It was our first visit to their new location on Main Street. We were favorably impressed with the atmosphere, service and overall dining experience. We shared the pear and spinach salad and the Halibut with risotto. The cuisine was scrumptious. The presentation eye appealing. We look forward to returning soon.
Michelle Maiochi Mazon
The new location at Main Street is modern, vibrant, and cozy. It has a covered parking garage, so it doesn’t matter if it is raining or snowing. Drinks are great and food delicious. I can not decide which one is my favorite dish, but for sure it would be one with the “polenta”. The cheesecake with coconut is to die for. If you are not from Wisconsin, ask for the Old fashion drink to taste a little bit of the local flavors. Wednesday is a great day for half price wine bottles. And Sundays have an extra “gastro pub” menu. If you go with a group, I recommend order different dishes and share, so you can try a bit of everything.
Tracy Swiatek
Fabulous food. Great atmosphere. Worth the price.
Layna Lutz
So happy I came here to visit from out of town! Nev offered THE BEST service tonight and had awesome suggestions! Thank you for making my experience here an unforgettable one!
S. G.
Very good service with fine food.
Rob Moore
I had the pleasure of being served by Nev at Butcher and Barrel, and she was absolutely outstanding!
From the moment we sat down, she was incredibly attentive, friendly, and professional. Nev made sure we had everything we needed without ever being intrusive.
Her timing was perfect, and she had great knowledge of the menu, offering thoughtful suggestions that made our meal even better. It's clear she truly cares about her guests and takes pride in her service.
Thank you, Nev, for making our experience so enjoyable you're a gem!
Robert
I had the pleasure of being served by Nev at Butcher and Barrel, and she was absolutely outstanding! From the moment we sat down, she was incredibly attentive, friendly, and professional. Nev made sure we had everything we needed without ever being intrusive. Her timing was perfect, and she had great knowledge of the menu, offering thoughtful suggestions that made our meal even better. It's clear she truly cares about her guests and takes pride in her service. Thank you, Nev, for making our experience so enjoyable you're a gem!
KERI
The waitress was wonderful and attentive! The food was out of this world! I had the pork and it was the best I have ever had! Everyone enjoy their meals. I love the building it is in with the brick sides and open ceiling! Best place ever!
Katie
Waste of 2 hours of a night. This restaurant doesn't deserve any more of my time with a review. They know it was horrible and should have rectified it when we were there
Great food and location. Only negative was the time it took to get our food. Our server gave us a heads up so we weren't caught off guard. Seems like the restaurant could use a couple more staff in the kitchen/bar on a Saturday night.
Joyce
I'm really sorry to say that our experience at Butcher and Barrel was far below expectations. We had been several weeks prior and had a great experience, however this last visit was very disappointing. The main issue was the service. Maybe our server was just having a bad day but her service was not good at all. She got one of the dinner orders wrong. She never checked on our table. She did not bring steak knives to our guests who ordered meat dishes, and just didn't seem to care. I could empathize if it was a crowded restaurant but there weren't that many tables of people and other servers working that night. The food also had issues. Most of the sides such as the risotto, potatoes, and quinoa were too salty and the fish was over cooked. It's such a nice location downtown. We really hope that things will improve.
Jerry
Excellent service with very pleasant atmosphere. Shrimp appetizer very well presented and excellent taste. All of the food was appropriately prepared to our request. Portions were appropriate. Wine selections complimented that food choices. 
Moreen
We had a lovely experience. The food was amazing, and the four of us enjoyed a few hours of food and conversation that we cherish. The people who served our meal were professional and attentive. The kitchen seemed to be somewhat slow, likely due to trying to accommodate larger parties and a restaurant filled to capacity for well over two hours. I highly recommend Butcher and Barrel, and I know that experience in their new, larger venue will soon have that kitchen humming again!
DarrylB
As always great food and service. We tried some of the new menu items and really liked them.
such good food!
It was our first visit to their new location on Main Street. We were favorably impressed with the atmosphere, service and overall dining experience. We shared the pear and spinach salad and the Halibut with risotto. The cuisine was scrumptious. The presentation eye appealing. We look forward to returning soon.
The new location at Main Street is modern, vibrant, and cozy. It has a covered parking garage, so it doesn’t matter if it is raining or snowing. Drinks are great and food delicious.
I can not decide which one is my favorite dish, but for sure it would be one with the “polenta”. The cheesecake with coconut is to die for. If you are not from Wisconsin, ask for the Old fashion drink to taste a little bit of the local flavors. Wednesday is a great day for half price wine bottles. And Sundays have an extra “gastro pub” menu. If you go with a group, I recommend order different dishes and share, so you can try a bit of everything.
Fabulous food. Great atmosphere. Worth the price.
So happy I came here to visit from out of town! Nev offered THE BEST service tonight and had awesome suggestions! Thank you for making my experience here an unforgettable one!
Very good service with fine food.
I had the pleasure of being served by Nev at Butcher and Barrel, and she was absolutely outstanding!
From the moment we sat down, she was incredibly attentive, friendly, and professional. Nev made sure we had everything we needed without ever being intrusive.
Her timing was perfect, and she had great knowledge of the menu, offering thoughtful suggestions that made our meal even better. It's clear she truly cares about her guests and takes pride in her service.
Thank you, Nev, for making our experience so enjoyable you're a gem!
I had the pleasure of being served by Nev at Butcher and Barrel, and she was absolutely outstanding! From the moment we sat down, she was incredibly attentive, friendly, and professional. Nev made sure we had everything we needed without ever being intrusive. Her timing was perfect, and she had great knowledge of the menu, offering thoughtful suggestions that made our meal even better. It's clear she truly cares about her guests and takes pride in her service. Thank you, Nev, for making our experience so enjoyable you're a gem!
The waitress was wonderful and attentive! The food was out of this world! I had the pork and it was the best I have ever had! Everyone enjoy their meals. I love the building it is in with the brick sides and open ceiling! Best place ever!
Waste of 2 hours of a night. This restaurant doesn't deserve any more of my time with a review. They know it was horrible and should have rectified it when we were there
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food and location. Only negative was the time it took to get our food. Our server gave us a heads up so we weren't caught off guard. Seems like the restaurant could use a couple more staff in the kitchen/bar on a Saturday night.
I'm really sorry to say that our experience at Butcher and Barrel was far below expectations. We had been several weeks prior and had a great experience, however this last visit was very disappointing. The main issue was the service. Maybe our server was just having a bad day but her service was not good at all. She got one of the dinner orders wrong. She never checked on our table. She did not bring steak knives to our guests who ordered meat dishes, and just didn't seem to care. I could empathize if it was a crowded restaurant but there weren't that many tables of people and other servers working that night. The food also had issues. Most of the sides such as the risotto, potatoes, and quinoa were too salty and the fish was over cooked. It's such a nice location downtown. We really hope that things will improve.
Excellent service with very pleasant atmosphere. Shrimp appetizer very well presented and excellent taste. All of the food was appropriately prepared to our request. Portions were appropriate. Wine selections complimented that food choices. 
We had a lovely experience. The food was amazing, and the four of us enjoyed a few hours of food and conversation that we cherish. The people who served our meal were professional and attentive. The kitchen seemed to be somewhat slow, likely due to trying to accommodate larger parties and a restaurant filled to capacity for well over two hours. I highly recommend Butcher and Barrel, and I know that experience in their new, larger venue will soon have that kitchen humming again!
As always great food and service. We tried some of the new menu items and really liked them.
Loading...