Im in utter shock, im a regular and have been goin here since almost the beginning. Heck even have come to know alot the staff/owners names. I pray Fixtures resolve what's goin on and pull thru-great place/food, seriously. Looking forward to you reopening! Even if you guys have to move location-I'll be there! Please come back 😢
I LOVE the meatball sandwich! It's the best in the area!
Divina Graika
If I could give NEGATIVE STARS I WOULD. I called multiple times just to place a carry out order and got no response , but when my boyfriend called they suddenly answered the phone immediately. Very concerning if it has anything to do with being biased towards people's names on the caller ID, but what do I know I only called 5 times and got no reply yet my boyfriend who has a Caucasian sounding name got a response the first time he called. Next we place our order, very simple order thin crust large pepperoni and cheese pizza and a personal thin crust cheese pizza for my son. My boyfriend goes to pick it up and they tell him they do not accept Apple Pay? It's 2026 lol like cmon there are very few businesses IF ANY that I know of that don't have Apple Pay. So we get the pizza , the pizza was DRENCHED with sauce to the point it is just dripping off the sides and just everywhere. There was hardly any cheese on the pizza mostly just a bunch of sauce and pepperoni spread at random. It just seemed very carelessly made and was not at all what we expected considering the price. My sons pizza also looked like a heated up mediocre pizza from Wal-mart. Lacked cheese as well although it was a CHEESE pizza. So immediately we tried to contact the restaurant directly to see if anything could be done , either re-made or refunded. Yet what do you know AGAIN NUMEROUS CALLS AND NO RESPONSE!! TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE!! ANY RESTAURANT THAT IS UNABLE TO DO SOMETHING AS SIMPLE AS ANSWERING THE PHONE SHOULD NOT BE IN BUSINESS!! WHY HAVE A PHONE THEN?? And if you're that understaffed that you cannot answer calls then maybe you should allow people to place orders online and deal with carry out orders that way. My boyfriend also said when he picked up the pizza it was dead in there and the phone is literally right on the counter near an employee, so not sure why calls are being ignored. Ultimately, a complete WASTE of time and money, since we paid for a pizza full of sauce and pepperoni so ig if you like pizza with NO CHEESE, I would say you'll love it. But considering this is Wisconsin and most love cheese, I doubt people will enjoy this place much longer. They definitely need to invest more in proper training on CUSTOMER SERVICE /ANSWERING PHONE CALLS as well as PIZZA MAKING. There are WAY BETTER OPTIONS in the area that KNOW HOW TO ANSWER THE PHONE AND HOW TO PROPERLY MAKE A PIZZA. Not just some crap that was SLOPPED together.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Aimeé Lopez
Our server, I believe her name was Alexis, was amazing!! Best pizza in milwaukee!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob Kranz
The pizza was excellent! I will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Will Bobo
We placed an order for 2 pizzas and garlic bread. One of the pizzas was not cooked thoroughly. I reached out to them, provided photos which they were nice and said they would refund the order. Then they didn’t. So I reached out again and just no response.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Aaron Burns
The Tin Widow deep dish is so thick and good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
salena kent
First time here!! Chad & Victor made our experience AMAZING!! Not only was the service amazing but the pizza And wings were also something to write home about!! We felt like we were at a REAL life CHEERS!! Right at home!! Can’t wait to share this place and our next trip with friends when we visit Milwaukee again!!!
Really love that Vic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Morgan
My family and I decided to come here before a Bucks game because we saw the mozzarella sticks and deep dish pizza and said “that looks amazing let’s go here.” The dim lighting and service were excellent and the atmosphere was so cozy. Definitely the best deep dish I’ve ever had!
First time. Service was ok. Never asked if we wanted more drinks. HEY KITCHEN, YA YOU! Your Pizza brought back wonderful memories of childhood!!! Get the deep dish Daddy! You will Not regret. As for kids , they serve a build your own za starting at $10. We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Lynn Parker
Pizza was good but not enough to get me to come back. Definitely worth a try. I like how the sauce is on top. But the crust was different, almost seemed not homemade. And the sauce was lacking a bit of flavor and spices.
Im in utter shock, im a regular and have been goin here since almost the beginning. Heck even have come to know alot the staff/owners names. I pray Fixtures resolve what's goin on and pull thru-great place/food, seriously. Looking forward to you reopening! Even if you guys have to move location-I'll be there! Please come back 😢
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, Garlic Bread, Artichoke Dip, Salad, Tin Widow Pizza, Cheese Bread
Delicious 🍕 and food 🤤
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I LOVE the meatball sandwich! It's the best in the area!
If I could give NEGATIVE STARS I WOULD. I called multiple times just to place a carry out order and got no response , but when my boyfriend called they suddenly answered the phone immediately. Very concerning if it has anything to do with being biased towards people's names on the caller ID, but what do I know I only called 5 times and got no reply yet my boyfriend who has a Caucasian sounding name got a response the first time he called. Next we place our order, very simple order thin crust large pepperoni and cheese pizza and a personal thin crust cheese pizza for my son. My boyfriend goes to pick it up and they tell him they do not accept Apple Pay? It's 2026 lol like cmon there are very few businesses IF ANY that I know of that don't have Apple Pay. So we get the pizza , the pizza was DRENCHED with sauce to the point it is just dripping off the sides and just everywhere. There was hardly any cheese on the pizza mostly just a bunch of sauce and pepperoni spread at random. It just seemed very carelessly made and was not at all what we expected considering the price. My sons pizza also looked like a heated up mediocre pizza from Wal-mart. Lacked cheese as well although it was a CHEESE pizza. So immediately we tried to contact the restaurant directly to see if anything could be done , either re-made or refunded. Yet what do you know AGAIN NUMEROUS CALLS AND NO RESPONSE!! TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE!! ANY RESTAURANT THAT IS UNABLE TO DO SOMETHING AS SIMPLE AS ANSWERING THE PHONE SHOULD NOT BE IN BUSINESS!! WHY HAVE A PHONE THEN?? And if you're that understaffed that you cannot answer calls then maybe you should allow people to place orders online and deal with carry out orders that way. My boyfriend also said when he picked up the pizza it was dead in there and the phone is literally right on the counter near an employee, so not sure why calls are being ignored. Ultimately, a complete WASTE of time and money, since we paid for a pizza full of sauce and pepperoni so ig if you like pizza with NO CHEESE, I would say you'll love it. But considering this is Wisconsin and most love cheese, I doubt people will enjoy this place much longer. They definitely need to invest more in proper training on CUSTOMER SERVICE /ANSWERING PHONE CALLS as well as PIZZA MAKING. There are WAY BETTER OPTIONS in the area that KNOW HOW TO ANSWER THE PHONE AND HOW TO PROPERLY MAKE A PIZZA. Not just some crap that was SLOPPED together.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Our server, I believe her name was Alexis, was amazing!! Best pizza in milwaukee!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was excellent! I will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We placed an order for 2 pizzas and garlic bread. One of the pizzas was not cooked thoroughly. I reached out to them, provided photos which they were nice and said they would refund the order. Then they didn’t. So I reached out again and just no response.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
The Tin Widow deep dish is so thick and good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time here!! Chad & Victor made our experience AMAZING!! Not only was the service amazing but the pizza And wings were also something to write home about!! We felt like we were at a REAL life CHEERS!! Right at home!! Can’t wait to share this place and our next trip with friends when we visit Milwaukee again!!!
Really love that Vic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family and I decided to come here before a Bucks game because we saw the mozzarella sticks and deep dish pizza and said “that looks amazing let’s go here.” The dim lighting and service were excellent and the atmosphere was so cozy. Definitely the best deep dish I’ve ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I love it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza and eggplant fries!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cold Beer
First time. Service was ok. Never asked if we wanted more drinks. HEY KITCHEN, YA YOU! Your Pizza brought back wonderful memories of childhood!!! Get the deep dish Daddy! You will Not regret. As for kids , they serve a build your own za starting at $10. We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Pizza was good but not enough to get me to come back. Definitely worth a try. I like how the sauce is on top. But the crust was different, almost seemed not homemade. And the sauce was lacking a bit of flavor and spices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...