It was my first time trying this place and it was really good. I got the double pan pizza and the crust was really tasty. I will for sure order again
Michele Michalak
Pizza was decent. This is the second time we ate there. The first time we waited about 20 min after our quoted time. This time I was quoted this visit was an hour or maybe a few minutes over. We arrived an hour after I ordered and waited an additional 30 min for our pizzas to be ready. Everyone who came in after us was waiting for their food past pickup time as well. The pizza is fine, but with all the good pizza options in the area there is no reason for me to continue going to a place that keeps me waiting on average 20-30 minutes after my quoted time.
Mark S.
I wish, I could post negative stars... this place has gone down hill over the years, even the pizza is questionable these days... I stopped and ordered an Italian beef sandwich and side of fries to go, they were ice cold and I only live a few blocks away... Arby's would've have been a better choice and they suck...
D Carls
I've been a customer since the old building they were in. I will say best pies in the state. Anything I have ordered was always delicious. Now my work Buddies ask for it. Great place, great price and excellent pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pizza with Pepperoni Mushrooms Green Pepper and Onion, Marinara Sauce, Garlic Bread, Thin Crust Pizza
Meyer Deaton
Pizza was amazing. Tried the Buffalo and Cheese/Sausage/mushroom. Both pizzas were on point! A little more pricy than most places but you get what you pay for.
Great za. Went in for a slice. Forgot how good it was. Go grab a couple of pies for the college basketball tournie or for a nice family time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pizza with Pepperoni Mushrooms Green Pepper and Onion, Sausage
Brian H
Been going here for years... Not sure how I've never reviewed them.. weird... Anyway, pretty much my favorite pizza in the Metro area (They have the accolades to prove it)...Pizza this good takes time to make though, so be ready for a Wait when you call it in.. in six years they messed up my order once, just once.. probably a new guy or something, honest mistake... I emailed them about it.. Boom, free credit towards our inevitable next order. You have to love a company that stands by its product... Especially when it's this good... Btw, make sure to save your half off tabs on your boxes.. After 10 pizzas it's half off one... And that can be worth some good cash if you get their largest most loaded pizza ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Pan Cheese Pizza
Nicole Gulrud
I ordered the Real Meal Deal and I’m 100% sure I ordered a sausage and onion pizza. I was delivered a plain cheese pizza. When I called I was told that’s what I ordered on their end. That’s not what I put in my cart. Oh well not worth it and won’t order again. In the trash went the plain cheese pizza after 1 slice.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Sebastian
I always get mozzarella sticks and their stuffed scotty extreme
Really good pizza, I always get the meat lovers stuffed pizza with the sauce on top, just WOW.
William L.
The first time I tried it it was excellent the second time wasn't bad either . But it seems like the pizza has been going downhill , and one time the driver forgot our bread things that we ordered and we had to take a credit with which we were really looking forward to them . I understand that happens but this last time took the cake . They charge $5 for delivery so we didn't feel that we needed to do a tip the driver had the audacity to come back after we didn't put a tip on the credit card receipt and asked us if we forgot the tip . That is really bold and a big turn off . I understand that these people look for tips to make their wages but they ought to take that up with their employer cuz the employer is charging five bucks for a delivery
Maj C
The stuffed pizza was totally worth the price.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tim S.
This is one of the best pizza joints in the Milwaukee area. I ordered a deep dish and a thin crust. Both were outstanding.
Food: 5
Thomas Hughlett
Unfortunately, I cannot give an accurate review on the food because they closed before posted closing time without proper notice. I got there at 9:25pm on 1/11/24 after a nice evening run, looking forward to a good pizza, and the posted closing time on here was listed as 10pm. When I got there, the only potential indication of them being closed was one or two signs being off, but lights were on, doors were unlocked, there was no sign indicating early closure, etc. I stepped in and was informed they closed early to keep labor costs down. I can understand that to an extent, but I also went out of my way to get here based on the knowledge that this business was open until 10pm. It was a frustrating experience.So far this was my first and only visit. I hope to try again in the near future (perhaps not as close to closing time) and I hope for a more pleasant experience that can bring this review up to 4 or 5 stars.
It was my first time trying this place and it was really good. I got the double pan pizza and the crust was really tasty. I will for sure order again
Pizza was decent. This is the second time we ate there. The first time we waited about 20 min after our quoted time. This time I was quoted this visit was an hour or maybe a few minutes over. We arrived an hour after I ordered and waited an additional 30 min for our pizzas to be ready. Everyone who came in after us was waiting for their food past pickup time as well. The pizza is fine, but with all the good pizza options in the area there is no reason for me to continue going to a place that keeps me waiting on average 20-30 minutes after my quoted time.
I wish, I could post negative stars... this place has gone down hill over the years, even the pizza is questionable these days... I stopped and ordered an Italian beef sandwich and side of fries to go, they were ice cold and I only live a few blocks away... Arby's would've have been a better choice and they suck...
I've been a customer since the old building they were in. I will say best pies in the state. Anything I have ordered was always delicious. Now my work Buddies ask for it. Great place, great price and excellent pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pizza with Pepperoni Mushrooms Green Pepper and Onion, Marinara Sauce, Garlic Bread, Thin Crust Pizza
Pizza was amazing. Tried the Buffalo and Cheese/Sausage/mushroom. Both pizzas were on point! A little more pricy than most places but you get what you pay for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Sausage, Thin Crust Pizza
Great za. Went in for a slice. Forgot how good it was. Go grab a couple of pies for the college basketball tournie or for a nice family time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pizza with Pepperoni Mushrooms Green Pepper and Onion, Sausage
Been going here for years... Not sure how I've never reviewed them.. weird... Anyway, pretty much my favorite pizza in the Metro area (They have the accolades to prove it)...Pizza this good takes time to make though, so be ready for a Wait when you call it in.. in six years they messed up my order once, just once.. probably a new guy or something, honest mistake... I emailed them about it.. Boom, free credit towards our inevitable next order. You have to love a company that stands by its product... Especially when it's this good... Btw, make sure to save your half off tabs on your boxes.. After 10 pizzas it's half off one... And that can be worth some good cash if you get their largest most loaded pizza ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Pan Cheese Pizza
I ordered the Real Meal Deal and I’m 100% sure I ordered a sausage and onion pizza. I was delivered a plain cheese pizza. When I called I was told that’s what I ordered on their end. That’s not what I put in my cart. Oh well not worth it and won’t order again. In the trash went the plain cheese pizza after 1 slice.
Food: 2
Service: 2
I always get mozzarella sticks and their stuffed scotty extreme
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks
Excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Really good pizza, I always get the meat lovers stuffed pizza with the sauce on top, just WOW.
The first time I tried it it was excellent the second time wasn't bad either . But it seems like the pizza has been going downhill , and one time the driver forgot our bread things that we ordered and we had to take a credit with which we were really looking forward to them . I understand that happens but this last time took the cake . They charge $5 for delivery so we didn't feel that we needed to do a tip the driver had the audacity to come back after we didn't put a tip on the credit card receipt and asked us if we forgot the tip . That is really bold and a big turn off . I understand that these people look for tips to make their wages but they ought to take that up with their employer cuz the employer is charging five bucks for a delivery
The stuffed pizza was totally worth the price.
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is one of the best pizza joints in the Milwaukee area. I ordered a deep dish and a thin crust. Both were outstanding.
Food: 5
Unfortunately, I cannot give an accurate review on the food because they closed before posted closing time without proper notice. I got there at 9:25pm on 1/11/24 after a nice evening run, looking forward to a good pizza, and the posted closing time on here was listed as 10pm. When I got there, the only potential indication of them being closed was one or two signs being off, but lights were on, doors were unlocked, there was no sign indicating early closure, etc. I stepped in and was informed they closed early to keep labor costs down. I can understand that to an extent, but I also went out of my way to get here based on the knowledge that this business was open until 10pm. It was a frustrating experience.So far this was my first and only visit. I hope to try again in the near future (perhaps not as close to closing time) and I hope for a more pleasant experience that can bring this review up to 4 or 5 stars.