A nice little supper club tucked away on a residential side street. Wasn’t overly busy for a Friday night. The waitress was nice, and checked in frequently. Sadly my meal was lackluster. Tasted like microwaved beef tips and was really greasy. The prices were nice, which was why we chose that one over the other 2 in the area.
Jeffery Woodruff
I’ve always had great dinners at Jeff’s, but tonight things were missing. They served us dinner rolls which were warm and delicious. I ordered a N/A beer that they didn’t have, but my old-fashioned drink hit the spot. I’m not a fan of French fries, so I asked for potato salad that they don’t have. I then ordered potato pancakes which were very good. Other places I have had potato pancakes and they are served with syrup or applesauce. Wasn’t offered either and didn’t ask for them. Another member of our group was told that they were out of ranch dressing. We also ordered coleslaw and were not served any because they were all out. Run to Pick and Save down the road and buy some! The rest of the meal was good.
Michael Deschaine (OMG)
**⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jeff's on Rugby – A Hidden Gem for Steak & Fish Lovers!**
If you're looking for a spot that serves up a **beautifully cooked steak** and the freshest **Friday fish fry**, Jeff's on Rugby is the place to be! Every dish is crafted with care, and the flavors are absolutely unforgettable. The steak is perfectly seasoned and melts in your mouth, while the fish is crispy, golden, and cooked to perfection.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it the ideal place for a casual night out or a celebration. Paige and the team provide outstanding service, always making you feel right at home.
Highly recommend Jeff’s on Rugby for anyone who appreciates quality food and top-notch hospitality. Can’t wait to come back!
Let me know if you'd like to tweak anything! I want to capture exactly what makes Jeff's special in your eyes.
Hailey Binder
Seriously the best food in Oshkosh!! The prime rib was amazing as well as the brussel sprouts with their glaze. SO GOOD.
Darrell Thoma
Always love going to Jeff's, great easy going atmosphere along with great drinks !
J K (The Jason)
Great place for food and drinks!
Kris Kronberg
Loved the food ! Also great drinks & service. Very much look forward to going back.
Denise Belfeuil
Accommodated us for a special get together. Delicious food. Great service.
Luis Garcia
Amazing food
Cliff Thompson
We ate at Jeff’s for Restaurant Week and it was superb. The place was very crowded and we had to wait about 15 minutes for a table even with a reservation but it was worth it. The meals was terrific and the overworked waitress was amazing and friendly. I learned that they are under new management and I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a great meal at a very reasonable price. I had the Duroc Porterhouse pork chop and it was delicious. My wife had the salmon on a bed of risotto and she couldn’t say enough good things about it. The appetizers and desserts were also excellent.
Tenderloin Oscar was amazing! Megan was also great ! The best was not a wait of 2 hours!!
Lisa Tiedje
Went for dinner wanted to stay local and support small business and was extremely disappointed. The liver was black burned and like a hockey puck. Wasn't what I wanted to order but out of alot of other options. Out of baked potatoes.no french dressing and no olives for drinks. Food use to be amazing really has gone down. And we said something about not being able to eat the food due to it being burned and all she did was give us a drink chip, never offered to remake it. Bartender though was excellent!
Evan Grieshop
What can I say? The food was amazing, the prices didn't hurt my feelings, and the atmosphere was fantastic. My wife and I met a friend for dinner tonight. Lucky for us we ended up sitting at the bar next to the owners. I wanted chicken strips and they were out, NBD. Ordered the smoked chicken bacon ranch wrap(very tasty) and while we were waiting, unknown to us, the owner snuck away and came back with a huge platter of homemade chicken tenders. Best I've ever had! Talk about service!! Duck bacon wontons, also a favorite!
TLDR: Food awesome, prices great, owners and staff fantastic. They want you to be happy and to leave wanting to return.
Scott Pierce
Great place for food and drinks. Service was awesome.
A nice little supper club tucked away on a residential side street. Wasn’t overly busy for a Friday night. The waitress was nice, and checked in frequently. Sadly my meal was lackluster. Tasted like microwaved beef tips and was really greasy. The prices were nice, which was why we chose that one over the other 2 in the area.
I’ve always had great dinners at Jeff’s, but tonight things were missing. They served us dinner rolls which were warm and delicious. I ordered a N/A beer that they didn’t have, but my old-fashioned drink hit the spot. I’m not a fan of French fries, so I asked for potato salad that they don’t have. I then ordered potato pancakes which were very good. Other places I have had potato pancakes and they are served with syrup or applesauce. Wasn’t offered either and didn’t ask for them. Another member of our group was told that they were out of ranch dressing. We also ordered coleslaw and were not served any because they were all out. Run to Pick and Save down the road and buy some! The rest of the meal was good.
**⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jeff's on Rugby – A Hidden Gem for Steak & Fish Lovers!**
If you're looking for a spot that serves up a **beautifully cooked steak** and the freshest **Friday fish fry**, Jeff's on Rugby is the place to be! Every dish is crafted with care, and the flavors are absolutely unforgettable. The steak is perfectly seasoned and melts in your mouth, while the fish is crispy, golden, and cooked to perfection.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it the ideal place for a casual night out or a celebration. Paige and the team provide outstanding service, always making you feel right at home.
Highly recommend Jeff’s on Rugby for anyone who appreciates quality food and top-notch hospitality. Can’t wait to come back!
Let me know if you'd like to tweak anything! I want to capture exactly what makes Jeff's special in your eyes.
Seriously the best food in Oshkosh!! The prime rib was amazing as well as the brussel sprouts with their glaze. SO GOOD.
Always love going to Jeff's, great easy going atmosphere along with great drinks !
Great place for food and drinks!
Loved the food ! Also great drinks & service. Very much look forward to going back.
Accommodated us for a special get together. Delicious food. Great service.
Amazing food
We ate at Jeff’s for Restaurant Week and it was superb. The place was very crowded and we had to wait about 15 minutes for a table even with a reservation but it was worth it. The meals was terrific and the overworked waitress was amazing and friendly. I learned that they are under new management and I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a great meal at a very reasonable price. I had the Duroc Porterhouse pork chop and it was delicious. My wife had the salmon on a bed of risotto and she couldn’t say enough good things about it. The appetizers and desserts were also excellent.
Restaurantji Recommends
Tenderloin Oscar was amazing!
Megan was also great !
The best was not a wait of 2 hours!!
Went for dinner wanted to stay local and support small business and was extremely disappointed. The liver was black burned and like a hockey puck. Wasn't what I wanted to order but out of alot of other options. Out of baked potatoes.no french dressing and no olives for drinks. Food use to be amazing really has gone down. And we said something about not being able to eat the food due to it being burned and all she did was give us a drink chip, never offered to remake it.
Bartender though was excellent!
What can I say? The food was amazing, the prices didn't hurt my feelings, and the atmosphere was fantastic. My wife and I met a friend for dinner tonight. Lucky for us we ended up sitting at the bar next to the owners. I wanted chicken strips and they were out, NBD. Ordered the smoked chicken bacon ranch wrap(very tasty) and while we were waiting, unknown to us, the owner snuck away and came back with a huge platter of homemade chicken tenders. Best I've ever had! Talk about service!! Duck bacon wontons, also a favorite!
TLDR: Food awesome, prices great, owners and staff fantastic. They want you to be happy and to leave wanting to return.
Great place for food and drinks. Service was awesome.
Delicious fish fry.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...