Señor Gordito’s

1801 E North Ave, Milwaukee
(414) 287-9900

Recent Reviews

Sort by
T D

If you order take out, be sure to count your items before leaving. They missed 3 items from our order. Guacamole was also bland and had no flavor. Wish we would have read reviews about this place before ordering

Food: 2

Gina Brown

$3.60 for guacamole in a small I mean small container

Food: 2

Service: 3

Mutonya Mutonya

If you are looking for authentic Mexican food, look no further! I had my torta which rekindled memories of my life in México City. Pocket friendly, fast and ample waiting space as they prepare your takeaway orders! Going back very soon!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

mike jones

I’m not gone lie I was disappointed I payed 14$ last night for a nacho that looked like it was worth 5$ I literally had a pile of chips and a scoop of meat literally little to no cheese and it wasn’t even flavorful never again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Amanda Panda

I ordered 3 birria tacos with cilantro and onion. What did I get? I got 3 tacos with lettuce, tomato and sour cream… 🤢 I didn’t even eat them because they looked disgusting. I also ordered a 16oz horchata for $9.20 but what did I get? I got a single can of Coca Cola, not even a price adjustment or refund for receiving an incorrect order. I would not recommend this place to anyone, not even the guests that stay at the hotels I work at.

Amanda Robinson

I ordered through uber eats on 7/18/2025. They gave me a $2.00 can of Coca Cola to “substitute” my $9.00 16oz horchata. There’s no way a can of Coca Cola costs $9.00 anywhere! I ordered birria tacos with cilantro and onion, that’s it. What did they send me? They sent me some tacos with lettuce, tomato and sour cream on them… Gross. I didn’t even eat the food because I don’t like lettuce, tomatoes or sour cream on birria tacos. They ruined my meal and I will not recommend this restaurant to any of the guests that stay at our hotel. I won’t even recommend uber eats anymore for no refund, not even a price adjustment.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dana Florian

I sure wish I would have looked at the reviews for this place before I stopped. But after working 16 hours straight and through the night I was hungry and seen this place. Now I will say I am from Chicago so it's it is hard for me to find a Mexican place that actually can stand up to Chicago food. There's a few places that are good this place is absolutely disgusting. Not only do they charge you almost $17 for a dinner plate tacos, but the amount of steak that was on all three tacos should have been on one taco. I have never ever seen literally a couple pieces of meat on a taco especially because there's two shells. The shells were hard as rock on the top even the onions had no flavor. There was no seasoning whatsoever on the meats. The beans were horrible just the texture alone was disgusting. It literally tastes like a cheap can of beans definitely not homemade. And the rice is 100% out of a box. This place is not going to be in business long because with the amount of bad reviews that they have, and them not stepping up their game and trying to make the place better, it will close. I took all the meat off all three tacos and put it on one so I spent $17 for one taco. I truly hope that people look at reviews before they eat at this terrible place. The guy has no idea how to make Mexican food and he's Mexican but on top of that he was not very inviting or even in a good mood. All I got out of him was telling me 5 minutes. In 5 minutes to make the plate I should have known right then and there and told him to give me my money back. Do not eat here it's Milwaukee there are other places that are good this place I give zero Stars

Food: 1

Service: 2

Jeff Anderson

Good food! A bit pricey.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amy Sue Combs (Amy-Sue)

Portions were pathetic

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

alexis soto

Don’t be fancy, its for tacos and donuts

Sherif Diop

Didn’t have donuts when I was there. I was heartbroken.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Erica Williams

I ordered a beef tacos and the meat didn't look too appetizing. It was really dark and hard. They were also cold. You guys need to work on your culinary skills on how long you should keep your beef🤷🏿‍♀️

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Yesenia

The hot Cheetos on the elote they served, to go, are STALE no crunch at all. So disappointed

Samoya K

They need to start wearing gloves and washing their hands. Picking noses and touching food doesn't mix

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Alisha Hall

I ordered the Chicken Chimichaunga dinner and got a meal that was not worth buying. The Chimichaunga was not cooked but on the outside. When you opened it up the cheese was not melted and there was more dough then meat. Oh and it was cold. Then gave me a tiny cup of rice. The milkshake was the only good item. This meal cost $25.47 I drove to get it. So disappointed never had bad food from there until today

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Loading...