There's a lot of room for improvement in Tamara's cupcakes and dessert offerings. Although beautiful, they were bland and not worth the calories nor price.
Haley Z.
I've never had a bad experience here, but I have a major sweet tooth. The thick frostings and fact that a lot of the cupcakes they make are filled inside with frosting and a ton on top can be a lot for an average sweets consumer even with the more sour or fruity flavored items. They also make other bakery items and beautiful custom cakes for graduations, weddings and such. It's a little more expensive for the area, but the quality of the items, freshness, and service are worth filling a box every once in awhile to treat yourself. Their pink boxes have become a recognizable object in Oshkosh! In a larger city the lack of no lot and further away street parking might be a hindrance, but being younger and able having to carry items halfway down a block hasn't impeded impulse stopping to buy. There is 1-2 spots of short term (15 min) parking in front, but every time I've been there they've been taken. The Lick the Bowl cupcake is my favorite option!
Nicole Draves
I had the best time picking up my online dessert order today!! 3/16/22 I didn’t catch the workers name, but she was amazing! We had some good laughs! And she went out of her way to help me! I had an amazing coffee and specialty cookie dessert! Thank you so very much! I also ordered the variety dessert bar platter a couple of weeks ago and my coworkers still talk about how good the bars were!
Theresa Murphy-Orlik
late post but these paczki were even better than some of my favorite bakeries in Illinois❣ YUMMMM
Jennifer Marohn
I decided last minute not to make my daughter’s birthday cake. I went on Tamara’s website, ordered, paid, and picked it up today. The cake was absolutely perfect!! We got a strawberry swirl cake with strawberry filling, and it has to be the best I’ve had in a long time. Thank you so much for making my daughter’s Harry Potter birthday PERFECT!
Joel W.
Fantastic pastry treats. I took them to my customer and they were impressed. Everything was delicious.
Deanne Marie
Ordered a cheesecake and cheesecake bites for my son’s birthday. Cheesecake was absolutely delicious! Cheesecake bites were smushed a little but the cashier offered to repackage them for me. Those also were delicious. Everyone enjoyed the desserts. The cheesecake was beautifully decorated as well. Honestly, the best tasting cheesecake I’ve had. I feel like the price was a little high but overall very happy with the purchase and service.
Valine Crowley
The cupcake was dry. The ice cream was good.
Megan Mueller
I have gotten cupcakes from here many times in the past and they were phenomenal. I was very disappointed with my recent experience about a week ago. For starters, the girl working had no clue how to set up the box for the cupcakes. Consequently, it fell apart while I was moving the cupcakes and dropped to the ground and my cupcakes were ruined. Some of my cupcakes, specifically the "Milky Way" cupcake was dry and the red velvet cupcakes just fell apart and turned to mush when I took the wrapper off. I traveled 2 hours for these cupcakes because I knew how good they were. I was very unsatisfied this time with the quality, especially given the price. I will not be back nor would I recommend this place to people. Not sure what happened to this place in the last 3 years.
skyy zoned
This store was adorably set up, with a variety of different cakes, cupcakes, pretzels, ice creams, drinks, and more! My children loved the kiddy cocktail drink with gummy bears, the roasted marshmallow macaroons, and the cheescake, was a must and you will definitely be back!
Topnotch delectables in a variety of enticing flavors! If you enjoy peanut butter I recommend the Reese's cupcake!
Samantha Marie Pasch
they did my daughters unicorn cake and nailed it! their cupcakes are to die for! highly recommend!!!!!
Izzi M.
Flavors amazing. I love the business so much itself, i've always had an amazing experience at tamara's! All of the cupcakes, cookies and cakes are beautifully done and not sloppy in the least. Definitely recommend when you're in the area!
Pardee Villain
It was my first time here. My fiance brought me here and showed me around. It smells so good very welcoming staff. We got a four pack of cupcakes can't wait to try them. Will be back to have more cupcakes.
Janine Muza
Always wonderful sweets.Tamara's gives coupons to Foster families. This is such a blessing ...thank you for caring!!
There's a lot of room for improvement in Tamara's cupcakes and dessert offerings. Although beautiful, they were bland and not worth the calories nor price.
I've never had a bad experience here, but I have a major sweet tooth. The thick frostings and fact that a lot of the cupcakes they make are filled inside with frosting and a ton on top can be a lot for an average sweets consumer even with the more sour or fruity flavored items. They also make other bakery items and beautiful custom cakes for graduations, weddings and such. It's a little more expensive for the area, but the quality of the items, freshness, and service are worth filling a box every once in awhile to treat yourself. Their pink boxes have become a recognizable object in Oshkosh! In a larger city the lack of no lot and further away street parking might be a hindrance, but being younger and able having to carry items halfway down a block hasn't impeded impulse stopping to buy. There is 1-2 spots of short term (15 min) parking in front, but every time I've been there they've been taken. The Lick the Bowl cupcake is my favorite option!
I had the best time picking up my online dessert order today!! 3/16/22 I didn’t catch the workers name, but she was amazing! We had some good laughs! And she went out of her way to help me! I had an amazing coffee and specialty cookie dessert! Thank you so very much! I also ordered the variety dessert bar platter a couple of weeks ago and my coworkers still talk about how good the bars were!
late post but these paczki were even better than some of my favorite bakeries in Illinois❣ YUMMMM
I decided last minute not to make my daughter’s birthday cake. I went on Tamara’s website, ordered, paid, and picked it up today. The cake was absolutely perfect!! We got a strawberry swirl cake with strawberry filling, and it has to be the best I’ve had in a long time. Thank you so much for making my daughter’s Harry Potter birthday PERFECT!
Fantastic pastry treats. I took them to my customer and they were impressed. Everything was delicious.
Ordered a cheesecake and cheesecake bites for my son’s birthday. Cheesecake was absolutely delicious! Cheesecake bites were smushed a little but the cashier offered to repackage them for me. Those also were delicious. Everyone enjoyed the desserts. The cheesecake was beautifully decorated as well. Honestly, the best tasting cheesecake I’ve had. I feel like the price was a little high but overall very happy with the purchase and service.
The cupcake was dry. The ice cream was good.
I have gotten cupcakes from here many times in the past and they were phenomenal. I was very disappointed with my recent experience about a week ago. For starters, the girl working had no clue how to set up the box for the cupcakes. Consequently, it fell apart while I was moving the cupcakes and dropped to the ground and my cupcakes were ruined. Some of my cupcakes, specifically the "Milky Way" cupcake was dry and the red velvet cupcakes just fell apart and turned to mush when I took the wrapper off. I traveled 2 hours for these cupcakes because I knew how good they were. I was very unsatisfied this time with the quality, especially given the price. I will not be back nor would I recommend this place to people. Not sure what happened to this place in the last 3 years.
This store was adorably set up, with a variety of different cakes, cupcakes, pretzels, ice creams, drinks, and more! My children loved the kiddy cocktail drink with gummy bears, the roasted marshmallow macaroons, and the cheescake, was a must and you will definitely be back!
Restaurantji Recommends
Topnotch delectables in a variety of enticing flavors! If you enjoy peanut butter I recommend the Reese's cupcake!
they did my daughters unicorn cake and nailed it! their cupcakes are to die for! highly recommend!!!!!
Flavors amazing. I love the business so much itself, i've always had an amazing experience at tamara's! All of the cupcakes, cookies and cakes are beautifully done and not sloppy in the least. Definitely recommend when you're in the area!
It was my first time here. My fiance brought me here and showed me around. It smells so good very welcoming staff. We got a four pack of cupcakes can't wait to try them. Will be back to have more cupcakes.
Always wonderful sweets.Tamara's gives coupons to Foster families. This is such a blessing ...thank you for caring!!