Shelby Campbell's Eatery & Bar

The nicest wait staff. Good food. Generous portions. Reasonable prices. Great experience.

This was a lovely place. It was near closing time when we ordered and p/u our food. The atmosphere seemed kinda on the Irish Pub side but seemed ok for outsiders 🤭. We had the steak and berry salad, which was really good. The price point for this salad was not quite $20 per person, but we thought it was worth it. There's a lobby area upon entry and then the bar area. Im assuming the dine-in area was somewhere close. Would recommend the salad we had. We will probably try other menu items in the near future.

When I work in the Pleasant Prairie area, I know I will be eating at Shelby Campbell's! Worthwhile stop for anyone in the vicinity

Delicious food in a relaxed atmosphere. The menu has a good balance of classic American and unique dishes. Staff is friendly and attentive.

Delicious!

Family owned. Great buffet each day a little different.

The menu provided a nice selection of lunch options. I decided on a salad and was very happy with my choice. The staff understood that I was vegan and added a little extra for my “protein” needs. I would definitely go back.

An unexpected treat. Food is innovative for the area, especially a hotel. An African soup?!?!? What?!?!? Delicious. Fritters were great. The complimentary bag of chips was addictive. Very veg friendly and will definitely return.

Busy, fun, cold drink and good food. The staff is awesome. Bartender was cool af!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice bar at the hotel. The burger was nice and the service was good.
We got recommendation for the happy hour beers and also the special beer like the Octoberfest was nice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Unfortunately it took over an hour to get our food after we ordered. Nothing was ordered that required any long cook times. "Burgers". When the food came out is was cold, not luke warm but cold.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Went with a group of 9 people; called just ~30 minutes ahead and they were happy to accomodate us. The food was way better (and more diverse) than it had any right to be, and our guy Nick was one of the best servers I've ever had. Awesome attitude for being the only guy on shift for th edining room, took awesome care of us, joked around, nailed it. Would definitely return, especially if Nick picked up the phone.

Vegetarian options: I had about 3lbs of kimchi hummus with heirloom veggies and it was freaking awesome, as were the pickle fries.

Dietary restrictions: Shared frier so GF friends cannot have fried things, but our GF friend was well taken care of.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food is great, especially the fried green tomato sliders...

Parking: Room for larger vehicles (buses, RV's and trucks)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Wisconsin Cheese Curd, Loaded Tots with Pulled Pork, Lake House Fish and Chips

Food was dry and hard, the service was slow. It took 40 min for food to arrive, and the establishment was wayyy too cold. We won’t go back. Such a disappointment.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I recently dined at Shelby Campbell’s Eatery & Bar and had the pleasure of trying their Brat Burger. The flavors were incredibly well-balanced, intermingling perfectly to create a delightful taste experience. The meatloaf patty was wonderfully textured and easy to devour, making each bite a true joy.

Our server, Nick was prompt and attentive, greeting us warmly upon arrival and quickly presenting us with house chips to munch on while we waited for our food. These chips were incredibly addicting and perfectly seasoned, making it hard to stop going back for more. They were the perfect appetizer to prep us for the main course to follow.

Overall, I would highly recommend Shelby Campbell’s Eatery & Bar. The combination of excellent food and top-notch service made for a memorable dining experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5