Sugar Troll

122 E Main St, Mt Horeb
(608) 437-0122

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Aerial Brina

A very nice and welcoming environment for anyone. The young girl working behind the counter did amazing and was very kind and helpful. Their cookie butter ice cream was amazing!!!! And they have a variety of candies from different countries that is fun. I would like to recommend they get some sodas and cold beverages to partner with the sweets.

Luv Fit

They have 2 vegan and gluten-free options for gelato: the mango sorbet and strawberry sorbet. It's corn free as well... literally just fruit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Waffles

Often out of gelato but good candy and treats

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

•BLOB•

Often out of gelato but good candy and treats

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Liz M.

Mainly just had a wide variety of taffy and a few Gelato choices.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

DEE SALINAS

They have something for everyone.

Nikki Lee

Super cute little candy store. The staff member that was working when we stopped in was so helpful, kind, and sweet.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Mira

Cute and clean candy shop. Delicious taffy, I loved the snow cone flavor. Looking forward to trying more!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mira Siegele

Cute and clean candy shop. Delicious taffy, I loved the snow cone flavor. Looking forward to trying more!

Allyce Z

The store is beautiful, fun, and clean. The variety of candy is amazing. There were so many candies that I have never seen. The prices were reasonable. The manager was working and was so delightful. We had a wonderful conversation. She has wonderful event ideas. I highly suggest a visit. The gelato and candies are a special treat. I appreciated the sorbet without dairy. This surely is a gem!

Demetrio Salinas

They have something for everyone.

Tatyana Risch

We visit frequently and always satisfied with a tasty treat!

Michelle

My partner and I were in town and stopped at your adorable store for gelato. While it was clean and pleasantly stocked with sugary goodies, the young female employee was doing nothing but standing behind the counter. She ignored us until we asked for assistance after standing at the counter for several minutes. No big deal :) We purchased a Kiddo and Regular size cups for gelato but the literal equivalent of 4 servings of the trial spoon size (super tiny) was put into each of our cups, even though our cups were completely different sizes. There was so little ice cream for what we paid and we were absolutely shocked. I don’t know if this is story policy, but it was incredibly disappointing considering neither of our cups were even a full ice cream scoop that she used. We each tried samples of different flavors and those few samples were larger than our container servings.I would not recommend purchasing their gelato, even though very delicious, you pay far too much for nothing. Just taste the free samples.

Marty Heil

We visit frequently to get Sara's Artisan Gelato...so glad they carry this!

First Name Last Name

My partner and I were in town and stopped at your adorable store for gelato. While it was clean and pleasantly stocked with sugary goodies, the young female employee was doing nothing but standing behind the counter. She ignored us until we asked for assistance after standing at the counter for several minutes. No big deal :) We purchased a Kiddo and Regular size cups for gelato but the literal equivalent of 4 servings of the trial spoon size (super tiny) was put into each of our cups, even though our cups were completely different sizes. There was so little ice cream for what we paid and we were absolutely shocked. I don’t know if this is story policy, but it was incredibly disappointing considering neither of our cups were even a full ice cream scoop that she used. We each tried samples of different flavors and those few samples were larger than our container servings.I would not recommend purchasing their gelato, even though very delicious, you pay far too much for nothing. Just taste the free samples.

Loading...