SmallPie

2504 E Oklahoma Ave, Milwaukee
(414) 763-7067

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Katy Shea

Really disappointed I ordered a cold brew and instead they gave me a nitro cold brew, which was $12! I talked to the people there and they refused to change my bill since I already had it. I actually thought they had accidentally added something else on my bill, so I went to check. Drink prices are also not listed,which makes it challenging .

Honni Al-Juma

The service is top notch, the blueberry turkey sandwich is something I tried on a whim and it’s my favorite now! Do yourself a favor and try it!

Maggie Benson

The food was great, service was good and loved the plants. Will be going here again and it’s a great stop if you’re going for a walk in the area.

Meredith W

We liked the pie and drinks, but wished there was more options for the drinks. Outdoor seating was great, and loved all the plants!

Gabe B

Best pies

John Loza

Delicious pie, tasty coffee

Steven Warenda

Way overpriced

Hannah Schwane

Went in today around 3:45pm will full intention of getting a vegan cake slice. I wanted a sweet treat so badly and I was deciding between going to Whole Foods or small pie. I decided on small pie because I usually try to buy local/small. I had my mind made up on flavors before I even got there as I called beforehand to find out what they were. Upon entering the store I looked at the slices and realized the one I didn’t plan on getting looked better. So, I asked the employee which one was better. She didn’t like either of them. As much as I appreciate honestly, you lost a customer. I turned around and left because there were no other vegan options and the employee had nothing good to say about the product. The only reason I left any stars is because I’ve had something from there before that I liked when I had been one other time. However, the other time the service was sub par too though. I’m usually a good review kind of person, but I haven’t really had any good experiences here and I likely won’t be back.

Benjamin Michael

i've never been. does anyone know why the bus always stops here?

Scott Kutcka

A quaint little bakery that impresses with every visit. Celebrating Pi Day with a classic slice of apple pie.

B HE

Very nice quint place to stop, have been past in a few times and thought I would stop, nice pleasant staff and excellent pies,next time will try their food, a must stop

Tim Flood

Stopped to pick up 1 cherry hand pie & 1 slice of key lime pie totaled over $18! Sadly the cherry was soggy, obviously old, less cherry filling and past its prime - for that price disappointing. Help was friendly.

Cameron

Staff was very friendly and helpful made me rough morning a little better

adoramann

Stopped to ask for the bakery that sold Lumpia, my mistake wasn't this place. Clerk was not sure but could recall hearing of a bakwry just opening somewhere near this location.

John Smith

Door county hand pie yum yum!! Broccoli and cheese hand pie 🤤

Loading...