We were just passing through, but we just loved this place, the good, and the gregarious staff so much that we may have to manufacture excuses to return to Milwaukee just to get more pie.
Kurt Schneider
Terribly slow
Cori Duran
this is hands down the best place in mke. food is always delicious and the pies NEVER disappoint. if all pies were like this, pie would rule the world.
rebel darkwolf
Stopped on my trek to catch the ferry. I was on foot, so I ordered to go. I was greeted by the friendly staff and managed to walk in, order, and out all in 15 minutes! Even more impressive, accomplished during lunchtime rush on Saturday 😀 Turkey Club is deliciously flavorful and a side ceaser salad. The dressing: simply wonderful! All topped off with a refreshing cherry limeade 🍒 I 100% recommend top of the list for lunchtime!
Dan DeVillers
Open on Memorial day...thanks.
Also open on the 4th of July...thanks!
Ashley Green
Quite possibly the best burger I have ever had!
Kelli Bundy
I loved this place so much! I sat at the counter and the owner took care of me. He made me feel like we've been friends for years. The food was great, all the servers were so friendly, pies were awesome. 10/10
David R Todd
It looks like a neighborhood hole in the wall, but Honeypie Cafe on KK in Bay View is now two full spaces with quick seating and a tasty menu. Service was on point. Delicious Eggs Benedict & roasted potatoes. I left with a slice of Key Lime pie. I was happy I did. So good. I'm not in love with the interiors, but it just feels a bit empty. Not my stomach. Consistently good. 👍 I'll be back.
Tim Witmer
Service at the bar was a bit slow, but understandable given it was a busy Sunday morning. But the food more than made up for it. Amazing breakfast casserole and eggs Benedict, one of the best brunches I've had in a while.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Avery Thompson
Cute little spot with a great biscuit and gravy. Burrito was nothing special. Tried the garlic rosemary Bloody Mary very interesting. Definitely worth the stop.
Kid-friendliness: Small kids menu but burger was good
This is a great little place with good coffee and amazingly big sticky buns.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Walker Manske
Very chill dinner spot, better known for breakfast and brunch. Nice staff, not a lot of hard liquor choices but local beers, and filling dishes, nice ambiance. I'd recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Banana Cream Pie, Burger, Fish Fry
Alida Mau
Insanely good food. I had the hash and got two pies to go and everything was fantastic. Some of the best pie I’ve had in Wisconsin.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dasha Tanner
Such a cute little spot and the pie was delicious. I loved the ambiance, every little nook was thoughtfully decorated. It had a very warm and inviting feel, alongside the whole staff being warm and inviting.
I enjoyed the breakfast burrito, i think i would’ve enjoyed it more if the potatoes inside were in smaller pieces. LOVED the truffle fries omg they were so good. the pie was also so good, we had to get our piece to go because we were too full leaving there. definitely worth a visit
We were just passing through, but we just loved this place, the good, and the gregarious staff so much that we may have to manufacture excuses to return to Milwaukee just to get more pie.
Terribly slow
this is hands down the best place in mke. food is always delicious and the pies NEVER disappoint. if all pies were like this, pie would rule the world.
Stopped on my trek to catch the ferry. I was on foot, so I ordered to go. I was greeted by the friendly staff and managed to walk in, order, and out all in 15 minutes! Even more impressive, accomplished during lunchtime rush on Saturday 😀 Turkey Club is deliciously flavorful and a side ceaser salad. The dressing: simply wonderful! All topped off with a refreshing cherry limeade 🍒 I 100% recommend top of the list for lunchtime!
Open on Memorial day...thanks.
Also open on the 4th of July...thanks!
Quite possibly the best burger I have ever had!
I loved this place so much! I sat at the counter and the owner took care of me. He made me feel like we've been friends for years. The food was great, all the servers were so friendly, pies were awesome. 10/10
It looks like a neighborhood hole in the wall, but Honeypie Cafe on KK in Bay View is now two full spaces with quick seating and a tasty menu. Service was on point. Delicious Eggs Benedict & roasted potatoes. I left with a slice of Key Lime pie. I was happy I did. So good. I'm not in love with the interiors, but it just feels a bit empty. Not my stomach. Consistently good. 👍 I'll be back.
Service at the bar was a bit slow, but understandable given it was a busy Sunday morning. But the food more than made up for it. Amazing breakfast casserole and eggs Benedict, one of the best brunches I've had in a while.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Cute little spot with a great biscuit and gravy. Burrito was nothing special.
Tried the garlic rosemary Bloody Mary very interesting. Definitely worth the stop.
Kid-friendliness: Small kids menu but burger was good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger, Fries
Restaurantji Recommends
Great service and food! Returning customer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a great little place with good coffee and amazingly big sticky buns.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very chill dinner spot, better known for breakfast and brunch. Nice staff, not a lot of hard liquor choices but local beers, and filling dishes, nice ambiance. I'd recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Banana Cream Pie, Burger, Fish Fry
Insanely good food. I had the hash and got two pies to go and everything was fantastic. Some of the best pie I’ve had in Wisconsin.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such a cute little spot and the pie was delicious. I loved the ambiance, every little nook was thoughtfully decorated. It had a very warm and inviting feel, alongside the whole staff being warm and inviting.
I enjoyed the breakfast burrito, i think i would’ve enjoyed it more if the potatoes inside were in smaller pieces. LOVED the truffle fries omg they were so good. the pie was also so good, we had to get our piece to go because we were too full leaving there. definitely worth a visit
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries
Loading...