Matty's Bar & Grille

14460 College Ave, New Berlin
(414) 427-3838

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Shelley Lussmyer

Excellent food, great waitress. Very cute place!

Mark Feldhusen

Great food.

Kate Kimmel

Billy at the outdoor bar was fantastic! Great energy, really attentive, fun conversation and he even ran through the rain for us to get our drinks! We’ll definitely come again and sit outside with him.

Kristin Wolf

The outside area was super nice and the waiter, Billy, was great. Super nice and attentive when refills were needed.

Chris Hansen

Had a great first experience here on July 4th. The food was great and fresh, the waitress was very nice but not too intrusive. All in all a great experience and for a good price too.

Cindy Puzia

Elli was an awesome server. Very personable and was a pleasure to have.

Kaylie Angiolo

We had Ellie as our server she was very sweet and kind!

Kassidy Kaufman

Do not recommend this place

SONIA

Probably not going back for food. Not great tasting. We ordered the rueben rolls. They seemed like jarred cheese not Swiss. The salmon was over cooked. The brussel sprouts were drowning in some unsavory sauce. The blt seemed like a no brainer bc who can mess that up...but I only ended up eating the bacon. Soggy shredded lettuce and tomatoes. The "garlic aioli was questionable. The waitress was nice and attentive but didn't give us chance to actually look at the menu before insisting we order drinks.

Laura Jensen

We had our sons going away party Mattys in their new event center. We just want to say everything was perfect! Taylor our bartender and Conner our server worked together to make our night more than what we expected. They went over and above to make sure everything was just perfect for us. The food was amazing!! We decided on appetizers and pizza and there was plenty for everyone and we received many compliments on everything from the food to the venue! We would highly recommend this place for your next event. Thank you for making our night special!

DAN

Bloody Mary was very HOT too much of something. Both had the fish. Baked Fish was tuff and over seasoned Patato Pancake very mealy coldslaw was about a tablespoon worth Pearch...breading was over seasoned and had a few bones Same as above for sides. Did not charge us for baked bill was still over $35 Not worth it. Have eaten a lot at Matty's food is usually very good....but not the Friday Fish...

Jennifer

Always a great experience at Matty's. Reservation check in was a breeze and they responded with a smile when we asked for a standard height table instead of a high top.

Mike

Made a New Year's Eve reservation in advance, and was accepted; day of Matty's canceled the reservation to close early. Couldn't find a reservation day of to find a new restaurant. This is simple stuff, if you're going to be closed, don't take reservations! Ended up cooking at home. On the plus side, the steak I made was better than any steak at Matty's.

Mike

Matty's is one of our favorite places! Never disappointed. Great friendly staff. Have tried many of their menu offerings.

ROBERT

Matty's is a traditional popular luncheon location, providing a varied menu, excellent food and great service

Loading...