We celebrated my husbands birthday. The food was absolutely delicious! Prime Rib was done to perfection and Broasted Chicken was great not to mention the awesome soup and salad bar. Our waitress overheard us talking about my husbands birthday and brought him out a little birthday cake. She was the best! We will definitely go back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thad Kluck
Favorite place to visit in New London. Good food and service, great prices
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathi Miller
Awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gail Bonlender
Fond was good, service was good. I would go back if I was in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Greunke
This was the second time that I've gone here. And the first time was much better. I thought the portions were kind of small for the price. And it was just kind of lacking flavor. I do still love their salad bar though that's pretty awesome. My waiter was definitely not very attentive to making sure that I had something to drink. I had to wait a lot of times between drinks. They were busy but they were far from full of diners.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Emily Huff
I definitely wouldn’t consider this a supper club… it’s more of a bar with a dine in option. We went here because of the reviews we saw about the salad bar, and heard from Neighbors it was a cool place. It had a cool vibe if you’re looking to go out for a very very casual.
The salad bar was less than par. Ice burg lettuce mix, the tomatoes were cut in 1inch wedges, the cucumbers were also largely cut, options were limited. No cottage cheese or croutons, unless you wanted to crumble up the stale garlic bread they offered.
When we got there we asked if we could sit outside (mind you we’ve never been here) the “host” handed us the menus and told us to find a table and then come back in and let her know where we sat… not a very welcoming experience.
The menus… ok I guess if you only want five options with different plate offerings of it.
I got the tenderloin and lobster. Paid a decent price. The steak was ok, and the lobster was way overcooked, and hard to chew. Couldn’t even swallow it.
For a supper club I didn’t see one dinner roll, anywhere.
We def won’t be back… I guess unless we want a burger or “decent meal” but not likely for the prices and service.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Patty Johnson
We’ve been here several times on our way to and from Northern Wisconsin and the food has always been excellent along with the service. The burger is homemade and excellent portions. My husband had the haddock it was light and delicious. The parking lot is always full great ambience and we enjoy eating here during our travels five stars and a big thumbs up to the Waters supper club team.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diane Nuernberger
Amanda was our waitress last night. She was excellent! It was very busy but she attended to all of our needs. She shared a light conversation with us which helped to smooth over the toddler screaming next to us for a half hour. She was so positive and always had a smile on her face
Brad Johnson
Great combination of super club and restaurant on the wolf river
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
SWIM
Unfortunately, on each of my visits, the steaks have not been prepared to the requested temperature. While I have refrained from submitting a negative review, this issue has persisted. Specifically, the three steaks ordered for my table, all requested as medium-rare, were consistently overcooked to well-done.
Had delicious boasted chicken on the deck overlooking the wolf river. Brought home plenty of leftovers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tony Conradt
Told my group of four about a 30 minute wait. We waited over two hours. We watched multiple groups get seated before us. Kept being told we were next in line. Told us multiple times they were busy with a large group but we could see empty tables and other groups being seated. We left before we got seated. Old fashions were good though.
Dan Weisensel
Absolutely amazing prime rib! Same quality as Black Otter. Salad bar was exceptional along with the drinks and service. Thank you so much to all the staff that made our first experience an absolute treasure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wendy Hammond
First time going. Got there at 645 waited at the bar for our table and by 7 they were out of prime rib. Not a good first impression! We left!!
We celebrated my husbands birthday. The food was absolutely delicious! Prime Rib was done to perfection and Broasted Chicken was great not to mention the awesome soup and salad bar. Our waitress overheard us talking about my husbands birthday and brought him out a little birthday cake. She was the best! We will definitely go back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Favorite place to visit in New London. Good food and service, great prices
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fond was good, service was good. I would go back if I was in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was the second time that I've gone here. And the first time was much better. I thought the portions were kind of small for the price. And it was just kind of lacking flavor. I do still love their salad bar though that's pretty awesome. My waiter was definitely not very attentive to making sure that I had something to drink. I had to wait a lot of times between drinks. They were busy but they were far from full of diners.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
I definitely wouldn’t consider this a supper club… it’s more of a bar with a dine in option. We went here because of the reviews we saw about the salad bar, and heard from
Neighbors it was a cool place. It had a cool vibe if you’re looking to go out for a very very casual.
The salad bar was less than par. Ice burg lettuce mix, the tomatoes were cut in 1inch wedges, the cucumbers were also largely cut, options were limited. No cottage cheese or croutons, unless you wanted to crumble up the stale garlic bread they offered.
When we got there we asked if we could sit outside (mind you we’ve never been here) the “host” handed us the menus and told us to find a table and then come back in and let her know where we sat… not a very welcoming experience.
The menus… ok I guess if you only want five options with different plate offerings of it.
I got the tenderloin and lobster. Paid a decent price. The steak was ok, and the lobster was way overcooked, and hard to chew. Couldn’t even swallow it.
For a supper club I didn’t see one dinner roll, anywhere.
We def won’t be back… I guess unless we want a burger or “decent meal” but not likely for the prices and service.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
We’ve been here several times on our way to and from Northern Wisconsin and the food has always been excellent along with the service. The burger is homemade and excellent portions. My husband had the haddock it was light and delicious. The parking lot is always full great ambience and we enjoy eating here during our travels five stars and a big thumbs up to the Waters supper club team.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda was our waitress last night. She was excellent! It was very busy but she attended to all of our needs. She shared a light conversation with us which helped to smooth over the toddler screaming next to us for a half hour. She was so positive and always had a smile on her face
Great combination of super club and restaurant on the wolf river
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Unfortunately, on each of my visits, the steaks have not been prepared to the requested temperature. While I have refrained from submitting a negative review, this issue has persisted. Specifically, the three steaks ordered for my table, all requested as medium-rare, were consistently overcooked to well-done.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food and terrific service from our waiter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had delicious boasted chicken on the deck overlooking the wolf river. Brought home plenty of leftovers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Told my group of four about a 30 minute wait. We waited over two hours. We watched multiple groups get seated before us. Kept being told we were next in line. Told us multiple times they were busy with a large group but we could see empty tables and other groups being seated. We left before we got seated. Old fashions were good though.
Absolutely amazing prime rib! Same quality as Black Otter. Salad bar was exceptional along with the drinks and service. Thank you so much to all the staff that made our first experience an absolute treasure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time going. Got there at 645 waited at the bar for our table and by 7 they were out of prime rib. Not a good first impression! We left!!
Loading...