Ian's Pizza Milwaukee | Story Hill

The pizza has so much variety! I love the barbecue chicken pizza with ranch had a surprising taste! Will come back again!

As a die hard NY style pizza fan, this is as close as you’re going to get in Milwaukee. I generally love a basic slice, but Ian’s specialty slices are always outstanding—in particular Smokey the Bandit (always available), Eternal Hamnation, and Italian Beef. The salads are great and the service is always friendly.

Wow no parking, ever

Great pizza! Nice late night spot

If you’re looking for some great slices of pizza, this is the place. My favorite is their Mac n cheese pizza. Every time we venture to Milwaukee we make sure a stop at Ian’s is in order. They are also open late and the prices are very reasonable.

I was on Reddit and this restaurant was recommended. We went on uber eats last night and ordered 2 large pizzas. First one was the mushroom pizza and the second pizza was pepperoni and sausage. The pizza was disgusting because literally burnt the bottom of the pizza therefore we kept getting an aftertaste. I made a joke that they didn’t want this first time customer to be a repeat customer. Anyways, decided to leave a review because we were so disappointed after reading reviews on Reddit.

Pizza was terrible, took 15 min for a few pepperoni slices. Once received there was barely any cheese covering the slices. Thanks for the tomato pizza!.

Edit: I am going to add another two stars off the strength of the compensation we recieved and Professionalism from Ryan. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Ian's is our favorite pizza. Closest we have found to NY/NJ pizza since moving here.

Parking: Parking is good, but NOT during Brewer baseball.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza, Macaroni and Cheese Pizza, Other, Cheese Pizza, Large Cheese Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Sausage

Ordered for pick up today (10/28) for around 5pm and I walked in for my order and no one bothered to ask, ‘how can I help?’ Then a man with his two kids walked in after me and they asked him if he had a pick up order or if he wanted anything. So I thought, ‘well maybe they’ll just help me in a second.’ I was wrong. Three more guys ended up walking in and they helped them first. So now I had 4 guys who all skipped me. I just stood there, feeling so ignored. I had to walk over to the two ladies who were just standing around and try to get one of the ladies attention- I had to wave like hello I’m here!!! and I just had 4 guys skip me and you guys didn’t even ask if I was there for pick up order or if I wanted anything! I even brought it up to one of other workers that was putting the pizzas in the oven, he just smiled a little bit and didn’t even offer an apology. Make sure you ask EVERY single person that walks in your door if they are there for pick up or if they want anything IN THE ORDER THAT THEY CAME IN. DON’T MAKE PEOPLE FEEL IGNORED!!!

Service: 1

I used to really like the pizza but now there is a lot of new staff and the last three pizza I’ve got have been completely black on the bottom it’s really disappointing 24 bucks for burnt pizza and I come here all the time makes me sad

Food: 2

Super nice staff and really great pizza ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’ve been eating this pizza for years and I genuinely hate how the employees pick and choose when they are able to do certain things. I pay extra for them to add buffalo sauce to my Mac and cheese pizza. Keep in mind, I’ve had this same pizza, the same way for years. It’s very crazy to me that it’s really a big deal over something so simple that I’m willing to pay for. The only thing I was ever told is they won’t do it when it’s busy which is perfectly fine. Then my pizza is burnt so at this point, it’s time to retire this place and find somewhere that listens to their customers….

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Great, fresh, quick pizza! And slices ready to go! Ordered the vegan sausage and vegan Mac n cheese. Delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Other, Vegan Pizza, Vegan

There are 2 Ian’s pizza in Milwaukee. My son and I went to the Mets game on Sunday and he recommended Ian’s because he had it once before and it’s hard to find good pizza in Wisconsin coming from Long Island. We stopped and the bigger one for lunch and it was just as described, fantastic! The second one was closer to the stadium and was much smaller but just as good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza

This is my second time buying pizza from this place and it will be my last time. Both times the pizzas were burned. I asked for a lightly baked pizza the second time but it didn't help. I paid for bacon to be added to the veggie pizza but it was not added. Also i think there is just not enough cheese on these pizzas to make them taste good. Both pizzas were pretty expensive too.

Food: 1