I got some ice cream and a brownie which were both delicious.I was however unaware you guys no longer use GrubHub for delivery.Also when the rule changed that your delivery drivers aren't supposed to enter apartment buildings because of Covid. I had ordered a couple other times months ago and the delivery drivers brought my food to my door. I was a bit upset that the driver told me he could not enter my apartment building because of Covid rules when a few months ago they could.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Cookie, Brownie
Donna B.
I'm giving 4 starts because the college age adults working here were great. It's in a location close to campus, but I didn't love the location or access to the business. Would love to see them relocate. We took our nieces after gaming at The Mine Shaft. I felt the prices were really high. Quality was good. Service was exceptional. In my opinion, however, it takes a lot to make a single cookie worth that much. It was good, not exceptional, and didn't leave me dreaming of going back. Based on location they are marketing to the college crowd. The price point should then be more accessible to those living on the resources of the average student.
Ava Fitzpatrick
The seating probably could've been better but over all the cookies were really good and they had good ice cream options
Shirley F.
Stopped by on a weekday after dinner to grab a late night dessert. The guys at the counter were super friendly and patient as I took my SWEET time selecting my cookie. The parking lot seemed a BIT sketch, but I devoured my beautiful dessert and left without any issues. Anyways, I definitely recommend y'all stop by and grab an ice cream sandwich!
Madeline Bannister
might as well change the name to afternoon cookies sense y’all arnt open till 3 am anymore. laaaame
Shelly Hitchcock
It is wrong that they refuse to accept cash - a legal form of payment. We will not return, and I will be sure to let my friends and family know to go elsewhere if they want overpriced cookies.
vinod kumar
The best in town. Person who is serving is amazing. So polite and respectful.
David Bartman
Cookies were warm, fresh, and tasty with a good variety of choices. Good service! The only draw back was the price. It cost a dollar or so more than I wanted to pay for cookie(s) and ice cream.
R Mode
Great late night, or anytime stop, save your appetite for dessert, gentleman working was very cool, friendly.
They have gone down in quality and up in cost. Some of our cookies were not even fully cooked. Insomnia Cookies needs to wake up or stay asleep.
Shelly Thompson
2 stars only for the good service. The cookies are awful. Obviously baked from frozen pucks-bad flavor and rock hard after an hour or so (probably been warmed multiple times). And expensive to boot. Two thumbs down. ?
Sheila Ipsen
I found this cookie shop on the 'Only in Your State of WI' app. It is a brilliant idea and placed well near the UWO campus. I brought some of the cookies home with me after the first time going there and will now stop in there when we are in the area. Delicious warm cookies!
Dan Braun
When you absolutely, positively need an amazingly delicious cookie that tastes like it was baked with love...this is your place. These cookies are best when served warm, dunked in milk, as a stand-alone snack, or simply on any day that ends in the letter "y". You need these cookies. Don't fight it!
Nicole Zajicek
Are you Vegan and want a delicious cookie?Then don't come here to the Oshkosh location. Or any I suppose. I'd honestly rather have a cookie from Subway, it's cheaper and more delicious. Plus vegan options I was told I'd have to wait 15 min. Why would I have to wait 15 min? It should be readily available like all the other options. Also NO CASH policy? That is ridiculous. What if that is all you have or you don't want to put $2.50 on a card for one fricken cookie. Don't waste your time or money. If you only have Cash you won't have a problem with spending it, They won't accept it anyway.
Little pricey, but totally worth it. Quick
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cookie, Sundae
I got some ice cream and a brownie which were both delicious.I was however unaware you guys no longer use GrubHub for delivery.Also when the rule changed that your delivery drivers aren't supposed to enter apartment buildings because of Covid. I had ordered a couple other times months ago and the delivery drivers brought my food to my door. I was a bit upset that the driver told me he could not enter my apartment building because of Covid rules when a few months ago they could.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Cookie, Brownie
I'm giving 4 starts because the college age adults working here were great. It's in a location close to campus, but I didn't love the location or access to the business. Would love to see them relocate. We took our nieces after gaming at The Mine Shaft. I felt the prices were really high. Quality was good. Service was exceptional. In my opinion, however, it takes a lot to make a single cookie worth that much. It was good, not exceptional, and didn't leave me dreaming of going back. Based on location they are marketing to the college crowd. The price point should then be more accessible to those living on the resources of the average student.
The seating probably could've been better but over all the cookies were really good and they had good ice cream options
Stopped by on a weekday after dinner to grab a late night dessert. The guys at the counter were super friendly and patient as I took my SWEET time selecting my cookie. The parking lot seemed a BIT sketch, but I devoured my beautiful dessert and left without any issues. Anyways, I definitely recommend y'all stop by and grab an ice cream sandwich!
might as well change the name to afternoon cookies sense y’all arnt open till 3 am anymore. laaaame
It is wrong that they refuse to accept cash - a legal form of payment. We will not return, and I will be sure to let my friends and family know to go elsewhere if they want overpriced cookies.
The best in town. Person who is serving is amazing. So polite and respectful.
Cookies were warm, fresh, and tasty with a good variety of choices. Good service! The only draw back was the price. It cost a dollar or so more than I wanted to pay for cookie(s) and ice cream.
Great late night, or anytime stop, save your appetite for dessert, gentleman working was very cool, friendly.
Restaurantji Recommends
They have gone down in quality and up in cost. Some of our cookies were not even fully cooked. Insomnia Cookies needs to wake up or stay asleep.
2 stars only for the good service. The cookies are awful. Obviously baked from frozen pucks-bad flavor and rock hard after an hour or so (probably been warmed multiple times). And expensive to boot. Two thumbs down. ?
I found this cookie shop on the 'Only in Your State of WI' app. It is a brilliant idea and placed well near the UWO campus. I brought some of the cookies home with me after the first time going there and will now stop in there when we are in the area. Delicious warm cookies!
When you absolutely, positively need an amazingly delicious cookie that tastes like it was baked with love...this is your place. These cookies are best when served warm, dunked in milk, as a stand-alone snack, or simply on any day that ends in the letter "y". You need these cookies. Don't fight it!
Are you Vegan and want a delicious cookie?Then don't come here to the Oshkosh location. Or any I suppose. I'd honestly rather have a cookie from Subway, it's cheaper and more delicious. Plus vegan options I was told I'd have to wait 15 min. Why would I have to wait 15 min? It should be readily available like all the other options. Also NO CASH policy? That is ridiculous. What if that is all you have or you don't want to put $2.50 on a card for one fricken cookie. Don't waste your time or money. If you only have Cash you won't have a problem with spending it, They won't accept it anyway.