that you get the PINT over anything, economically it's your best bet
You can get the LARGE which is literally 1 decent scoop for $7.25 or something or a whole pint for $9!!!!!!! Pink grapefruit is the best flavor and chocolate thai chili. Their hours aren't great but it is what it is. Every time I go there, it's absolutely dead inside. The staff are always great too. They may not know whats in every flavor but they're always patient as you try different flavor samples. All in all it's good but expensive. And some flavors taste similar. But I recommend the place to everyone.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

A M

Gelato was excellent (mixed berry). Inside the shop it smells like an old house (not technically a bad thing but just a thing). I will be back to try more flavors!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Gelato

Steve Wellenstein

Nice neighborhood spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gelato

Risto Eland (Christopher)

Colf Spoons has a kitchy/old-timey feels with a twist. Behind the counter area is a fanciful mural.I samped a number of players. They had flavors such as: Tiramisu, Caramel Sea Salt, Cappuccino, Mango, Mixed Berry, Pink Mango, The staff was very pleasant.I ultimately chose the Chocolate Tai Chili. I hear it a local favorite. I doubt I'd have ever paired these on my own, but this was definitely 1 of my favorite, culinary, plot t³wists in a long time. Besides delicious, perhaps the words comfort & whimsical might describe this best. Just like the decor.

Rachel Wasmund

Best gelato!! So many amazing flavors!

Gregory Z

Absolutely delicious! Drove from Kenosha Wisconsin to get some gelato and worth every mile/penny

Loading...