Love the variety of goodies. Highly recommend for cupcakes and special treats.
Sarah Quist
Blown away! I was in need of desserts for my little guy’s first birthday. We were having a large group and had allergies to consider. Ordering online was a breeze and I loved having the option to order GF/DF desserts. Everyone loved the cupcakes, sugar cookies, and scones! Cannot recommend Bettersweet Bakery enough!
Nicole Dobbe
Not a fan of butter cream except for Bettersweet's. It's heavenly. Cake is moist and the prices are unbeatable. We have to get scrape scraps whenever we are in town!
Bethany Kreiter
Thank you Curt and Jen for making the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake. Although there are many new options for wedding desserts, a traditional wedding cake was something I knew I wanted to still have. It was such a pleasure working with Jen and letting her take over the design of the cake. I knew I wanted a white cake with tiers, but other than that I let her take the lead of the overall design. I have had the joy of indulging in her wedding cakes in the past, for my sisters wedding and another good friends wedding, so I knew the actual taste was going to be fabulous. During our first meeting, she made a sample of the flavors we chose: vanilla bean cake w/ raspberry compote & vanilla creme fillings, vanilla bean butter frosting. No need to try any other combos; this was it. I dream about this cake. Even though the bakery is in Plymouth, there was no hesitation about taking on our wedding in Milwaukee. Thanks for making our wedding that more special with your delicious cake!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Heichler
Bettersweet Bakery provided our wedding cake and cupcakes on September 7th 2024! Very professional, accommodating, and wonderful service! Our wedding cake was TO DIE FOR!! So delicious and worth every penny. Highly recommend the "Lemon" cake, with "Raspberry Compote" filling and Bettersweets Signature Buttercream frosting. Yum!! We didn't have any cupcakes but we're guessing everyone loved them, they were all gone! 12 Dozen! Highly Recommend!!! ?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tracy Ellen Meyers
I have never been disappointed with anything I've tried at Bettersweet! From brunch breads to cupcake samplers to scraps, everything has been delicious, flavorful, moist and amazing! You can tell things are made with care! The unique flavor combinations always surprise me, they're so good! I can't figure out which is my favorite, as I haven't met one I didnt like!
Ashley Gaszak
Very poor communication. Wedding date was beginning of June and delivery and cupcakes were fine, but even before the order getting a response back took 1-2 weeks. I’ve now been emailing them regarding a refund of deposit since June 12th and still have not received our deposit back. I’ve tried calling as well and they tell me it should be a day or two response but then don’t get one for weeks. There was about a month time with zero responses back from the owner. Last response from them was 7/29 and now again 12 days without a response.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Angel Palmisano
We use to get this cake at work and Brenda would pick it up for us....This is the best tasting and looking cakes I ever had in my life! Even better than Simma's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rachelle E. Laessig
Quite literally the best cupcakes I have ever had in my life.
-German chocolate
-raspberry lemon
the filling is EVERYTHING
Lexie Saladini
Bettersweet Bakery was great to work with. I knew our wedding cake would turn out amazing. We had so many compliments on our cake! (Best birch cake our photographer has seen). I definitely recommend Bettersweet Bakery to everyone for both cupcakes and cake for all events!
Bettersweet Bakery was great to work with. I knew our wedding cake would turn out amazing. We had so many compliments on our cake! (Best birch cake our photographer has seen). I definitely recommend Bettersweet Bakery to everyone for both cupcakes and cake for all events!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cakes
Lexie Saladini
Bettersweet Bakery was great to work with. I knew our wedding cake would turn out amazing. We had so many compliments on our cake! (Best birch cake our photographer has seen). I definitely recommend Bettersweet Bakery to everyone for both cupcakes and cake for all events!
Elizabeth Plotka
Delicious cake. Everyone was asking where we got our cake. Very patient and helpful. Thank you for walking the cake up to our car! We look forward to ordering from you many times in the future. Thank you
Paula Carson
Jen and the team at Bettersweet are the absolute best! What I wanted for a birthday cake was unusual and not everyone’s cup of tea. Jen took my ideas and made a cake so beautiful I didn’t want to cut it! Not only was the cake gorgeous- it tasted amazing. She also decorated the cupcakes inspired by the cake theme. I wish I had found Bettersweet much earlier. I can’t recommend them enough!
Sarah-Lyn Patrick
Jenn has been amazing. She tracked me down by phone when my email suddenly started restricting her communications. She adjust pick up times and overall had amazing responses. The cake was just what we wanted and was amazing!
Love the variety of goodies. Highly recommend for cupcakes and special treats.
Blown away! I was in need of desserts for my little guy’s first birthday. We were having a large group and had allergies to consider. Ordering online was a breeze and I loved having the option to order GF/DF desserts. Everyone loved the cupcakes, sugar cookies, and scones! Cannot recommend Bettersweet Bakery enough!
Not a fan of butter cream except for Bettersweet's. It's heavenly. Cake is moist and the prices are unbeatable. We have to get scrape scraps whenever we are in town!
Thank you Curt and Jen for making the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake. Although there are many new options for wedding desserts, a traditional wedding cake was something I knew I wanted to still have. It was such a pleasure working with Jen and letting her take over the design of the cake. I knew I wanted a white cake with tiers, but other than that I let her take the lead of the overall design. I have had the joy of indulging in her wedding cakes in the past, for my sisters wedding and another good friends wedding, so I knew the actual taste was going to be fabulous. During our first meeting, she made a sample of the flavors we chose: vanilla bean cake w/ raspberry compote & vanilla creme fillings, vanilla bean butter frosting. No need to try any other combos; this was it. I dream about this cake. Even though the bakery is in Plymouth, there was no hesitation about taking on our wedding in Milwaukee. Thanks for making our wedding that more special with your delicious cake!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bettersweet Bakery provided our wedding cake and cupcakes on September 7th 2024!
Very professional, accommodating, and wonderful service! Our wedding cake was TO DIE FOR!! So delicious and worth every penny. Highly recommend the "Lemon" cake, with "Raspberry Compote" filling and Bettersweets Signature Buttercream frosting. Yum!!
We didn't have any cupcakes but we're guessing everyone loved them, they were all gone! 12 Dozen!
Highly Recommend!!! ?
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have never been disappointed with anything I've tried at Bettersweet! From brunch breads to cupcake samplers to scraps, everything has been delicious, flavorful, moist and amazing! You can tell things are made with care! The unique flavor combinations always surprise me, they're so good! I can't figure out which is my favorite, as I haven't met one I didnt like!
Very poor communication. Wedding date was beginning of June and delivery and cupcakes were fine, but even before the order getting a response back took 1-2 weeks. I’ve now been emailing them regarding a refund of deposit since June 12th and still have not received our deposit back. I’ve tried calling as well and they tell me it should be a day or two response but then don’t get one for weeks. There was about a month time with zero responses back from the owner. Last response from them was 7/29 and now again 12 days without a response.
Food: 4
Service: 1
We use to get this cake at work and Brenda would pick it up for us....This is the best tasting and looking cakes I ever had in my life! Even better than Simma's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Quite literally the best cupcakes I have ever had in my life. -German chocolate -raspberry lemon the filling is EVERYTHING
Bettersweet Bakery was great to work with. I knew our wedding cake would turn out amazing. We had so many compliments on our cake! (Best birch cake our photographer has seen). I definitely recommend Bettersweet Bakery to everyone for both cupcakes and cake for all events!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cakes
Restaurantji Recommends
Bettersweet Bakery was great to work with. I knew our wedding cake would turn out amazing. We had so many compliments on our cake! (Best birch cake our photographer has seen). I definitely recommend Bettersweet Bakery to everyone for both cupcakes and cake for all events!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cakes
Bettersweet Bakery was great to work with. I knew our wedding cake would turn out amazing. We had so many compliments on our cake! (Best birch cake our photographer has seen). I definitely recommend Bettersweet Bakery to everyone for both cupcakes and cake for all events!
Delicious cake. Everyone was asking where we got our cake. Very patient and helpful. Thank you for walking the cake up to our car! We look forward to ordering from you many times in the future. Thank you
Jen and the team at Bettersweet are the absolute best! What I wanted for a birthday cake was unusual and not everyone’s cup of tea. Jen took my ideas and made a cake so beautiful I didn’t want to cut it! Not only was the cake gorgeous- it tasted amazing. She also decorated the cupcakes inspired by the cake theme. I wish I had found Bettersweet much earlier. I can’t recommend them enough!
Jenn has been amazing. She tracked me down by phone when my email suddenly started restricting her communications. She adjust pick up times and overall had amazing responses. The cake was just what we wanted and was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cakes
Loading...