Roth’s Supper Club & Pizzeria

4020 County Rd R, Plover
(715) 991-5991

Recent Reviews

Kayla Kowalewski

This is my favorite pizza near point ?????? ive been getting the same pizza now a few times since i tried it a couple months ago. Its delicious every time! Thank you!

Food: 5

Jessica Bonnell

Ordered a few times from here through Doordash. The food was good. Pizza was delicious and they offer a variety of toppings including green olives. We will be ordering from here again.

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kyle Slazakowski

The Mushroom Swiss I got was the saltiest, dryest burger I have ever had. The mushrooms were just canned mushrooms that were heated up. The Swiss somehow wasn't melted even though the patty was whatever is past well done. Also most Mushroom Swiss have some kind of sauce. This was canned mushroom, a slice of Swiss, and a burger patty. The side of fries was smaller than a small fry at McDonald's and completely flaccid. Do not assume your special instructions will be followed. I wanted to add sautéed onions to the burger which they didn't do. I asked for a side of sour cream for the Mini Tacos because there is no option on door dash which we didn't get. Also we initially wanted Alfredo pasta but we got a call saying they don't do pasta on Friday so we switched to 6 Pcs Deep-Fried Shrimp with a side salad. For $19... We asked for French dressing for the side salad but we got ranch. Which is slightly understandable but I did say French twice. The shrimp was extremely greasy and a bit rubbery. Also over the phone I was told the 6 Pcs Deep-Fried Shrimp comes with a roll. It did not. No napkins or utensils were provided. Out of everything we got the appetizers were the best. Goor Mini Tacos and Fried Mushrooms. Wish they came with sour cream and marinara like any other restaurant on the planet. We have ordered from here before and it was really good. I heard a lot of the cooks from Mickey T's Club 10 were working here now. I would have said "makes sense. Great food" the first time we ordered but either that was not true, they quit, or got fired because whoever made our food tonight are not the same people that made our order a few months ago.

Food: 2

K. Bons

Wings are top notch! Drinks are strong and delicious. Pasta tastes homemade. My only suggestion is keep the fries in another 30-60 seconds.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Alfredo

kathleen hodgden

I went there for a fish fry by myself. I am single and that happens at times.It did bother me that when I was asked if I would like a table or a booth. And my answer was a booth the hostess made a disappointing face towards me. And then put me in the corner. Which was ok, but yet made me feel like I was being punished for asking for a booth. The place was super quiet. It was right at 4 p.m. So it was not like I was taking a booth from a bigger group of people.I will go back again because the food is always good. And the service is always good.And yes I did leave a good tip for the very nice waitress.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt Dow

Kitchen struggled tonight. My girlfriend ordered mostaccioli and got overcooked penne in pizza sauce. My prime rib special took 70 minutes to arrive and while it tasted pretty good, it was so full of fat and gristle it was difficult to eat.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

T.J.

It took an hour and 15 minutes between our order and our food being brought. Food was basically tasteless. The mostacani was pasta with pizza sauce on top. The prime rib was so grizzly and fatty that my son had indigestion. The bathrooms were in poor condition. We won't go again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Salad

Lori

Wow awesome prime rib! This place was formerly smileys bar and grill. Roths now have the bar and restaurant. Excellent dinner, super friendly staff! I would recommend this place to anyone looking for great prime rib dinner made the old fashion way!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Adams

Great food, great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brad Wilson

I feel bad posting this but stopped in on September 3rd to try the pizza. We got the sausage and mushroom it had no flavor in the sauce (almost like it was watered down). I did like the crust. Our server was so amazing though she was so nice and attentive!! I absolutely hate when restaurants charge for fountain drink refills and don’t tell you until you get the bill. Very sad had such high hopes for here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Janet Slowinski

Parmesan crusted cod was awesome!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diane

Ordered the works pizza, it was good except there was hardly any sausage, maybe 6 pieces on the entire pizza. It tasted more like a vegetable pizza. I would rate it a 2/5 for those reasons.

Samantha Mansavage

Great service, food, and drinks. Haven't tried pizza yet, but looks amazing. Had spaghetti and was delicious. My family had burgers and they were yummy they said. Owner amy is very

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jason Bush

Great pizza and wings! Tried the chicken, bacon, ranch pizza and the chicken wings and both were delicious. Very happy with the food here and will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

B L Swan

One of the BEST places We have ever been for Fish Fry!!!Super Light Breading on Awesome Fish!Loaded Mashed potatoes were Also VERY VERY GOOD!!!If You have not tried it yet, Highly Recommend to put it on your list!!All 9 of Us were Very Satisfied with all of our meals, Awesome Service, and Bar!*****

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mac N Cheese

Load More

Roth’s Supper Club & Pizzeria

4020 County Rd R, Plover, WI 54467
(715) 991-5991