I always see this spot posted all over Reddit so I thought it was time to check it out. It's a nice walk from the Third Ward and also right on the Green Line. Parking can get tight but there is a paid lot nearby. The place was pretty busy which caused slower service, but staff remained attentive. The bar and dining room both had plenty of seating. This would be a great spot for large groups! I ordered a glass of wine and the Eggplant Parmesan sandwich with a side caeser. I was disappointed in the wine list, especially for an Italian restaurant. The glass of wine I ordered was pretty stale which makes me think they might not sell a lot of wine. Again, odd for an Italian restaurant. The sandwich was excellent. It had perfectly crisp eggplant with a flavorful marinara and plenty of cheese. I like that they serve giardinera to add some extra crunch and spice to the sandwich. I would love to return for the pizza that I read so much about! The food was amazing!
Christopher Hoffman
Best pizza in Milwaukee. Excellent wings and eggplant fries too. Large booths so you can take little kids too. Great beer selection and friendly staff. My family tries to stop every time in town and I often grab some to go when driving through MKE.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patrick Nichol
Absolute favorite pizza in Milwaukee. My wife swears it's the best gluten free crust in the city! Our last visit they were on a bit of a wait and it was so worth it, the staff was moving quickly through the waitlist and absolutely knew what they were doing to make sure everyone was taken care of. Very impressive operation in terms of food and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doug Lenski
I absolutely love the atmosphere in this place. You have to check it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatballs, Chicken Wings, Chicken Parm Sandwich, Italian Beef
Todd H.
Really good food at Fixture. Had artichoke dip, wings and deep dish pizza. Enjoyed them all. Sat at the bar and was served by Matt, he was awesome. Great guy that was easy to talk to. He works hard and is still very personable. Made are experience very fun. We ended up staying about 3 hrs. Busy place, but great vibe. We will definitely be going back.
Drew Lied
Simply put, it's overrated. Definitely not worth of 4.7 Stars on Google. THE GOOD - location, atmosphere, honey ginger wings (and wings in general), our waitress, how quick we got our food. THE BAD - the male host placing people... memorably bad experience.Thin crust is better than deep dish but it is by no means some of the best pizza in the city.Not a staple but worth coming to annually.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Chris Adamczyk
best wings in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Salad
Dominic S.
I have recommended this place as the best wings in Milwaukee about 50 times, but things change. The last time I went, I figured people make mistakes and sometimes bad food gets served so I didn't complain, paid for my meal and headed out. This time I was also extremely disappointed so I feel a bad review isn't too extreme. I'm not sure how, but the wings were somehow soggy yet completely dry inside, the cooks must have fried/baked them to hell before they went on the grill, a complete 180 from fixture a year ago when wings were perfect every single time. I've had the server before and she was nice, but when I complained there was no apology or care in the world, simply "what do you want instead?" I know it seems picky but I was a waiter for 10 years and you always apologize when someone has a bad experience especially if the food clearly wasn't enjoyed. The apps were delicious and pizza was okay, half the garlic was hard as a rock. Not angry, just sad that this place is just another restaurant that's a shell of its former self.
My Name
Had appetizers. Fried zucchini taste burnt. The wings they put on the grill too, I guess for the grill marks, but they taste burnt too. Pizza is great. No more appetizers here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Tamara R.
Delicious pizza, fresh toppings. The wings are fire! Great friendly service. We will be back !!
Pizza is out of this world good! Can't wait to come back! We got a large thin pepperoni. Seems like they do the sauce on top of the cheese maybe? Then the toppings... and wow so good!
Wyatt G.
Trendy high ceiling wood cladded old Milwaukee bar atmosphere with some uncomfortable high backed seating on sometimes very wonky wobbly tables.... Get a booth or sit at the bar if possible. Now for the pizza.... AMAZING! Great tasty toppings on a wonderful Milwaukee style pizza with top notch tasting crust. I get the "tin widow". It seems to have all the good things I like about pizza. Also, try the hot honey on the pizza! The staff does good work and there is always something good on tap for the beer snob in the group like me. Weekends get busy.
Ryan Mears
First visit, will definitely be back! WP Tattoo pizza, wings, cocktails were all great!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Honey Great on Everything, Chicken Wings
Katie Keen
Very disappointed after coming here about once a month for the last two years we had some rude service from the manager on Tuesday 2/6/2024 I always come and get the margaritas they used to be my favorite for some reason that night they tasted water down so I kindly asked for a new one just to get attitude. The manager came over and said it’s a premix and there’s no way they can fix it, they used to have so much flavor spice with the perfect amount of tequila. Don’t know if it was a bad bartender or if he was just having a bad day when I asked for something similar they told me all the drinks are premixed. I don’t appreciate the attitude that’s just how they’re made. It’s gonna taste the same. They lost a customer. I’m also disappointed that all of their drinks are premixed. $10 drink is not even hand made anymore? The eggplant fries were extremely salty. I couldn’t even eat them also an order of 12 wings You are not allowed to order half-and-half flavors, so you have to pay an extra dollar in order to order six & six. the garlic Parmesan wings were extremely disappointing. I didn’t even eat them. Pizza was OK nothing crazy I normally order the buffalo wings and pizza which were good but other than that the service made the experience horrible and I will not be back Which sucks because it’s one place I really like to hang out I even liked it so much I celebrated my birthday there in November and everything so I’m very disappointed. I always had a good experience with the redhead but other than that everybody else is so rude.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Samantha Mehring
Really delicious, and unique pizza. Really nice staff and owners.
I always see this spot posted all over Reddit so I thought it was time to check it out. It's a nice walk from the Third Ward and also right on the Green Line. Parking can get tight but there is a paid lot nearby. The place was pretty busy which caused slower service, but staff remained attentive. The bar and dining room both had plenty of seating. This would be a great spot for large groups! I ordered a glass of wine and the Eggplant Parmesan sandwich with a side caeser. I was disappointed in the wine list, especially for an Italian restaurant. The glass of wine I ordered was pretty stale which makes me think they might not sell a lot of wine. Again, odd for an Italian restaurant. The sandwich was excellent. It had perfectly crisp eggplant with a flavorful marinara and plenty of cheese. I like that they serve giardinera to add some extra crunch and spice to the sandwich. I would love to return for the pizza that I read so much about! The food was amazing!
Best pizza in Milwaukee. Excellent wings and eggplant fries too. Large booths so you can take little kids too. Great beer selection and friendly staff. My family tries to stop every time in town and I often grab some to go when driving through MKE.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolute favorite pizza in Milwaukee. My wife swears it's the best gluten free crust in the city! Our last visit they were on a bit of a wait and it was so worth it, the staff was moving quickly through the waitlist and absolutely knew what they were doing to make sure everyone was taken care of. Very impressive operation in terms of food and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I absolutely love the atmosphere in this place. You have to check it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatballs, Chicken Wings, Chicken Parm Sandwich, Italian Beef
Really good food at Fixture. Had artichoke dip, wings and deep dish pizza. Enjoyed them all. Sat at the bar and was served by Matt, he was awesome. Great guy that was easy to talk to. He works hard and is still very personable. Made are experience very fun. We ended up staying about 3 hrs. Busy place, but great vibe. We will definitely be going back.
Simply put, it's overrated. Definitely not worth of 4.7 Stars on Google. THE GOOD - location, atmosphere, honey ginger wings (and wings in general), our waitress, how quick we got our food. THE BAD - the male host placing people... memorably bad experience.Thin crust is better than deep dish but it is by no means some of the best pizza in the city.Not a staple but worth coming to annually.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
best wings in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Salad
I have recommended this place as the best wings in Milwaukee about 50 times, but things change. The last time I went, I figured people make mistakes and sometimes bad food gets served so I didn't complain, paid for my meal and headed out. This time I was also extremely disappointed so I feel a bad review isn't too extreme. I'm not sure how, but the wings were somehow soggy yet completely dry inside, the cooks must have fried/baked them to hell before they went on the grill, a complete 180 from fixture a year ago when wings were perfect every single time. I've had the server before and she was nice, but when I complained there was no apology or care in the world, simply "what do you want instead?" I know it seems picky but I was a waiter for 10 years and you always apologize when someone has a bad experience especially if the food clearly wasn't enjoyed. The apps were delicious and pizza was okay, half the garlic was hard as a rock. Not angry, just sad that this place is just another restaurant that's a shell of its former self.
Had appetizers. Fried zucchini taste burnt. The wings they put on the grill too, I guess for the grill marks, but they taste burnt too. Pizza is great. No more appetizers here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Delicious pizza, fresh toppings. The wings are fire! Great friendly service. We will be back !!
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is out of this world good! Can't wait to come back! We got a large thin pepperoni. Seems like they do the sauce on top of the cheese maybe? Then the toppings... and wow so good!
Trendy high ceiling wood cladded old Milwaukee bar atmosphere with some uncomfortable high backed seating on sometimes very wonky wobbly tables.... Get a booth or sit at the bar if possible. Now for the pizza.... AMAZING! Great tasty toppings on a wonderful Milwaukee style pizza with top notch tasting crust. I get the "tin widow". It seems to have all the good things I like about pizza. Also, try the hot honey on the pizza! The staff does good work and there is always something good on tap for the beer snob in the group like me. Weekends get busy.
First visit, will definitely be back! WP Tattoo pizza, wings, cocktails were all great!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Honey Great on Everything, Chicken Wings
Very disappointed after coming here about once a month for the last two years we had some rude service from the manager on Tuesday 2/6/2024 I always come and get the margaritas they used to be my favorite for some reason that night they tasted water down so I kindly asked for a new one just to get attitude. The manager came over and said it’s a premix and there’s no way they can fix it, they used to have so much flavor spice with the perfect amount of tequila. Don’t know if it was a bad bartender or if he was just having a bad day when I asked for something similar they told me all the drinks are premixed. I don’t appreciate the attitude that’s just how they’re made. It’s gonna taste the same. They lost a customer. I’m also disappointed that all of their drinks are premixed. $10 drink is not even hand made anymore? The eggplant fries were extremely salty. I couldn’t even eat them also an order of 12 wings You are not allowed to order half-and-half flavors, so you have to pay an extra dollar in order to order six & six. the garlic Parmesan wings were extremely disappointing. I didn’t even eat them. Pizza was OK nothing crazy I normally order the buffalo wings and pizza which were good but other than that the service made the experience horrible and I will not be back Which sucks because it’s one place I really like to hang out I even liked it so much I celebrated my birthday there in November and everything so I’m very disappointed. I always had a good experience with the redhead but other than that everybody else is so rude.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Really delicious, and unique pizza. Really nice staff and owners.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Var Gallery Pizza, Salad