Hilby's Restaurant & Sports Bar

300 S Pearl St, New London
(920) 982-4982

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Zac Zitske

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Perch and Fries, Bacon Cheeseburger, Five Meat Combo

Janice Bergsbaken

My family went there after church today. Food was very good. The 4 piece chicken dinner was very good and reasonably priced.

Keith Dorn

Today is the last time I will do business with this place the last 2 times I actually got food from there I got sick and our orders were messed up . Then 2 weeks ago my other half convinced me to give it a try again so I called in an order guy told me it would be 15 to 20 minutes and it would be ready I waited 20 minutes went to pick it up guess what no order they told the kitchen was closed and that the guy i gave my order to tried to call me back which was a complete lie.so i wasted my time going there the bar tender did give me a 15$ certificate for my inconvenience so i figured id give another shot . Now today which is a Friday is very busy for me I go to call in an order and am told they don't take carry orders on Friday from 4 to 8 there is nothing on their site about this and I have never had an issue ordering take out on Friday before.. so that being said I'm done between getting sick having my orders screwed up and just complete disappointment and incompetence by some employees not all I won't waste my time or money at this establishment

Trinity Rosenow

We had a great experience! Everyone was so nice and friendly, and the staff went above and beyond and welcomed my Autistic boys with open arms... we will be back for sure!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Single Topping Pizza

Autumn Stumpf

A couple people in my group didn’t get half the food that they ordered, and the waitress wasn’t too bright. The burger was so little and over done, and it was not from the kids menu lol. Won’t be back

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Beth Coppersmith

Hilby patty melt was awesome. Danielle is a top waitress. Recommend..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

T G

Ordered over the phone for some wings and fries for my family, server on the phone was so completely rude and unapologetic and screamed at us over the phone. Our meal that should have been less than $45 ended up costing us $75 because it was entered in wrong. Food was good, but the service and charge for the wings is outrageous…

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings

Cathy Noack

Our waitor was amazing as he was the only one working and had quite a few tables. Food was great. The turkey club was HUGE!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erica

Had a bad experience today. Cook sucks and the problem, waitress and bartender were great!!

Food: 1

Service: 2

Nicole Peterson

No idea if there food is good or not. They had specials posted on Facebook earlier that day. Called to pickup food about 5pm and was told kitchen wasn't open. Not sure what the problem was but advertised hours and actual hours didn't match

Nikki Cruz

I send my husband weekly (sometimes multiple times a week) for a Philly cheesesteak sandwich and garlic Parmesan fries! I could eat those every day. They’re truly so delicious! The service is always amazing too! My husband really loves the blts and bloody Mary’s too!!! The pizza and calzones are always so wonderful also! One of my most favorite places to eat!!

Julia Martinson

Enjoyed their taco bar on Tuesday for lunch. Beef and chicken options with either chips, soft shell, or hard shells. Salad bar toppings with a couple cold salads and 2 soup options made a completely filling meal. Having rice or beans as a side or topping would have been nice. Cheese lovers would request a cheese sauce/queso as well.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Priscilla Greiten

Our waitress did not give us silverware after requesting 2 x’s he had to go up and get himself as did another table. When our food arrived my husbands fish order was hugh. We we got our bill, she put the order in for 1 1/2 orders. I had requested veg and coleslaw but she must have been confused and asked if I wanted a potato if soup. I thought that was something that came with my meal. When delivered no veg, just the potato and coleslaw had to ask for butter and sour cream which she finally delivered but still no silverware.She is young and needs some additional service training. Otherwise food was great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

David Vande Vyver

Great spot to grab some food and or go bowling, we had the pizza and I really like the BBQ chicken

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

K Hanson

We live about 15 minutes out of town and were having some friends come from over an hour away to bowl a game or two and then get something to eat. The place has SUCH potential. The bowling area is nice and big and well kept. The bartender was having to run that side and the bar side, so he was running back and forth. Very nice though.We then headed to the bar side to get some dinner. We were fairly impressed with some of our food, but sad to see that the burgers aren't the nice juicy bar burgers. They are the flat uniformed kind with not much flavor. The buns were super dry as well. The waitress at first seemed to come across as a little standoff-ish, but she warmed up and was quite pleasant.It's hard to find a place with good atmosphere, good staff, and good food. The atmosphere was great, staff was decent, but the food...was meh. Tweak a couple things and it would be a super great place.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Loading...

Hilby's Restaurant & Sports Bar

300 S Pearl St, New London, WI 54961
(920) 982-4982