Tarantino's Pizzeria
2577 S 68th St, Milwaukee
(414) 545-5373
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
best pizza around the owner is great guy and his sister delivers fast .
There is no place to eat inside this place but the pizza is phenomenal it is like the old Maria's pizza used to be with a crust that's real nice and late and fluffy and good love this place
Staff was great and pizza was absolutely phenomenal. Great mom and pop shop for pizza.
Glad Grub Hub was offering $8 off $25 because it was not even worth what I paid. Bland sauce, canned mushrooms, skimpy toppings. I'll stick with Pizzaria Scotty.
Excellent tasting Thin Crust Pizza, Love the crust. 1st time customer and I will definitely be going back. Used to be a Maria's, Papa Luigis, and Pepi's Pizza Person, now Tarantino's Pizzeria will get my business when I want to pick up or have my pizza delivered, since they do NOT have any seating. This Pizza Restaurant is Pick up or Delivery ONLY. If you like thin crust Pizza I'd definitely recommend you give this Longstanding Family Run Pizza Place a try!
The owner of this pizza place is amazing is pizza you can't stop eating it is awesome homemade recipe
Got to try the spaghetti w/ sauce last night because as I soon as I walked in the house from work, my daughter handed me her to-go container that her grandma got for her, saying it was nasty and the noodles were hard…
Well, she’s pretty picky and I was hungry, so I decided to try it…. Yeah, wow, she was right! It was basically noodles with canned tomato paste and some herbs tossed in…. It was extremely bland and tasteless. Zero flavor. And dry as hell. Not even dousing it with Parmesan could save it….
I got through about 3/4 of the container(I was hungry) and had to stop. Honestly, I’d be ashamed to serve that to customers if I owned this place. It was probably the worst spaghetti with sauce I’ve ever had from any restaurant. It was bad….
If you want a good quick spaghetti from a restaurant, I highly recommend Tanino’s on 76th. That’s where we usually go for takeout spaghetti. FAR better!
We ordered a pepperoni and mushroom and got a pepperoni and sausage and we STILL give this place FIVE STARS. It's that good.
Tried so many pizzas can never really find that "perfect" pizza and I have to say i think I finally found the best pizza! Crust was thin and crispy, sauce was so tasty all in all phenomenal pizza! Thank you Tarantinos for making the most yummiest pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was completel raw in the middle. The crust was burnt. The box and crust were one in the middle. I won’t order here again
Restaurantji Recommends
Last time I ordered a pizza from here, my then-gf found a large clump of human hair beneath the cheese, after we had eaten about half of the pizza. She puked, pizza was trashed, and I’ll never order from here again.
The people were great, and the spot is cool with its vintage style. But never again will I eat from here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Tried 3 different times over a month to call in an order for carryout. No one answers the phone...
Service: 1
Pizza was good breaded mushrooms was a waste of 6 dollars right in the garbage
Atmosphere: 3
Pizza is absolutely delicious.. knock on wood I have never had a bad experience here!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Never meet your heroes. Apparently the occupation “famous director” was actually all a facade for being a literal pizza.
Loading...