The ice cream here is superb! We had both the gingerbread chocolate (house made gingerbread!) and the salted waffle cone, and both were terrific. Glad they sell at the Outpost, too, for when we need an ice cream fix. They even had a vegan choice (chocolate), and told us they usually have 2 of them, but were out of one. There are no bad choices!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heaven Valdes
Very small awkward space. Limited flavors. The ice cream was okay. My son loved it and you get alot of ice cream for the price.
Nicole Williams
They had a lot of cool vegan options but fell flat for regular flavors to try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
ELVIRA ROCKWELL
Did u know that in the summer of 1790 George Washington spent 5000 bucks on just ice cream? Even from the beginning we were in love with it. This shop always has the best ice cream with options for vegans. It's right on the patio. So u can take your decadent delight, bask in the light and relax. It's the little things.
Daniel Joseph
Mediocre at best. I mean, it’s ice cream, so if you’re passing by…I suppose. Even so, lazy service, average ice cream…oh well,
Amy Heck Collins
The vegan vanilla was good for vegan ice cream, but the regular flavors all have eggs in them... So doesn't that make them custard? Finding ice cream, not custard, seems to be impossible in this town. Husband says his was just mediocre.
Maggie B.
The ice cream was great! I got butter pecan which I loved. I really like that they list the allergen information on each flavor at the counter and there are vegan options!
Kayla K.
Big thumbs down. Terrible service. My ice cream was melted and icy. Wouldn't recommend it.
Patrice Campbell
This was a nice unexpected find and experience. I loved the location, and the ice cream was fantastic. I had a single scoop which was huge. Overall five stars
Enjoyed the ice cream. Had coffee toffee ice cream per previous recommendation. Recommend to my friends. This weekend they had the east side festival. Good times. Ice cream hard to find because it is inside a "food hall" with other restaurants called collective eateries. Attached photos from outside of building.
WillowLute
My sister and I got cookies and creme, would reccomend!
Emily Parr
i love coming here! the ice-cream selection is always different but the flavors are always so well thought out so that it's hard to choose. the girl that works there Abby is so kind, she always offers a flavor to try if you mention one you're thinking about. always a pleasant experience. thanks!!!
Lucas B.
The presumed owners were working (a husband and wife) and they gave us the smallest bit of ice cream imaginable. We got about half a pint for $10 (2 bowls). If you want to waste your money, this is a perfect place for you.
Amir G.
Wow! We stopped in for a bite to eat and stayed for some small batch, Wisconsin dairy approved, ice cream. The portions are HUGE and they have some great flavors. We went with 3 (yup, 3)...traditional strawberry, cold brew & toffee, and a "lucky charms" type cereal ice cream. Each was outstanding and super creamy, not too sweet, and the perfect texture for a rich ice cream. The strawberry was spot on. The Cold Brew had just enough coffee flavor that it wasn't overpowering. And well, the lucky charms cereal one was just flat out awesome. Who doesn't love the great marshmallows in lucky charms?!
Super
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Chocolate Brownie
The ice cream here is superb! We had both the gingerbread chocolate (house made gingerbread!) and the salted waffle cone, and both were terrific. Glad they sell at the Outpost, too, for when we need an ice cream fix. They even had a vegan choice (chocolate), and told us they usually have 2 of them, but were out of one. There are no bad choices!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very small awkward space. Limited flavors. The ice cream was okay. My son loved it and you get alot of ice cream for the price.
They had a lot of cool vegan options but fell flat for regular flavors to try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Did u know that in the summer of 1790 George Washington spent 5000 bucks on just ice cream? Even from the beginning we were in love with it. This shop always has the best ice cream with options for vegans. It's right on the patio. So u can take your decadent delight, bask in the light and relax. It's the little things.
Mediocre at best. I mean, it’s ice cream, so if you’re passing by…I suppose. Even so, lazy service, average ice cream…oh well,
The vegan vanilla was good for vegan ice cream, but the regular flavors all have eggs in them... So doesn't that make them custard? Finding ice cream, not custard, seems to be impossible in this town. Husband says his was just mediocre.
The ice cream was great! I got butter pecan which I loved. I really like that they list the allergen information on each flavor at the counter and there are vegan options!
Big thumbs down. Terrible service. My ice cream was melted and icy. Wouldn't recommend it.
This was a nice unexpected find and experience. I loved the location, and the ice cream was fantastic. I had a single scoop which was huge. Overall five stars
Restaurantji Recommends
Enjoyed the ice cream. Had coffee toffee ice cream per previous recommendation. Recommend to my friends. This weekend they had the east side festival. Good times. Ice cream hard to find because it is inside a "food hall" with other restaurants called collective eateries. Attached photos from outside of building.
My sister and I got cookies and creme, would reccomend!
i love coming here! the ice-cream selection is always different but the flavors are always so well thought out so that it's hard to choose. the girl that works there Abby is so kind, she always offers a flavor to try if you mention one you're thinking about. always a pleasant experience. thanks!!!
The presumed owners were working (a husband and wife) and they gave us the smallest bit of ice cream imaginable. We got about half a pint for $10 (2 bowls). If you want to waste your money, this is a perfect place for you.
Wow! We stopped in for a bite to eat and stayed for some small batch, Wisconsin dairy approved, ice cream. The portions are HUGE and they have some great flavors. We went with 3 (yup, 3)...traditional strawberry, cold brew & toffee, and a "lucky charms" type cereal ice cream. Each was outstanding and super creamy, not too sweet, and the perfect texture for a rich ice cream. The strawberry was spot on. The Cold Brew had just enough coffee flavor that it wasn't overpowering. And well, the lucky charms cereal one was just flat out awesome. Who doesn't love the great marshmallows in lucky charms?!