Tony's Pizzeria, LLC

604 W Historic Mitchell St, Milwaukee
(414) 212-8465

Recent Reviews

Jasmine Varela

It was aight .

Cesar Hernandez

Good service

Richie Galonski

First time going and it was worth it, pizza and wings are very tasty!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Build Your Own, Wings

Amy Vang

This may be a pizzeria but the real gems here are the Mexican food!! That’s probably why the pizza has such bad reviews because their speciality is tamales, empanadas, and mole chicken!! Rosa is the sweetest and always smiling and bubbly. She makes the tastiest, moist, banana leaf wrapped tamals with the perfect ratio of mass and filling. I love meat filling but the rasa con queso is my personal fav. This is definitely a takeout spot and I don’t recommend dining in but if the pizza disappointed you please give the Mexican food a try

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Don Gelo

Pizza ? is made right. Sauce is good and the price ia right! Definitely coming back.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tyler Madoche

They didn’t make the request for my girlfriend’s calzone to be vegetarian. So she couldn’t eat one part of our meal. The cheese curds tasted microwaved, but the mozzarella sticks and the pizza were decent. Unsure if I would recommend this place unless as a last resort. Mostly irritated we couldn’t enjoy one part of the meal we paid for.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Kayla Garner

The pizza was fresh and had good flavor but they were stingy with the ingredients. By the time the pizza cooled down it was dry because of the lack of cheese, pizza sauce, and toppings. It tasted like I was eating bread. I would order again but If I did I would order extra everything on the pie in order for it to be the way I like my pizza. I felt like it could have been a better value for what I paid. Staff were nice though. I might give it another chance.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Daniel C.

Small business in the Historic Mitchell Street neighborhood. Owner is super nice. Great mix of food including Latin cuisine. Burgers and pizza are good choices. However, you should try the tamales and tacos too.

Jennifer Graham

Absolutely disgusting!..... extremely under cooked pizza and papas locos that was completely covered in bacon FAT not 1 single piece of bacon......

Jonathan Castellanos

It's says they closed at 11pm , I was there at 10 pm and it was closed already but the open signs is still on , wasted my time going there for

Service: 1

Rolando Monterrey

Great testing pizza, always fresh and very hot. Love every slice.Vegetarian options: Great vegi pizza!!Kid-friendliness: Can bring family

Amber Oberfoell

Insanely boring pizza, no flavor, no sauce, no toppings. A frozen pizza would’ve been better than this

Jose Sixtos

They are just Their prices change all the time and they never have the pizza ready on time I will not be back here no moreKid-friendliness: They keep getting Worse their prices change all the time they tell you one time that your pizza will be ready and it's completely opposite it's double time justcnot a good place no more not coming back

Courtney MacDonald

Delicious pizza and amazing customer service! We'll definitely be back! :)

Kaele Evon

PIZZA IS THIN & NASTY ?! If You Like Thin, Dry Pizza This The Pizza For You, BETOS Hit Wayyyyy Better! $25 For A Lrg Thin Pizza & No Sauce.

Load More