Broken Tree Pizza has an adorable set up and decorations! The servers were attentive and the garlic sticks and pizza were ready quickly even though it was a busy Friday night! The garlic sticks were scrumptious and slightly greasy. The pizza was amazing! The crust was thick and tasted very fresh. I love a good wood fired pizza and will be back when I'm in town next!
Will S.
The atmosphere was amazing and the pizza was fantastic. They had many vegetarian options, which is a major plus! We would definitely recommend Broken Tree to anybody and everybody!
Christopher S.
Great service very friendly staff. Pizza was also great. Had our six year old granddaughter with us instead of crayons they gave pizza dough. Great idea she had fun.
Matt W.
Visited BTP on a Friday night. First off, didn't know these businesses existed in this little strip of shops in Neenah. You need to watch for the sign for the restaurant as it shares it's entry doors with a handful of other businesses. The place was packed but we only had to wait a few minutes. One reason for the 4 stars is they only had 1 person handling the tables. She did a great job considering the situation and all the tables being full. However, i think there was opportunity for the manger who seemed to just be roaming around in the back (kitchen is out front so not sure what he could have been doing) to help out in front. Seemed to be alot of opportunities to refill peoples drinks ($$$). The food in general was very good. The other reason for the 4 stars is that they don't cook any of the vegetables on their cheese breads or their pizzas. So you get a nice soft crust and gooey cheese, but then the vegetables are raw and crunchy. So it would be nice to at least have that communicated or be given the option to have yours cooked with the pizza. Prices are reasonable, i think our meal with apps, drinks and pizzas was around $75 for the 3 of us.
bigtoe1klein
What a great place! Owner went above and beyond for us! And the pizza was great too! We were visiting for the first time and were beyond pleased. Thank you!
Darla Hackel
Great choices or design your own. Friendly staff! Great pizza! Highly recommend!
Regina N.
Let's start with the free stuff! I got water! It's clean. It's cold. It's what it's supposed to be. Friend and I got a large pizza. An extra large pizza. We were really hungry. Decided to get Pepperoni. And I must say, this Pepperoni Pizza is already one of my favorite Pepperoni pizzas ever! Why so? Well I loved the sauce. Now this one is different. The Pepperoni sauce was more on the sweet side instead of the tangy side. But that's the reason I really enjoyed this pizza! Pepperoni was the star. Just full-bodied sauce! Also good was the cheese. Broken Tree's used goat cheese and had dollops of it on the pizza. Oh it was just cheesy goodness. Crust had some crisp to it. Not doughy at all. I'm not a fan of doughy pizzas. Now I know this is an Extra Large Pizza. But this pizza had so many floppy slices. I either had to fold this pizza in half or eat this pizza with two hands. Now I know nobody eats pizza with two hands, so I ate it folded. All in all, this pizza was great. One of my favorite Pepperoni Pizzas. Simple phenomenal!
Melissa C.
I'm a s***** for interesting pizzas, and this place has them. Cute little inside atmosphere with great food. Good location right downtown. What more can you ask for?
Jim S.
Awesome staff, nothing beats a coal fired pizza. They also have a nice selection of tap beers.
Jennifer P.
We ended up at broken tree after a restaurant down the street had a long wait and I'm glad we did! Pizza was great. We did the Fire Sticks for appetizers - had a little kick but not too spicy. We took our 3 kids (all under 8). I wouldn't say it's super kid-friendly (no kids menus) but between the baseball game on TV and being able to see the pizzas being made in the brick oven, they were pretty entertained. We ordered a pepperoni pizza for the kids, which was good. My husband and I got the Duke Silver and it was delicious. The honey drizzle was unexpected but really put it over the top. Crust was perfect. Price was reasonable for really good pizza - more expensive than chain delivery but also a big step up in quality.
First time ordering & highly recommend. Awesome customer service. We will be back.
Dennis K.
I rate this pizza in the top five that I've had in the past 10 years and I've been to Italy and around the United States during that time. The brussels sprouts were to die for even though they didn't have a salad which I was really looking forward to with my meal and I'm sure it's just because of everything that the food service industry is going through right now I would come back here all the time. You just have to try it and if you don't want something that is authentic ever woodfired oven just go to dominoes or Pizza Hut because you will never understand how good this pizza is.
Peggy Schreiner
Awesome wood-fire pizza, reasonable prices & great customer service.
Pete R.
Great pizza, fast service, downtown Neenah, wood fired so it's fast and has a great crust, many different sauces and combinations. It's our "go to" pizza for a fast and very satisfying meal.
Broken Tree Pizza has an adorable set up and decorations! The servers were attentive and the garlic sticks and pizza were ready quickly even though it was a busy Friday night! The garlic sticks were scrumptious and slightly greasy. The pizza was amazing! The crust was thick and tasted very fresh. I love a good wood fired pizza and will be back when I'm in town next!
The atmosphere was amazing and the pizza was fantastic. They had many vegetarian options, which is a major plus! We would definitely recommend Broken Tree to anybody and everybody!
Great service very friendly staff. Pizza was also great. Had our six year old granddaughter with us instead of crayons they gave pizza dough. Great idea she had fun.
Visited BTP on a Friday night. First off, didn't know these businesses existed in this little strip of shops in Neenah. You need to watch for the sign for the restaurant as it shares it's entry doors with a handful of other businesses. The place was packed but we only had to wait a few minutes. One reason for the 4 stars is they only had 1 person handling the tables. She did a great job considering the situation and all the tables being full. However, i think there was opportunity for the manger who seemed to just be roaming around in the back (kitchen is out front so not sure what he could have been doing) to help out in front. Seemed to be alot of opportunities to refill peoples drinks ($$$). The food in general was very good. The other reason for the 4 stars is that they don't cook any of the vegetables on their cheese breads or their pizzas. So you get a nice soft crust and gooey cheese, but then the vegetables are raw and crunchy. So it would be nice to at least have that communicated or be given the option to have yours cooked with the pizza. Prices are reasonable, i think our meal with apps, drinks and pizzas was around $75 for the 3 of us.
What a great place! Owner went above and beyond for us! And the pizza was great too! We were visiting for the first time and were beyond pleased. Thank you!
Great choices or design your own. Friendly staff! Great pizza! Highly recommend!
Let's start with the free stuff! I got water! It's clean. It's cold. It's what it's supposed to be. Friend and I got a large pizza. An extra large pizza. We were really hungry. Decided to get Pepperoni. And I must say, this Pepperoni Pizza is already one of my favorite Pepperoni pizzas ever! Why so? Well I loved the sauce. Now this one is different. The Pepperoni sauce was more on the sweet side instead of the tangy side. But that's the reason I really enjoyed this pizza! Pepperoni was the star. Just full-bodied sauce! Also good was the cheese. Broken Tree's used goat cheese and had dollops of it on the pizza. Oh it was just cheesy goodness. Crust had some crisp to it. Not doughy at all. I'm not a fan of doughy pizzas. Now I know this is an Extra Large Pizza. But this pizza had so many floppy slices. I either had to fold this pizza in half or eat this pizza with two hands. Now I know nobody eats pizza with two hands, so I ate it folded. All in all, this pizza was great. One of my favorite Pepperoni Pizzas. Simple phenomenal!
I'm a s***** for interesting pizzas, and this place has them. Cute little inside atmosphere with great food. Good location right downtown. What more can you ask for?
Awesome staff, nothing beats a coal fired pizza. They also have a nice selection of tap beers.
We ended up at broken tree after a restaurant down the street had a long wait and I'm glad we did! Pizza was great. We did the Fire Sticks for appetizers - had a little kick but not too spicy. We took our 3 kids (all under 8). I wouldn't say it's super kid-friendly (no kids menus) but between the baseball game on TV and being able to see the pizzas being made in the brick oven, they were pretty entertained. We ordered a pepperoni pizza for the kids, which was good. My husband and I got the Duke Silver and it was delicious. The honey drizzle was unexpected but really put it over the top. Crust was perfect. Price was reasonable for really good pizza - more expensive than chain delivery but also a big step up in quality.
Restaurantji Recommends
First time ordering & highly recommend. Awesome customer service. We will be back.
I rate this pizza in the top five that I've had in the past 10 years and I've been to Italy and around the United States during that time. The brussels sprouts were to die for even though they didn't have a salad which I was really looking forward to with my meal and I'm sure it's just because of everything that the food service industry is going through right now I would come back here all the time. You just have to try it and if you don't want something that is authentic ever woodfired oven just go to dominoes or Pizza Hut because you will never understand how good this pizza is.
Awesome wood-fire pizza, reasonable prices & great customer service.
Great pizza, fast service, downtown Neenah, wood fired so it's fast and has a great crust, many different sauces and combinations. It's our "go to" pizza for a fast and very satisfying meal.
Pizza was awesome! Will be going there again