SALA - Modern Sicilian Dining

There is nothing bad about Sala...from the diverse menu, to having the food prepared your way....great atmosphere, service, clean etc...
HIGHLY RECOMMEND

Food was good but service was AWFUL!! We waited over 20 minutes for water which was given to us by a waitress waiting on another table who said our waitress would be right there. She came by us about 15 min later. Unacceptable !

The food was wonderful. In our party of 4 we had a pizza, the super Sugo, and a pasta dish. All were outstanding. The waitstaff was kind and helpful and the atmosphere was good. The only downside was the time. The place was about half full, yet it took 2 hours to get in our order, get served, and finish. A bit long I think.

This place is great but so overpriced! I had just returned from trip to Florence and Rome so may have been more accustomed to those prices but spent well over $120 for a dinner for 2 (we had pizza, Cesar salad, split pasta dish and 2 glasses of red wine). We were charged extra for splitting our pasta! Again great great food but the price was far too steep.

The best chicken parmesean in Milwaukee

Beth server was great !!! Very attentive!! Food was excellent loved the Carciofi !! N the flourless chocolate cake was da bomb. Halibut special in Dijon sauce was great. The old fashioned sour uses sour syrup as a heads up. It was wife's retirement n they made it very special with candle in the canoli n a card as well!! Very thoughtful !!!! Definitely go back plus want to try the pizza.

Great dining experience. I like their fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp. I do feel it's somewhat overpriced, however . Pasta and sauce with some standard sized shrimp shouldn't cost almost $40. I enjoyed the arugula salad and the bruschetta was very flavorful and crispy. I love their creamy Italian sodas and always get the hazelnut flavor. Our server was phenomenal. Great place for a birthday dinner.

Great food and great service.

The food was quite good but the salad could be improved alot
The Service wasn't very good however
Seriously a 20m wait for a sent-back dish is way too long and we didn't get any drink refills

Jeez,, the experience here was bad. The place smelled bad, and the service wasn’t great either. The server had headphones on and seemed uninterested, like she didn’t care at all. I got a chocolate croissant, and it was hard as a rock , definitely not fresh. Not planning on coming back. :)

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Just had a drink, but surely will be back for a meal!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Pricey, but really good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We hadn’t been to Sala in over 10 years, since we moved from the area. We were regulars for a long time, beginning when Teresa and Tony opened the restaurant as Sala da Pranzo. How lovely to return and find it as wonderful as before. Still the best — thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

1. Ran out of menus, the restaurant wasn’t even full and we had to wait at our table for water and menus when we had a reservation.
2. Service was unreliable . Our server was obviously tired and overworked and unfortunately took it out on us with bad customer service.
3. Food was… interesting. Menu was confusing and didn’t have common options for an italian restaurant. The only thing that could have saved this was the pasta (we did order appetizers and they were not good), my chicken alfredo was good but my boyfriends shrimp still had their tails on, which was confusing.
4. Don’t bother making a reservation, online said they were completely booked both inside and outside during the time we ate. But outside was bare and inside wasn’t full at any point in our saturday night dinner time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Cozy and inviting atmosphere. Food is superb.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5