The Conroy | Contemporary Dining

Overall- this place is decent. New years ever dinner there was loud with the singer they had and I could barely hear my friends over it. Food was good. But definitely over priced. I understand what they're going for being a modern elevated supper club. But it seems to have missed the mark. The ambiance is amazing and the drinks were well balanced.

Food was very good. Atmosphere was awesome. Everyone was very friendly but unbelievably shortstaffed. Felt bad for the ones that showed up on Christmas cause they were in the weeds the entire time. Couldn't get a cocktail before dinner and getting drinks during dinner was next to impossible. Again, no one's fault, but had we known they were gonna be with a skeleton crew, we would've gone a different night to get the full experience.

First time there. Terrible experience, will not be back. Only 2 servers for 70+ people. Because servers didn't want to work on Christmas Eve. Should have probably closed for the holiday.

Modern Supper Club, amazing ambiance, fabulous drinks, service impeccable, décor 10 out of 10

Amazing ambiance, staff, service, and food! Really enjoyed the caviar flight, and the A5 Wagyu was outstanding! Highly recommend!

We left truly impressed—this is the kind of elevated dining Milwaukee rarely sees, and every dish showed real craftsmanship. The Royal Osetra caviar was pristine and presented with the elegance you expect from major-market restaurants. The wagyu carpaccio with grilled bread was outstanding—silky, rich, and perfectly balanced by the char on the toast. Even the beet and goat cheese salad felt unexpectedly refined, bright, and beautifully plated. The Roasted Seafood Tower was the star of the evening: lobster, shrimp, scallops, and mussels all cooked perfectly and served piping hot with an addictive chili-garlic butter. For entrées, the A5 wagyu was indulgent and expertly handled, while the Ribeye Au Poivre delivered a deep char and a peppercorn sauce with real finesse. We finished with tiramisu and crème brûlée, both textbook perfect and far better than what most steakhouses offer. Service was polished, pacing was excellent, and the entire experience felt curated and genuinely special. Easily one of the finest meals we've had in Milwaukee—and we're already planning our return.

We thoroughly enjoyed our meal at the new Conroy restaurant. The decor is upscale and chic, the lighting is low, and our booth was comfortable. Our waiter was very attentive as were the support staff. Our cocktails were delicious, and we each ordered different entrees. All 3 met or exceeded our expectations....steak, scallops and salmon. The tiramisu for dessert was amazing! It was not an inexpensive meal, but those are hard to come by these days! We'll definitely visit again and rec to our friends to try.

Great experience, would highly recommend as a date night for couples looking for excellent service and even better cuisine options. Everything we had was exceptional

Had a fabulous meal last night. Staff was very attentive to everything. We tried the wagyu carpaccio and it was excellent. 4 different entree selections and we all thought each one was fantastic. Don't forget to leave room for dessert. The white chocolate cheesecake was delicious. Thanks for a fun evening! Highly recommended!!

Food was beautifully balanced and the drinks were amazing. Brooke was an informative server with great suggestions. The music could be updated.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent experience. The service was top notch. Went for our anniversary and really enjoyed ourselves. Great cocktails. Good was above average, but will be back to try new menu for their supper club.

Definitely don’t come here if you are in a hurry, or if you don’t want to wait over a hour in total. Service was very slow, took 10 minutes to have been brought menus. Server was a little passive aggressive as well. Food was good but waited for a salad that never came, which they tried to charge us for. 😭

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Food had good flavor, but I anticipated more BANG. Drinks were satisfying and delicious. Staff very attentive, friendly, and helpful. Atmosphere is dimmed, romantic, soothing, without straining your eyes. Each table has a good light source. We will definitely come back to try different plates. Thank you for a great date night.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

This is a great place for a cocktail and some high quality food all served with some attention to presentation. You feel like it could be in NYC or DC. The happy hour prices are outstanding!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is a great place for a cocktail and some high quality food all served with some attention to presentation. You feel like it could be in NYC or DC. The happy hour prices are outstanding!