McGillycuddy's

1135 N Water St, Milwaukee
(414) 278-8888

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Agnar Odinson

BEST FRENCH FRIES IVE EVER HAD.
Seriously, this place, and whoever runs the kitchen, needs to be famous for these fries.
There's no comparison for the crisp pub flake, and the unique flavor.
I dont know how else to put it people.... these fries are really good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mitch Bentley

Phenomenal pub to visit! I’m not from the state. Came out there this last weekend and visited multiple bars with great experiences overall. But this spot was by far one of the best spots I’ve been to throughout the Country. The staff was magnificent, fun, attentive, and extraordinary. Went back the second night and had nothing short of a great time. Highly encourage anyone to check this spot out. Tylee and Kennie were both amazing to us!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

D J Landscaping

took my real id and refused to give it back

W Scott Decker

Great happy hour❗👍❗😊

Lucas Schumacher

Edward was very kind, personable, and a true ambassador of this establishment!! A must give location!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex Edwards

Won 🏆 a swag bag!
Thanks McGillycuddy 😊

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dennis Goering

Fun bar. Food was good but a little slow. However, it was NCAA basketball tournament weekend. I'd go back.

Patrick Prabhu

Great friendly staff. I love going here to watch a game with friends.

Kaiya Lee

Kicked out of my friends even though they were of age. Bouncers refused to look at a second form of ID. People were willing to show multiple forms of ID because they are 21 years of age and the main bouncer refused to let them.

Breanna Simons

Rain was the absolute sweetest bartender! We came from up north and it felt like a dive bar with the happy hour pricing and kind staff. I always come back here when we go to Milwaukee because of the FOOD!!! best bar food you’ll ever have in your life ❤️

Abigail Glackin

It was a great experience!! I loved it there except the fact that I left my keys there and did not receive an email back about my keys!

Max Peck

Terrible staff very rude and it’s only underage kids and very expensive

Anisah Wilks

McGillicuddys have the best service with the friendliest staff! For packer game they offer FREE breakfast buffet. Eggs, sausage, bacon, toast, potatoes and more! Always a great time!

Delena “Nina Bean2323” Joseph

Didn't eat but my drink was good I went here for Boo fest ft Bar Crawl Nation and was tossed by a bull that's a plus in my book

Wheelchair accessibility: No

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 4

Megan MacNaughton

I came here last weekend on a pretty crowded night. The doorway was packed with people so when I stepped in, I attempted to step to the side so I could be out of the way while I grabbed my ID out of my bag. The bouncer thought I was just trying to pass through I guess so he grabbed my arm extremely hard and yelled at me to show my ID as I was actively reaching for it? It was startling to be grabbed that hard, and I actually now have a big bruise on my arm where he jabbed his thumb into me. This is the only time a man has left a bruise on me and I’m honestly disturbed and never want to/never will come back. Disappointing because I’ve been coming here for years

Service: 1

Loading...