Who's on Third

I am a Cubs fan, but this bar is awesome for watching games and their service has to be the best I have ever experienced. Super fast and nice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good beer, location and music. That being said, service wasn't great...probably the worst I've experienced in a bar roughly 20% full at the time. Numerous looks by the bartenders with an empty glass until being asked if I wanted a refill 10 minutes later.

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 1

Food was good; best cheese curds around and the staff was friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

We came here while in town for a conference. As we arrived, a large group from the same office (who we did not know) was leaving. One person from their group said a casual hello to us on their way out. Minutes later, our waitress came to our table accusing us of being with that group and demanding we cover a bill that someone in their party skipped out on. We explained clearly that we were not with them, had no connection to them, and would not be paying their tab.

Instead of resolving the mistake professionally, the waitress walked away in tears and brought over the manager — a young blonde woman who literally got up from a table where she was drinking and taking shots with friends to confront us. She scolded us for “making the waitress cry” and doubled down on demanding we pay the other group’s tab.

We stood our ground and again made it clear we were not affiliated with that party in any way. The manager’s behavior was incredibly unprofessional — not only for drinking on the job, but for mishandling the situation and throwing her own staff under the bus. If this is how management operates, I cannot recommend anyone waste their time or money here. Completely unacceptable experience

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

We schlemieled! We schlimazeled! We didn't find Hasenpfeffer Incorporated but we did find an AMAZING new place we love!! The food was incredible. The staff was fun and engaging. We will definitely go back!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Too loud. And I am a rocker!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Normally am a huge fan of Who's on Third. I have been coming here for many years. Unfortunately after this weekend we will not be back. My group came in for the shuttle for Harley Fest that was supposed to start at 4 PM. We got there early to eat and have a few drinks. At around 5:00 we realized we have yet to hear an announcement for the shuttle, we asked our server and was told that due to high demand for the brewer game the shuttles were pushed back until after the game. Once the game ended another 20/30 minutes went by with no update. We asked again and this time it was they will not be running until 6. 6 rolls around and still nothing we end up asking the bartender this time and we were told another 25 minutes. We ended up having to take an Uber there and back because the shuttle never came and no one was able to give a precise location for pickup after the concert ended. The food was great as always but we missed a lot of what we were planing to do at the festival due to poor planning on Who's on Third end. If there was an adjustment to the time that needed to be made it should've been announced and posted on Facebook. We were not the only group that this affected and many people were upset. Very disappointing.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

A great place to hang out, inexpensive and casual. Not to mention, you can catch the free shuttle to the stadium from here!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Awesome wings but it’s a hit or miss w the service. No one’s ever rude, but the hospitality could be better. It’s mostly young people serving, so they might just not be experienced with customer service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Jack was a great bartender! Great food and great service!

Great place but letting a homeless person sleep outside of the door and annoy you for money your entire meal. I'll pass.

Came for dinner on 5/29 evening. Food was great. Disappointed in bartender, a girl in plaid on her cell phone while patron was trying to have conversation. Simple yeps, okay, scroll. Former bartender here, sad to see customers treated with little respect. As a bartender it should be your job to not only serve drinks but also engage with customers. And if you’ve got time to lean, you’ve got time to clean.

Spent some great times in here during our trip to Milwaukee to watch the Orioles play baseball. Free shuttle to the stadium with friendly drivers. The staff were amazing and unexpected drink deals. We will be back!

Great service, food, and fun!

Only giving this place a 4 out of 5 because i haven't tried the food. The service at the bar is nice and so is the atmosphere.