Prospect Hill Pub & Eatery

19745 W National Ave, New Berlin
(262) 971-9000

Recent Reviews

Darlene Tuescher

Love Kim!!! Always a great visit!!

Tom Makkoo

highly recommend

John Weborg

The owner is very personable and friendly. She cooks and tends the bar at the same time. Always with a smile and happy to see you.

Andy M.

This place was not a very good bar it had rude people working and the bartender seem to be annoyed by having any customers attend to her this place was overall disappointment and no beer choice and the crowd was very Rowdy I can't imagine how many fights would be here on this Friday or Saturday nights the place is a dump and there's nothing unique about the structure and this Barn likely ranks as one of the more unpopular ones in the area

Katlyn Tappy

Stopped here for dinner. The perch was excellent! Bartender was very kind and attentive. She even even convinced us to take a piece of cheesecake to go! If we didn't live out of town we would definitely be back!

Ken Gille

As a previous reviewer said the mozzarella sticks are off. Great crispy wonton wrapper but the cheese tastes like provolone. Chicken tenders, fries and tator tots had no seasoning whatsoever. Burger was ok but again they served the wrong type of cheese. Menu said cheddar and it came with American cheese and a low rent version at that.

Bryan Groshek

I ordered the mozzarella sticks and a cod fish fry. The mozzarella sticks had a crispy, hand rolled wonton wrapper just like I like, but the cheese inside was not good. The cod had a very nice Panko breading on it and was the star of the meal. The fries and coleslaw that accompanied it were sub par.

John Wayne Farber

Stopped here after we noticed the new sign. Glad we did. Awesome food and great beer selection. Staff was friendly and entertaining. We have been back several times and recommend to friends. If you’re looking for a nice oasis in New Berlin, I suggest stopping in.

RanL B

A bar out of town charging premium prices for standard drinks. They must think they are downtown Milwaukee. When I travel to high end places I expect the price to follow. When I stop in a whole in the wall out by nothing dive bar, well call me cheap, the prices should be reasonable not downtown matching.

Joseph Neusen

The bottles of beer were warm. The shots were more like mini shots. After spending $60 +, I asked for " One on the house". The response I got was a cold "No". ?

Tim Biggin

The food was good, they have a big deck out back, and the staff was friendly!

E Zimm

Great service and I had the Argentina Prawns. AMAZING!!

Rip E

We came for the Friday Night Fish Fry and ate outside on the deck. The perch was excellent and my wife said the cod was very good. She has had some that she was not pleased with but this was light and flaky. I really enjoyed the potato balls which were one of the potato options with the dinners. You also got cole slaw and apple sauce. Kim served us personally and was very attentive. Prices reasonable.

Load More