The pasties are really good in the morning time they fresh
Parking: The parking sucks
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Spicy Whole Pickle, Carrot & Onion Mix, Fresh N Hot Pasty with Beef Gravy Add On, Hot Pasty, Pecan Pie Slice
Gandalf the Grey
I just drove up here from Cudahy on Saturday and found out they're not open. There are hours in the store and online that they are open today. A lot of time, gas, and patience in busy traffic for nothing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
David Lee
Employee refused to take an old school 20 dollar. State that if she took the money her boss will be mad. She don’t have a marker and told me I will have to go get change in order to pay for my food. I tried showing her how to check money without a marker and she even refused. I told her you just lost a customer for life because she even refused to get help to verify and had an attitude.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Frannie Riedijk-Dean
This has been one of my favorite places to eat when visiting Milwaukee. The fresh savory ingredients in the perfect pastry. Great service fast and friendly. I have enjoyed eating pasties for at least 50 years. I had to buy a bunch taking some back to Georgia. Yum.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasty by the Dozen, Frozen, Lemonade, Fresh N Hot Pasty with Beef Gravy Add On
Erik Smith
The UP of Michigan is known as the home of the Pasty. I’ve had several while visiting up there, all good. Reynold’s brings that flavor, quality and tradition to Milwaukee. I only wish I had found this place sooner! I was in and out in about 4 min with a hot Pasty that was more than enough for lunch! Highly recommend Reynold’s!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Neil Aggen
Love their Pasties. The place smells amazing even before you get in the door. The staff are very friendly and happy for your business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasty by the Dozen Day-Old Dozen
Bonnie Weston
Love Reynolds past us. Being eating them for 40 years. But moved up to the Wisconsin Dell's and can't find them
snowblo1
Okay, seriously, like what in the heck is going on with this place? They must be under new ownership....or something?
Anyhow, I've been making several attempts to call and inquire about methods of payment. I'm still not sure if they're just cash only or what???
And just this morning, not too long ago (8:45AM) I'm in the area after traveling from Menomonee Falls where I now reside, and thought, let me just stop over there and ask in person. I pull up & the sign clearly says open from 9:30 to 6:30, Tuesdays thru Saturdays. I decided to just park in front of the shop and wait. I then notice a little after 9AM, the Boost Mobile right next to Reynolds pasties had opened their doors indicating that they were open for business, inviting customers to come on in. I'm thinking okay, wonderful, the pasty shop should be opening in a bit. Well, 9:30 comes and goes and the freaking shop did not open. I should have known better because I couldn't smell any goodness wafting in the air. Mad as heck but didn't want my wait to be in vain, I stay until after 10AM & nope! Doors still locked. OPEN sign still not lit. Ugh! I get out and double check the sign to see if maybe they were closed due to observance of the 4th of July. Nope, no indications of that. So yeah, I'm done trying. Was going to buy 2 dozen par-baked pasties, as well as 1 dozenn hot for the family. We grew up on 36th & Meineke and haven't had these things in years. So disappointing ?
So edit. Just did some research & found out that the original owner apparently retired and sold the pasty shop to some Nigerian guy that used to own African Hut. I believe it used to be on the East side, I think. Not sure, I've never been and have yet to try any African cuisine. But my point is, damn, I wish that man would have never sold his place. He used to be open at the times that were indicated. And they used to open way earlier back in th day. Oh well, I'm just heartbroken.
Service: 1
Donna Benton
Went to buy 2 Pastys and we received baked frozen ones. You/We could tell the difference between fresh and frozen
Atmosphere: 2
Recommended dishes: Fresh N' Hot Pasty
Tiffany Expose-Davis
I wanted to add that I wish they accepted Door Dash or opened a location on the far North side.
Haven't had a pastry since 2008 when I moved to the south. The only place I wanted food from when I got here for a visit. Glad to see they haven't lost a step. It was worth the 900 miles.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh N' Hot Pasty
Shereatha perry
Ive been going to this place for years and always had good service and food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tanara Carson
Customer service and food was awesome
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pecan Pie Slice, Fresh N' Hot Pasty
DOC HIPHOP
Great Kind Reguards ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A iknow User
I won't be returning to this location because the BLACK AFRICAN EMPLOYEES ARE VERY DISRESPECTFUL.... SHE PLACED MY CHANGE ON THE COUNTER WITH ATTITUDE. REYNOLDS PASTIES ISNT LIKE THEY USE TO BE.I WONT BRING MY MONEY HERE ANYMORE. THIS BUSINESS HAS TO GET BETTER RESPECTFUL CUSTOMER SERVICE. PASTIES are freaking DRYNO GRAVY, NO CARROTS, THE TASTE NASTY!!! TERRIBLE
The pasties are really good in the morning time they fresh
Parking: The parking sucks
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Spicy Whole Pickle, Carrot & Onion Mix, Fresh N Hot Pasty with Beef Gravy Add On, Hot Pasty, Pecan Pie Slice
I just drove up here from Cudahy on Saturday and found out they're not open. There are hours in the store and online that they are open today.
A lot of time, gas, and patience in busy traffic for nothing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Employee refused to take an old school 20 dollar. State that if she took the money her boss will be mad. She don’t have a marker and told me I will have to go get change in order to pay for my food. I tried showing her how to check money without a marker and she even refused. I told her you just lost a customer for life because she even refused to get help to verify and had an attitude.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
This has been one of my favorite places to eat when visiting Milwaukee. The fresh savory ingredients in the perfect pastry. Great service fast and friendly. I have enjoyed eating pasties for at least 50 years. I had to buy a bunch taking some back to Georgia. Yum.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasty by the Dozen, Frozen, Lemonade, Fresh N Hot Pasty with Beef Gravy Add On
The UP of Michigan is known as the home of the Pasty. I’ve had several while visiting up there, all good. Reynold’s brings that flavor, quality and tradition to Milwaukee. I only wish I had found this place sooner! I was in and out in about 4 min with a hot Pasty that was more than enough for lunch! Highly recommend Reynold’s!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love their Pasties. The place smells amazing even before you get in the door. The staff are very friendly and happy for your business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasty by the Dozen Day-Old Dozen
Love Reynolds past us. Being eating them for 40 years. But moved up to the Wisconsin Dell's and can't find them
Okay, seriously, like what in the heck is going on with this place? They must be under new ownership....or something?
Anyhow, I've been making several attempts to call and inquire about methods of payment. I'm still not sure if they're just cash only or what???
And just this morning, not too long ago (8:45AM) I'm in the area after traveling from Menomonee Falls where I now reside, and thought, let me just stop over there and ask in person. I pull up & the sign clearly says open from 9:30 to 6:30, Tuesdays thru Saturdays. I decided to just park in front of the shop and wait. I then notice a little after 9AM, the Boost Mobile right next to Reynolds pasties had opened their doors indicating that they were open for business, inviting customers to come on in. I'm thinking okay, wonderful, the pasty shop should be opening in a bit. Well, 9:30 comes and goes and the freaking shop did not open. I should have known better because I couldn't smell any goodness wafting in the air. Mad as heck but didn't want my wait to be in vain, I stay until after 10AM & nope! Doors still locked. OPEN sign still not lit. Ugh! I get out and double check the sign to see if maybe they were closed due to observance of the 4th of July. Nope, no indications of that. So yeah, I'm done trying. Was going to buy 2 dozen par-baked pasties, as well as 1 dozenn hot for the family. We grew up on 36th & Meineke and haven't had these things in years. So disappointing ?
So edit. Just did some research & found out that the original owner apparently retired and sold the pasty shop to some Nigerian guy that used to own African Hut. I believe it used to be on the East side, I think. Not sure, I've never been and have yet to try any African cuisine. But my point is, damn, I wish that man would have never sold his place. He used to be open at the times that were indicated. And they used to open way earlier back in th day. Oh well, I'm just heartbroken.
Service: 1
Went to buy 2 Pastys and we received baked frozen ones. You/We could tell the difference between fresh and frozen
Atmosphere: 2
Recommended dishes: Fresh N' Hot Pasty
I wanted to add that I wish they accepted Door Dash or opened a location on the far North side.
Restaurantji Recommends
Haven't had a pastry since 2008 when I moved to the south. The only place I wanted food from when I got here for a visit. Glad to see they haven't lost a step. It was worth the 900 miles.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh N' Hot Pasty
Ive been going to this place for years and always had good service and food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Customer service and food was awesome
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pecan Pie Slice, Fresh N' Hot Pasty
Great Kind Reguards ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I won't be returning to this location because the BLACK AFRICAN EMPLOYEES ARE VERY DISRESPECTFUL.... SHE PLACED MY CHANGE ON THE COUNTER WITH ATTITUDE. REYNOLDS PASTIES ISNT LIKE THEY USE TO BE.I WONT BRING MY MONEY HERE ANYMORE. THIS BUSINESS HAS TO GET BETTER RESPECTFUL CUSTOMER SERVICE. PASTIES are freaking DRYNO GRAVY, NO CARROTS, THE TASTE NASTY!!! TERRIBLE
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...