Papa Murphy's - Pewaukee

2177 Silvernail Rd, Pewaukee
(262) 650-0600

Recent Reviews

Kelly Wagner

Awful customer service! Placed my order in person, I walked up to cashier and said hello and got stared down with not a word back. Placed order, she didn't say a word again, and when I was handed my receipt and said thank you, I got another stare down. On top of that, my pizza made by the same girl, was wrong. When I called it out I was asked by who I assume was the manager if incorrect ingredients could just be picked off. I said no, and the response was tossing the pizza across the back counter with, "Fine, we'll make a new one." Really? Customer lost.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Brian McFar

The pizza itself is pretty decent, but the customer service is extremely lacking. Walked in to get order, there was no greeting or acknowledgment of any kind. I yelled out "thanks much" with no response what so ever. And yes people were

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

David Boxhorn

Always a good deal there!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Lindsey Nickels

Don’t order curbside. Apparently the employees are too busy sitting at the counter doing nothing to bring the order out. Had to take my sleeping daughter out of her car seat to go in to get the order.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Jean Smith

Food is great if you can get it. They start shutting down at 6:30 so don’t walk in at 6:50 and expect to get food. They have all the food put away and ready to head home before 7pm. It was 6:55 tonight and a “sorry we packed all the food away already”.

Service: 1

Kevin McCloud

Good pizza and friendly staff. They no longer offer our favorite cheesy bread and s'mores dessert.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jason Ong

The Saturday before Halloween we ordered 11 pizzas. They were scheduled to be picked up at 1 but due to everyone ordering pizza for trick o treat, they were running out of dough and were overwhelmed. The store called to tell us that they are being flooded with orders and that our 1pm order won’t be ready until 5. Rather than getting upset for the delay I had to give the credit for taking on so many orders at once. So thanks for the great teamwork in getting our huge order in.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Dan Brunner

Pizza wasn't ready. Barely any pepperoni. Barely any ham or pineapple. This is a really poor product. It looked like the young staff needed some additional training.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Kevin Cook

Take & bake from strip mall business.Pretty cost effective over delivery, and it's always fresh & hotter for sure :)Parking: Never been an issueWheelchair accessibility: Park right in front

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cowboy Pizza Baking Required, Pizza

C

We arrived at 4:50 and they closed at 5:00.I understand it is not ideal but they had already locked the doors and refused to accommodate. As a fellow service industry worker, and the establishment that I work for, we would have gladly serviced anyone walking in before 5, with a smile.Very disappointed.

Service: 1

Gilbert Cari

We arrived at 4:50 and they closed at 5:00.I understand it is not ideal but they had already locked the doors and refused to accommodate. As a fellow service industry worker, and the establishment that I work for, we would have gladly serviced anyone walking in before 5, with a smile.Very disappointed.

Nate Holm

Horrible customer service!! I ordered a special cheesy bread and they didn’t have it, but they still charged me for it. The young useless woman behind the counter had a terrible attitude and was of no help whatsoever. Avoid this place like the plague!!!!!

Paul Johnson

Pizza was terrible. Quality is no longer available on there pizzas. Little toppings, super thin crusts, hardly no sauce &no flavor compared to past pizza.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Brad Bassler

Hair found in pizza! Ordered gourmet veggie. No mushrooms very little cheese on 2 pizza’s ordered!!!

Alison Gacek

Tried to call to let them know pizza was made terrible and there was no crust. What was there tasted like old dough . Phone number is wrong . I could not even call to tell them . Wish i could get my money back .

Load More