We went for the first time on a Friday. We got there around 5pm and it wasn't busy. We sat right away and ordered drinks and apps. The drinks came out but my husband didn't get his old fashioned for 20 minutes. The fried mushrooms came out and were ice cold however by this time the dining room was busy and they only had 2 servers so it was hard to send them back. The servers were working very hard but had too many tables. Our meal came out and a lot was missing. One of us ordered a full rack and received a half rack. We had to go up to the bar to get someone to fix the price difference. My chicken sandwich was supposed to be fried and it came out grilled with cheese on it which I didn't order. Also we all had condiments missing that we never got. Overall the food was ok but be prepared to spend 2 hours there. It is an order what you want and eat what you get kind of place.
William Vander Heyden
We sat there for 10 minutes before the waitress came over with our menu. The fish fry was good but my wife’s shrimp was so small that I didn’t think a restaurant Served them that small for 17.50 8 small shrimp was ridiculous. The baked potato came without butter and ask the waitress for some but never came out with any
Walter Harvey
Bad Service, Bad food had to get waitress attention for everything. could smell the stinky shrimp from the next table. our shrimp stunk. crusted shrimp was in a mushroom sauce that made the crust mushy. Beer batter fishfry was doughy and potato pancakes were undercooked.extra fish wasn't the same batter. Our salad order never came. We were there a total of 2 hours from start to finish having to ask finally for the check so we could leave.
Marjorie Behling
We ate there on a Friday and very much enjoyed their fish fry. I had the beer batter cod and hubby had the fried cod. Both were generous in size. The potato pancake was tasty but could have been hotter. Cole slaw was tasty. One of the 4 pieces of rye bread was nice and thick and there was plenty of butter. It is a bar and was extremely loud. Decor was meh...
Nicholas Binder
Food is excellent. The bang bang shrimp are really good and actually have a good kick to them. Burgers and sandwiches are great. Will update when I finally get to try the tomahawk ribeye
Marcella Canfora
Had a reservation for a party. Food was terrible for starters. Nachos didn’t have cheese sauce, just American cheese slapped on top of it & stuffed in the microwave. If a restaurant cannot get nachos right, I wouldn’t trust eating their seafood or steaks! Oh, not too mention, it took 2 hours to get the food. & Was supposed to have 2 servers for the party but only had one. Instead of being served first, they served their regulars & came to us last. I will never come here or recommend anyone to come here
Gregg L.
Food was ok but high priced staff very slow and looked like they were the cleaning staff
Andy Covey
My first review ever. 45 minutes to get water, 20 minutes after that we received our drinks. One hour after that we got soup and salads, and another 45 minutes after that we received dinner. Everything was way over cooked or wrong and I mean everything. An 80 dollar steak came well done when ordered rare. I said I didn’t want it but they said it was the last one they had. They stilled charged me for it even though I didn’t eat any of it, but said they wouldn’t charge for any of the drinks. After the bill came we found out that drinks meant only a few 1 dollar beers. Wasted 380 dollars. The last time I was there I never even received my meal after 2 hours and they still tried to charge me. I wanted to give it another chance but this time it was even worse. This place used to be great but it always goes back to management.
Andy C.
My first review ever. 45 minutes to get water, 20 minutes after that we received our drinks. One hour after that we got soup and salads, and another 45 minutes after that we received dinner. Everything was way over cooked or wrong and I mean everything. An 80 dollar steak came well done when ordered rare. I said I didn't want it but they said it was the last one they had. They stilled charged me for it even though I didn't eat any of it, but said they wouldn't charge for any of the drinks. After the bill came we found out that drinks meant only a few 1 dollar beers. Wasted 380 dollars. The last time I was there I never even received my meal after 2 hours and they still tried to charge me. I wanted to give it another chance but this time it was even worse. This place used to be great but it always goes back to management.
Katrina Hennings
I was not impressed. I went here for my birthday last week due to the nice pictures of food I’ve seen. There was only one lady working all tables and bar area. My shrimp was cold, rubbery, no seasoning and definitely wasn’t grilled. There was no grill lines or flavor to it. Definitely not fancy as they make it look.
I enjoyed the special tomahawk steak and crab legs. Very casual bar/dining. You have to ask for it because it's not listed on the menu. Hours need to be updated and reservation policy.
Caitlin D.
We had such a fun time with our family at Jim Dandys. They have arcade games and a very friendly staff. We were well taken care of and will come back very soon.
Ashley John
I dont usually give a bad review unless the service was very poor. I was so disappointed as their food is very good. We came in for a friends birthday and had called the day prior for a reservation as we had 10+ people. We were told they had no reservation and instead of accommodating us, the waitresses stood around arguing about who was going to take our party. We had to find enough tables and arrange them ourselves. Was 20 minutes before we were even asked what we wanted to drink so by the time we were finally asked we were ready to order our food as well. Also to get the tomahawk special you have to call in advance, which we did. We requested 6 and they only had 4. We arrived at 7pm and were not served our food until 830pm. Very disappointed!
Anthony Rupert
The food was delicious and insanely filling for the price. I will definitely be back.
Christine F.
We went here for a late Mother's Day present. My daughter saw their Tomahawk steak on Facebook and knew we had to go. It was relatively quiet for lunch and we were able to order right away. We did make Tessie's but they weren't needed. It has a supper club feel to it. Not really fancy. There were locals at the bar. Service was really good. There were about 7 tables seated. We sat in the back section to have a bit of privacy gorging ourselves. You have your choice of potato, crab legs or lobster, and a bread starter. The star of the show was perfectly cooked medium rare. It was enough for two of us. We didn't need any apps . We were in meat heaven! It was $70 and IMO worth every penny!
We went for the first time on a Friday. We got there around 5pm and it wasn't busy. We sat right away and ordered drinks and apps. The drinks came out but my husband didn't get his old fashioned for 20 minutes. The fried mushrooms came out and were ice cold however by this time the dining room was busy and they only had 2 servers so it was hard to send them back. The servers were working very hard but had too many tables. Our meal came out and a lot was missing. One of us ordered a full rack and received a half rack. We had to go up to the bar to get someone to fix the price difference. My chicken sandwich was supposed to be fried and it came out grilled with cheese on it which I didn't order. Also we all had condiments missing that we never got. Overall the food was ok but be prepared to spend 2 hours there. It is an order what you want and eat what you get kind of place.
We sat there for 10 minutes before the waitress came over with our menu. The fish fry was good but my wife’s shrimp was so small that I didn’t think a restaurant Served them that small for 17.50 8 small shrimp was ridiculous. The baked potato came without butter and ask the waitress for some but never came out with any
Bad Service, Bad food had to get waitress attention for everything. could smell the stinky shrimp from the next table. our shrimp stunk. crusted shrimp was in a mushroom sauce that made the crust mushy. Beer batter fishfry was doughy and potato pancakes were undercooked.extra fish wasn't the same batter. Our salad order never came. We were there a total of 2 hours from start to finish having to ask finally for the check so we could leave.
We ate there on a Friday and very much enjoyed their fish fry. I had the beer batter cod and hubby had the fried cod. Both were generous in size. The potato pancake was tasty but could have been hotter. Cole slaw was tasty. One of the 4 pieces of rye bread was nice and thick and there was plenty of butter. It is a bar and was extremely loud. Decor was meh...
Food is excellent. The bang bang shrimp are really good and actually have a good kick to them. Burgers and sandwiches are great. Will update when I finally get to try the tomahawk ribeye
Had a reservation for a party. Food was terrible for starters. Nachos didn’t have cheese sauce, just American cheese slapped on top of it & stuffed in the microwave. If a restaurant cannot get nachos right, I wouldn’t trust eating their seafood or steaks! Oh, not too mention, it took 2 hours to get the food. & Was supposed to have 2 servers for the party but only had one. Instead of being served first, they served their regulars & came to us last. I will never come here or recommend anyone to come here
Food was ok but high priced staff very slow and looked like they were the cleaning staff
My first review ever. 45 minutes to get water, 20 minutes after that we received our drinks. One hour after that we got soup and salads, and another 45 minutes after that we received dinner. Everything was way over cooked or wrong and I mean everything. An 80 dollar steak came well done when ordered rare. I said I didn’t want it but they said it was the last one they had. They stilled charged me for it even though I didn’t eat any of it, but said they wouldn’t charge for any of the drinks. After the bill came we found out that drinks meant only a few 1 dollar beers. Wasted 380 dollars. The last time I was there I never even received my meal after 2 hours and they still tried to charge me. I wanted to give it another chance but this time it was even worse. This place used to be great but it always goes back to management.
My first review ever. 45 minutes to get water, 20 minutes after that we received our drinks. One hour after that we got soup and salads, and another 45 minutes after that we received dinner. Everything was way over cooked or wrong and I mean everything. An 80 dollar steak came well done when ordered rare. I said I didn't want it but they said it was the last one they had. They stilled charged me for it even though I didn't eat any of it, but said they wouldn't charge for any of the drinks. After the bill came we found out that drinks meant only a few 1 dollar beers. Wasted 380 dollars. The last time I was there I never even received my meal after 2 hours and they still tried to charge me. I wanted to give it another chance but this time it was even worse. This place used to be great but it always goes back to management.
I was not impressed. I went here for my birthday last week due to the nice pictures of food I’ve seen. There was only one lady working all tables and bar area. My shrimp was cold, rubbery, no seasoning and definitely wasn’t grilled. There was no grill lines or flavor to it. Definitely not fancy as they make it look.
Restaurantji Recommends
I enjoyed the special tomahawk steak and crab legs. Very casual bar/dining. You have to ask for it because it's not listed on the menu. Hours need to be updated and reservation policy.
We had such a fun time with our family at Jim Dandys. They have arcade games and a very friendly staff. We were well taken care of and will come back very soon.
I dont usually give a bad review unless the service was very poor. I was so disappointed as their food is very good. We came in for a friends birthday and had called the day prior for a reservation as we had 10+ people. We were told they had no reservation and instead of accommodating us, the waitresses stood around arguing about who was going to take our party. We had to find enough tables and arrange them ourselves. Was 20 minutes before we were even asked what we wanted to drink so by the time we were finally asked we were ready to order our food as well. Also to get the tomahawk special you have to call in advance, which we did. We requested 6 and they only had 4. We arrived at 7pm and were not served our food until 830pm. Very disappointed!
The food was delicious and insanely filling for the price. I will definitely be back.
We went here for a late Mother's Day present. My daughter saw their Tomahawk steak on Facebook and knew we had to go. It was relatively quiet for lunch and we were able to order right away. We did make Tessie's but they weren't needed. It has a supper club feel to it. Not really fancy. There were locals at the bar. Service was really good. There were about 7 tables seated. We sat in the back section to have a bit of privacy gorging ourselves. You have your choice of potato, crab legs or lobster, and a bread starter. The star of the show was perfectly cooked medium rare. It was enough for two of us. We didn't need any apps . We were in meat heaven! It was $70 and IMO worth every penny!