Casa Tequila

1405 Capitol Dr UNIT K, Pewaukee
(262) 746-6966

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kim Peritz Fanella

Absolutely NOT! We went for a fish fry and the fish was awful!!’. i love a good fish fry!! i don’t know what this was. The fish taste disgusting, fishy!! i couldn’t eat ANY of it!’. They didn’t offer me another entree! He didn’t apologize!! He didn’t remove it from the bill!! Highly unprofessional! Highly unethical!!! No customer service whatsoever!!! Never again!’

Colleen Ulvila

Good options. Nice staff. Good margaritas.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa

Francisco Rodriguez

I had to share my experience, I had the best chicken nachos ever at Casa Tequila.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Janis Bira

Great food & drinks

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ron Sankey

Overall experience was pretty good. Food was good. Waitress was very nice. Must have been a slow day, was just her by herself. But she kept up pretty darn good. We didn't fault her for that. I had the carne asada tacos, which were fine. It is a decent amount of food, plus the steak is quite filling. It was sunday... but they were all out of bloody mary ingredients. Pretty sad.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Theresa Caven

Slow service, but I think it was an off day. Great food and pleasant staff.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Robert Unger

I had the shrimp tacos.The shrimp sump like it came from mechanic was not fresh.It was not good.It was one of the most depressing meals i've ever had

Food: 1

Service: 2

Jessi Nick - Meunier

Can you guys please season the shrimp before you add it into the burrito or tacos…etc. Even some lime juice and salt would make all the difference. 2nd time ordering something with shrimp and it is not seasoned! Love Casa Tequilla but I think I’m going to pass on anything with shrimp in it.

John Leair

Excellent food! One of my favorite restaurants.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Benjamin Luedke

I’ve been to Casa Tequilla on at least three different occasions. I wasn’t impressed with my first visits and thought the food was just “okay” at best. I recently stopped in again for lunch out of convenience and am now regretting that choice. I ordered the taco carnitas. The chips and salsa that are standard were nothing special, salsa isn’t homemade and the chips are cheap store bought tortilla chips. The rice and beans on the side were sadly the best part of the meal and they were absolutely average. The tacos came on corn tortillas per my request with the pulled pork, cilantro and onion. The pork looked pale as I’m sure it came out of some leftover container in the refrigerator and the juice had all seeped out of the meat along with the flavor. The corn tortillas were very mushy and it was obvious that the whole thing was constructed from the fridge and then microwaved before topping with the cilantro and onion. I have to be honest and had a moment where I did wonder if this was safe to eat. Fast forward about 45 min and I was desperately looking for a restroom and afterwards I had several minutes of clammy cold sweats. The bill got three tacos and a Diet Coke plus tax was almost $20. I tipped $5 as the service was friendly and attentive but don’t think I’ll ever be going back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

J R

Carlos is the best servicer and Diana is the best manager! Always makes us feel welcome!
Love the food and drinks!
Thanks for being a great Wednesday lunch spot for the past 10 years!

Weswife

IF YOU ARE VEGETARIAN....
The VEGETARIAN portion of the menu does NOT tell you the truth. The rice is made with chicken broth, and the pinto beans are made with lard.
The older guy that took our order wasn't forthright about this until we really grilled him.
Be careful.

Destiny CASTILLO

Delicious! Angel is the BeST!

Ralph Schwieger

Great bartender took care of us! Loved our food and wonderful margaritas.

Joe Padilla

Being from Texas, I assume that Mexican restaurants would be good everywhere I go. How disappointing it is to find out that these people cook to appease the gringos. The food is bland, the beans come from a can, and the rice has no spices whatsoever. I had the parillada, and the little pieces of meat had no seasoning on it and way too many veggies on it. It also had potatoes on it. Potatoes!!!! I don't understand how any restaurant won't make homemade tortillas!!! I think I'm going to give up on these places. They just plain out suck.

Loading...