The Dark Horse Tavern

1517 S 2nd St, Milwaukee
(414) 837-3016

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Don Pintux

It's a very nice place. Wide variety of beers, spirits and cocktails. It's a good place to have a good time.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

David Labitzke

First time ever coming, and the bartender had such good vibes. Really enjoyed my time here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

DomingoS R

It is a very nice and quiet bar. I loved it.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Angela C

Mondays with Charlie not a bad crowd. Mostly service industry/regulars.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Flora Aguilar

Dava is a really marvelous woman friend bartender she makes u feel important special matters thank you. Also there is Shawn he just had a birthday Happy Birthday. These people are so cool make u feel hey I'm coming back.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Eric Fowle

Great place, great service, great drinks. Thanks Charlie!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Mike Metzger

The bar’s location is on my way to other places like Fluid and Walker’s pint. Back in 2021, I was being re-introduced to the Milwaukee LGBTQ+ community after living in Denver for the past 8 years. Before leaving, I volunteered at the AIDS Resource Center of Wisconsin, helped organize the gay softball World Series in 2009, and also volunteered at American Family Field for the LGBTQ+ softball league SSBL. I ran into this bar walking from Woodys to Walkers Pint. I walked in and was greeted by the bartender, Charlie. I recently parted ways with some of my gay “bar friends” and needed a change of scenery. Not knowing my story Charlie made conversation and made me feel welcome. In about 7-8 minutes meeting Charlie, he knew I happened to be gay. Since then I make it a point when friends visit for pride I take them to this place. All of the bartenders have always treated me with great respect and I enjoy the atmosphere. With me standing tall at 4’9” I’m happy to visit this inclusive place where I’ve happened to develop friendships with people who happen to be straight, oh and people who happen to be gay as well.

David Duncan

Walked in with two of my friends (we’ve been coming here a couple of times a week for months), and a bartender we had previously been very cordial with suddenly asked all of us for our IDs. I’m 33, clearly above 21 (as are my friends). We happily complied (I even made a joke about feeling young), and ordered our drinks. He asked us if we wanted to open or close the card. While we were trying to figure it out, he makes a loud, slick-ass comment about how he’s only closing the card once, so we need to decide. I called him out for being rude, and he said under his breath, “I’m not serving these fa@@0+$.” After we said that we could pay with another card if necessary for a second transaction, he said the credit card processing fees were too high, and acted like it was personally coming out of his check. He was embarrassed because we called him out for being rude and homophobic, so he dumped out our drinks and told us to go. We were stunned and didn’t put up any resistance, but the bartender had to make one more slick-ass remark about not worrying about pushing in the chairs as we left because “that’s my job”. We have spent hundreds at this bar over the past couple of months because I was trying to avoid my ex, but we will NEVER be back to this bar unless they get rid of that homophobic bartender.

Zeen Absolute

What more can you ask for from a working folks bar?! Good drinks, great prices, and a humming jukebox. Love it.

darren di giacomo

Hoorah!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

The Chartender

$2 shots of Tully during happy hour and in this economy!?! IYKYK so get to knowing!

ler1926

Typical dive bar atmosphere, great drink prices and the bartender Jeff was amazing. He was super personable and was willing to chat with anyone. Highly recommend this bar for a fun night out or quick stop. We stopped for “one” and ended up staying for a few.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Gregg Wolf

Pretty amazing

Theresa “Tree”

B safe lady this guy smokes crake and seems like he is good and not .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeremy Schoeberle

It is an awesome bar with a great staff and also the do a lot of community activities. Couldn't ask for a better bar.

Loading...